Hypernymy Detection for Low-Resource Languages via Meta Learning

Changlong Yu, Jialong Han, Haisong Zhang, Wilfred NgACL 2020 · OpenReview

Abstract: Changlong Yu, Jialong Han, Haisong Zhang, Wilfred Ng. Proceedings of the 58th Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics.

2020.

Introduction

Hypernymy detection—the task of identifying "is-a" relationships, such as recognizing that "crimson" is a type of "red"—is a fundamental component of natural language processing (NLP). It underpins the construction of taxonomies and the understanding of lexical entailment. While high-resource languages like English benefit from massive datasets, developing similar resources for other languages is labor-intensive and costly.

Traditional methods, such as Hearst patterns (e.g., "X such as Y"), are highly language-dependent and do not generalize well across different linguistic structures. Modern machine learning models, while powerful, typically require substantial training data. In low-resource scenarios, these models often fail to capture linguistic nuances or suffer from overfitting, where they memorize small training sets rather than learning generalizable patterns. This research explores how to leverage high-resource data to improve performance in languages with minimal available data.

Methodology

The authors evaluate three joint training paradigms using a Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP) base model with concatenated word embeddings as input. To bridge the gap between languages, they utilize MUSE, an unsupervised word translation technique, to project all embeddings into a shared English-centric feature space.

  1. Cross-lingual Training: Training on a combination of English and one specific low-resource language.
  2. Multilingual Training: Merging datasets from all eight languages (EN, FR, ZH, FI, IT, TH, JA, EL) into a single training pool.
  3. Meta-Learning (MAML): Utilizing Model-Agnostic Meta-Learning to treat each language as a separate task. The goal is to find a model initialization that can adapt to any language with minimal gradient steps.

The datasets are categorized by resource availability: High-Resource (EN), Moderately Low-Resource (FR, ZH, FI, IT), and Extremely Low-Resource (TH, JA, EL).

Key Insights: Stability and Generalization

A critical finding is that multilingual training can be detrimental to extremely low-resource languages. While it aids moderately low-resource languages, the model tends to master the high-resource data and subsequently overfit the tiny datasets of languages like Thai or Greek.

Comparison of development loss between multilingual training (top) and meta-learning (bottom).

As shown in the loss curves above, meta-learning provides a significantly more stable descending trend for development loss. In contrast, standard multilingual training often results in "spiky" or erratic loss on small datasets, indicating poor generalization. Meta-learning succeeds by seeking a "ready-to-learn" initialization rather than a static "one-size-fits-all" solution.

Experimental Results

The meta-learning approach, specifically the Finetune variant, consistently outperformed other paradigms across all seven low-resource languages.

Accuracy results across different training methods for low-resource languages.

Significant gains were observed in extremely low-resource settings. For instance, in Greek (EL), accuracy improved from .653 (Multilingual) to .734 (Meta-Learning). Similarly, Thai (TH) saw an increase from .657 to .709. The meta-learning framework effectively prevents the performance drop-off typically seen when introducing extremely small datasets into standard training pipelines.

Conclusion and Future Work

This study demonstrates that meta-learning is a robust framework for hypernymy detection in low-resource settings. However, limitations remain. The method assumes structural similarity (isomorphism) between embedding spaces, which may not hold for very dissimilar languages. Future research could explore the integration of contextualized embeddings (e.g., BERT) or zero-shot multilingual pre-training to further enhance performance without requiring target-language hypernymy data.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{yu2020hypernymy,
  author = {Changlong Yu and Jialong Han and Haisong Zhang and Wilfred Ng},
  title = {{Hypernymy Detection for Low-Resource Languages via Meta Learning}},
  booktitle = {Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=d0rqRYv20cI},
}
Figure