Hydroxyl on Stepped Copper and its Interaction with Water

Kallum Mistry, Henry Snowden, George R. Darling, A. HodgsonThe Journal of Physical Chemistry C 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how water and hydroxyl groups interact on a stepped copper surface (Cu(511)), revealing specific structural arrangements and their stability. Understanding these interactions is crucial for designing more efficient copper-based catalysts for important chemical reactions like CO2 reduction.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The behavior of water and hydroxyl groups on catalyst surfaces is fundamental to many chemical processes, yet it's incredibly complex to study. Hydrogen bonding creates intricate structures that are easily perturbed by experimental conditions. While much is known about these interactions on flat (plane) metal surfaces, the role of surface steps – which are abundant in real-world catalysts – is less understood. This paper aims to bridge this knowledge gap by examining the specific structures formed when oxygen reacts with water on a stepped copper surface (Cu(511)) and comparing it to what's observed on flat copper surfaces. This is particularly relevant as copper is a key catalyst for reactions like CO2 electroreduction, where surface structure plays a critical role in product selectivity.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach combining experimental and theoretical techniques:

  • Thermal Desorption Spectroscopy (TPD): This technique was used to study the stability and decomposition of different water/hydroxyl phases on the copper surface by monitoring the gases released as the surface is heated.
  • Scanning Tunneling Microscopy (STM): STM provided atomic-scale images of the surface structures, allowing researchers to visualize the arrangement of water and hydroxyl molecules. They used low-temperature STM to image these fragile structures.
  • Low-Energy Electron Diffraction (LEED): LEED was used to probe the ordering and symmetry of the surface structures, complementing the real-space imaging from STM.
  • Density Functional Theory (DFT) Calculations: DFT was employed to model the adsorption energies and structures of various possible configurations of hydroxyl and water on the stepped copper surface. This theoretical work was crucial for interpreting the experimental observations and understanding the underlying bonding.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Steps Matter: The presence of steps on the copper surface significantly influences how water and hydroxyl groups arrange themselves, leading to distinct structures compared to flat surfaces.
  • Ordered Chains Form: When oxygen reacts with water on the stepped surface, it forms well-defined 1D chains of mixed hydroxyl-water structures. These chains are stabilized by hydrogen bonds and bind across adjacent copper steps.
  • OH Prefers Bridge Sites: Hydroxyl groups preferentially adsorb at the bridge sites on the close-packed copper steps, with their hydrogen atoms pointing outwards.
  • Structural Analogies: The observed hydroxyl and mixed hydroxyl-water structures on the stepped copper surface are remarkably similar to those found on flat copper and nickel surfaces. This suggests a common structural motif driven by the presence of low-coordination metal sites and the ability of these sites to accept protons from water.
  • Trimer Formation: Pure hydroxyl phases, after excess water desorbs, can form H-bonded trimers that bridge between two copper steps, indicating a tendency for OH groups to form networks even in the absence of water.

Key Results

  • Two Main Phases: Upon heating the hydroxyl/water layer, two distinct phases are observed: a 1OH:1H2O phase and a pure OH phase.
  • 1OH:1H2O Structure: This phase consists of zigzag chains of water along the terrace, stabilized by hydrogen bonds to OH groups adsorbed in the step bridge sites. These chains have a double periodicity along the step direction.
  • Pure OH Phase: At higher temperatures (around 210 K), the mixed phase decomposes to leave OH adsorbed in the Cu step bridge site. Some of these OH groups form H-bonded trimers.
  • OH Disproportionation: At even higher temperatures (around 300 K), hydroxyl groups disproportionate, releasing water and leaving behind chemisorbed oxygen.
  • DFT Confirmation: DFT calculations successfully predicted the preferred adsorption sites for OH and provided insights into the stability of the observed hydroxyl-water structures, aligning well with STM observations.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that distinguishing between monomers and dimers of OH on the surface is challenging due to similar STM contrast. They also note that the precise proton orientation within some H-bonded structures is at the limit of DFT precision and cannot be definitively determined by STM alone.

Future work could explore the influence of different step densities and terrace widths on these structures. Further investigation into the role of these specific OH/water arrangements in catalytic reactions, particularly in the context of CO2 electroreduction, would be highly valuable. The paper also suggests that understanding how these H-bond networks modulate OH reactivity is crucial for designing better catalysts.

Summary updated

Abstract

We describe the hydroxyl and mixed hydroxyl-water structures formed on a stepped copper surface following the reaction of adsorbed O with water at a low temperature and compare them to the structures found previously on plane copper surfaces. Thermal desorption profiles, STM, and low-energy electron diffraction show that water reacts with O at temperatures below 130 K on Cu(511). Two well-defined phases appear as the OH/H<sub>2</sub>O layer is heated to desorb excess water, a 1OH:1H<sub>2</sub>O phase and a pure OH phase. The 1OH:1H<sub>2</sub>O structure consists of 1D chains binding across two adjacent copper steps, with a double period along the step. Electronic structure calculations show that the structure has a zigzag chain of water along the terrace, stabilized by hydrogen bonds to OH groups adsorbed in the step bridge sites. This structure binds OH in its favored site and is similar to the structure observed on other open faces of Cu and Ni, suggesting that this structural arrangement may be common on other surfaces that have steps or rows of close packed metal atoms. The hydroxyl/water chains decompose at 210 K to leave OH adsorbed in the Cu step bridge site, with some forming H-bonded trimers that bridge between two Cu steps. Heating the surface causes hydroxyl to disproportionate near 300 K, desorbing water to leave chemisorbed O.
BibTeX
@article{mistry2024hydroxyl,
  author = {Kallum Mistry and Henry Snowden and George R. Darling and A. Hodgson},
  title = {{Hydroxyl on Stepped Copper and its Interaction with Water}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physical Chemistry C},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.jpcc.4c04091},
}
Figure