Hydrogen Dynamics in Na3AlH6: A Combined Density Functional Theory and Quasielastic Neutron Scattering Study

Johannes Voss, Qing Shi, H. Jacobsen, Michaela Zamponi, Kim Lefmann, Tejs VeggeThe Journal of Physical Chemistry B 2007 · DOI

TL;DR

This study combines theoretical calculations (DFT) and experimental neutron scattering (QENS) to understand how hydrogen moves within the complex hydride Na₃AlH₆, a potential hydrogen storage material. They found that hydrogen diffusion is primarily a slow, localized process mediated by vacancies, and that titanium doping, contrary to some hypotheses, doesn't significantly improve bulk hydrogen diffusion.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The quest for efficient hydrogen storage materials for applications like fuel cell vehicles is a major challenge. Complex hydrides, such as sodium alanate (NaAlH₄ and its decomposition product Na₃AlH₆), are promising candidates due to their high hydrogen content. However, their practical use is hindered by slow hydrogen absorption and release kinetics. Titanium doping has been proposed as a way to enhance these kinetics, with one hypothesis suggesting it improves hydrogen's ability to move through the bulk material. This paper aims to clarify the fundamental mechanisms of hydrogen diffusion in Na₃AlH₆, both undoped and titanium-doped, to understand the role of titanium and identify pathways for improving hydrogen storage performance.

Methods

The researchers employed a powerful combination of two key techniques:

  • Density Functional Theory (DFT): This is a computational quantum mechanical modeling method used to predict the electronic structure and properties of materials. Here, DFT was used to calculate:
  • The energies required for hydrogen to move between different sites (activation energies).
  • The preferred locations for titanium atoms when doped into the Na₃AlH₆ structure.
  • The dynamics of hydrogen vacancies, which are crucial for understanding diffusion.
  • They utilized the nudged elastic band (NEB) and adaptive nudged elastic band (ANEB) methods to accurately map out the minimum energy pathways for diffusion and identify transition states.
  • Quasielastic Neutron Scattering (QENS): This is an experimental technique that probes the dynamics of atoms and molecules in materials by measuring how neutrons scatter off them.
  • QENS is particularly sensitive to hydrogen due to its large incoherent scattering cross-section.
  • The technique measures the energy and momentum transfer of scattered neutrons, providing information about the speed and length scales of atomic motion.
  • The data was analyzed using models like the Chudley-Elliott model to extract parameters such as hydrogen jump lengths and diffusion rates.

The synergy between these methods is key: DFT provides atomistic insights into energy barriers and pathways, while QENS offers experimental validation of these dynamics on a macroscopic scale.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical calculations and experimental measurements on synthesized samples.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Vacancy-Mediated, Localized Diffusion: The dominant mechanism for hydrogen movement in Na₃AlH₆ is not free diffusion but rather a "hopping" process mediated by hydrogen vacancies. These jumps are localized within specific structural units, rather than enabling rapid, long-range transport.
  • High Activation Energies for Bulk Diffusion: Long-range bulk diffusion of hydrogen in Na₃AlH₆ requires significant activation energy, making it a slow process under typical operating conditions.
  • Limited Mobile Hydrogen Fraction: Even at elevated temperatures (350 K), only a small fraction of hydrogen atoms are mobile, further contributing to slow diffusion rates.
  • Titanium's Role is Not Bulk Diffusion Enhancement: Contrary to some hypotheses, bulk-substituted titanium does not appear to significantly improve hydrogen diffusion. While titanium can lower local vacancy formation energies, it doesn't translate to faster overall hydrogen transport.
  • Alternative Explanation for Low-Temperature Dynamics: The paper proposes that previously observed low-temperature point defect motion (around 70 K) in sodium alanate might be due to vacancy-mediated sodium diffusion, rather than hydrogen diffusion, as the activation energies for hydrogen diffusion are found to be much higher.

Key Results

  • DFT Calculations:
    • Formation energy of hydrogen interstitials is very high (2.42 eV).
  • Hydrogen vacancy formation energy in undoped Na₃AlH₆ is 1.54 eV.
  • Titanium substitution for aluminum (Ti@Al) has a substitution energy of 0.95 eV.
  • Localized hydrogen diffusion paths in undoped Na₃AlH₆ have activation energies around 0.41 eV and jump lengths of 2.50 Å.
  • Long-range diffusion in Ti-doped Na₃AlH₆ has a calculated barrier of 0.36 eV.
  • Long-range diffusion in undoped Na₃AlH₆ has activation energies of at least 0.75 eV.
  • QENS Experiments:
    • For undoped Na₃AlH₆ at 390 K, a hydrogen jump length of 2.80 Å and an inverse jump rate of 2.35 ns were determined, corresponding to an activation energy of 0.37 eV and a mobile fraction of 13%.
  • For Ti-doped Na₃AlH₆ at 350 K, an activation energy of 0.31 eV and a mobile fraction of only 2% were found.
  • No significant hydrogen dynamics were observed below 250 K in QENS experiments, suggesting activation barriers below ~0.3 eV are unlikely for hydrogen.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Localized vs. Long-Range Diffusion Ambiguity: While the QENS data shows a broadening consistent with a Chudley-Elliott model (often associated with long-range diffusion), the DFT results strongly suggest localized dynamics. The authors highlight that an independent QENS analysis might have incorrectly concluded long-range diffusion without the DFT insights.
  • Low-Temperature Defect Motion: The paper proposes sodium diffusion as a potential explanation for low-temperature anelastic spectroscopy signals, but acknowledges that more work is needed to definitively clarify this.
  • Titanium's Precise Role: While bulk substitution is deemed unlikely to improve hydrogen diffusion, the exact role of titanium in enhancing kinetics remains somewhat elusive, possibly involving surface effects or other mechanisms not explored in this bulk diffusion study.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further investigation into the role of sodium diffusion and other non-hydrogen species in low-temperature defect motion. They also imply that understanding surface phenomena might be crucial for fully grasping titanium's catalytic effect.

Summary updated

Abstract

Understanding the elusive catalytic role of titanium-based additives on the reversible hydrogenation of complex hydrides is an essential step toward developing hydrogen storage materials for the transport sector. Improved bulk diffusion of hydrogen is one of the proposed effects of doping sodium alanate with TiCl3, and here we study hydrogen dynamics in doped and undoped Na3AlH6 using a combination of density functional theory calculations and quasielastic neutron scattering. The hydrogen dynamics is found to be vacancy mediated and dominated by localized jump events, whereas long-range bulk diffusion requires significant activation. The fraction of mobile hydrogen is found to be small for both undoped and doped Na3AlH6, even at 350 K, and improved hydrogen diffusion as a result of bulk-substituted titanium is found to be unlikely. We also propose that previously detected low-temperature point defect motion in sodium alanate could result from vacancy-mediated sodium diffusion.
BibTeX
@article{voss2007hydrogen,
  author = {Johannes Voss and Qing Shi and H. Jacobsen and Michaela Zamponi and Kim Lefmann and Tejs Vegge},
  title = {{Hydrogen Dynamics in Na<sub>3</sub>AlH<sub>6</sub>: A Combined Density Functional Theory and Quasielastic Neutron Scattering Study}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physical Chemistry B},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.1021/jp0667036},
}
Figure