Hypercoordinate iodine for catalytic asymmetric diamination of styrene: insights into the mechanism, role of solvent, and stereoinduction

A. Sreenithya, Christopher M. Hadad, Raghavan B. SunojChemical 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses computational methods to unravel the intricate mechanism of asymmetric diamination of styrene catalyzed by hypercoordinate iodine. It reveals how the chiral catalyst, solvent additives like HFIP, and specific interactions dictate the stereochemical outcome, providing a valuable model for designing similar catalytic systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Synthesizing vicinal diamines, crucial building blocks in pharmaceuticals and natural products, is a significant challenge in organic chemistry. While metal-catalyzed methods exist, metal-free approaches using hypercoordinate iodine have gained traction due to their milder conditions and environmental benefits. Specifically, the asymmetric diamination of styrene using chiral hypercoordinate iodine catalysts has shown promise, but the precise mechanistic details and the origin of stereoselectivity have remained unclear. This paper aims to elucidate these aspects, focusing on the role of the catalyst's chiral environment, solvent effects, and the precise steps leading to the formation of a specific enantiomer of the diamine product.

Methods

The researchers employed density functional theory (DFT) calculations to investigate the reaction mechanism. Key computational techniques included:

  • Geometry Optimization: Using the M06-2X functional with the 6-31G** basis set (and SDD for iodine) to find the lowest energy structures of reactants, intermediates, and transition states.
  • Solvation Models: The SMD continuum solvation model was used to account for solvent effects, with specific attention paid to the mixture of MTBE and hexafluoroisopropanol (HFIP). HFIP was also treated explicitly in some stationary points to capture specific interactions.
  • Transition State Verification: Intrinsic reaction coordinate (IRC) calculations were used to confirm that the identified transition states connect the correct reactants and products.
  • Atoms In Molecule (AIM) Analysis: Used to identify bond paths and weak interatomic interactions.
  • Natural Bond Orbital (NBO) Analysis: Employed to understand electron delocalization and charge distributions.
  • Activation-Strain Model: Utilized to quantify the contributions of reactant distortion and interaction energies to the activation barrier, particularly for stereoselective steps.

The computational setup was validated by comparing results obtained with different basis sets and functionals, and by referencing previous studies using similar methodologies for hypercoordinate iodine catalysis.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on theoretical calculations rather than experimental data analysis or the development of new datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Mechanism Unveiled: The study details a catalytic cycle involving the formation of a catalyst-substrate complex, displacement of an imidate ligand, and subsequent nucleophilic attack by the displaced imidate on the styrene double bond to form an iodonium ion intermediate.
  • HFIP's Crucial Role: Explicit interaction of the imidate ion with HFIP significantly lowers the activation barrier for iodonium ion formation, highlighting the importance of this solvent additive in facilitating the reaction.
  • Chiral Environment Dictates Selectivity: The P helical fold of the chiral arms of the iodoresorcinol catalyst creates a specific chiral environment. This environment influences how the styrene molecule approaches the catalyst.
  • Facial Selectivity: The catalyst preferentially binds styrene through its si prochiral face over the re face, leading to enhanced catalyst-substrate interaction and a more favorable orientation for subsequent reactions.
  • Polarization is Key: Coordination of the styrene double bond to the iodine catalyst polarizes the double bond, making the benzylic carbon more electrophilic and thus a preferred site for nucleophilic attack. This polarization is further modulated by the chiral environment.
  • Stereoelectronic Control: The si face binding leads to a staggered arrangement of the styrene double bond, which is more polarized and facilitates a lower energy transition state for nucleophilic addition, ultimately directing the formation of the S enantiomer.

Key Results

  • The energetically preferred catalytic pathway was identified, involving key mechanistic events like catalyst-substrate complex formation and imidate rebound.
  • HFIP-assisted nucleophilic addition exhibits a barrier that is 3.5 kcal mol⁻¹ lower than the unassisted pathway.
  • The si face catalyst-substrate complex (C1si) is energetically favored over the re face complex (C1re) by 1.8 kcal mol⁻¹.
  • The transition state for nucleophilic addition to the re face (leading to the S enantiomer) is 3.1 kcal mol⁻¹ lower in energy than that for addition to the si face (leading to the R enantiomer).
  • The computed enantiomeric excess (ee) based on the stereoselective transition states is 98%, which is in good agreement with the experimental observation of 94%.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Model: While DFT calculations provide valuable mechanistic insights, they are approximations of reality. The accuracy of the results depends on the chosen functionals and basis sets.
  • Experimental Validation: The study is primarily theoretical. Further experimental validation of the proposed mechanistic steps and the role of HFIP would strengthen the conclusions.
  • Broader Applicability: The authors suggest that the stereoselective model developed in this study can be extended to other related asymmetric styrene difunctionalizations and potentially to internal alkenes. Future work could explore these extensions.
  • Further Refinement of Interactions: While noncovalent interactions were analyzed, a deeper understanding of their precise contribution to the energy differences could be explored.

Summary updated

Abstract

Hypercoordinate iodine has evolved as an impressive class of catalysts for various organic transformations. Extension of this idea to asymmetric applications, such as in the asymmetric difunctionalization of styrene or its derivatives, constitutes an important reaction. In this study, the mechanism and origin of stereoinduction in styrene diamination, with a sulfonimide (HNMs<sub>2</sub>) as the diaminating agent and iodoresorcinol (((iPr)<sub>2</sub>N(CO)-CH(Me)-O)<sub>2</sub>Ar-I) based chiral hypercoordinate iodine as the catalyst, are investigated using density functional theory calculations. The energetically preferred catalytic pathway has been found to involve, among other steps, two very important mechanistic events: (a) the formation of a catalyst-substrate complex by the action of styrene on the catalyst ArI(NMs<sub>2</sub>)<sub>2</sub>, resulting in the displacement of one of the imidates (NMs<sub>2</sub> <sup>-</sup>); and (b) a rebound of the departed imidate on the iodine-bound styrene to form an iodonium ion intermediate with a N-C bond. Explicit interaction of the imidate ion with hexafluoroisopropanol (HFIP), used as a solvent additive, lowers the barrier for the formation of the iodonium ion. The <i>P</i> helical fold of the chiral arms of the iodoresorcinol catalyst is found to offer a chiral environment for the reactants. Coordination of the iodine catalyst to the styrene double bond is found to make the benzylic carbon more electrophilic and hence makes it the preferred site for the nucleophilic addition. In the chiral environment of the catalyst, an enhanced polarization of the styrene double bond is noticed when the double bond coordinates through the <i>si</i> prochiral face than the <i>re</i> face. Nucleophilic addition on the <i>re</i> face of the catalyst-substrate complex is associated with a lower activation barrier leading to the experimentally observed <i>S</i> enantiomeric product. The stereoselective model developed in this study can be employed to related asymmetric styrene difunctionalizations using similar hypercoordinate iodine catalysts.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sreenithya2019hypercoordinate,
  author = {A. Sreenithya and Christopher M. Hadad and Raghavan B. Sunoj},
  title = {{Hypercoordinate iodine for catalytic asymmetric diamination of styrene: insights into the mechanism, role of solvent, and stereoinduction}},
  booktitle = {Chemical},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1039/c9sc01513b},
}
Figure