Hydrochar did not reduce rice paddy NH3 volatilization compared to pyrochar in a soil column experiment

Xiaoyu Liu, Yueqin Cheng, Yang Liu, Danyan Chen, Chen Yin, Yueman WangScientific 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Pyrochar (PC) typically possesses a high pH, and its application can inadvertently increase rice paddy ammonia volatilization (PAV), a primary pathway for nitrogen loss. In contrast, hydrochar (HC) offers higher production rates and generally lower pH values. This study utilized soil column experiments to investigate the effects of PC and HC (derived from wheat straw and sawdust) at two application rates (0.5% and 1.5% w/w) on PAV. Results indicated that HC application did not reduce PAV compared to PC. In fact, total PAV increased significantly with higher HC application rates, particularly for wheat straw hydrochar (WHC). This unexpected increase is attributed to the soil's strong buffering capacity, biochar aging processes, and the high nitrogen content inherent in HC. These findings suggest that hydrochar requires pretreatment before agricultural use to mitigate nitrogen loss.

Introduction

Nitrogen (N) is a critical nutrient for rice production, yet its management remains inefficient. Between 10% and 40% of applied N fertilizer is lost to the atmosphere via paddy ammonia volatilization (PAV), leading to environmental issues like water eutrophication and atmospheric haze. While biochar is often proposed as a solution to enhance N retention, traditional pyrochar (PC)—produced via high-temperature dry pyrolysis—often has an alkaline pH (8–10) that can stimulate $NH_3$ release.

Hydrochar (HC), produced via hydrothermal carbonization (HTC) at lower temperatures in water, typically has an acidic pH (3.5–6.5). Researchers hypothesized that HC’s acidity would neutralize the alkaline conditions in paddy floodwaters, thereby reducing PAV. This study tests this hypothesis in a controlled soil column environment.

Methods

The researchers conducted a soil column experiment using a typical paddy soil (stagnic anthrosol). They compared four biochar types:

  • WPC & SPC: Pyrochar from wheat straw and sawdust (700 °C).
  • WHC & SHC: Hydrochar from wheat straw and sawdust (260 °C).

Treatments included application rates of 0.5% and 1.5% (w/w), alongside a non-biochar control (CKU). Fertilization followed a standard three-stage regime: Basal Fertilizer (BF), Tiller Fertilizer (TF), and Panicle Fertilizer (PF). $NH_3$ fluxes were captured daily for seven days after each fertilization using a continuous air-flow enclosure method. Additionally, chemical "aging" of hydrochar was simulated using $H_2O_2$ to observe pH stability over time.

Results and Discussion

Temporal Dynamics of Ammonia Volatilization

The application of biochar significantly altered the temporal patterns of $NH_3$ emissions. Peaks in volatilization typically occurred 1–3 days after each fertilization event.

Ammonia volatilization rates over time following fertilization events: Basal Fertilizer (BF), Tiller Fertilizer (TF), and Panicle Fertilizer (PF).

Contrary to the initial hypothesis, the lower pH of hydrochar did not translate into reduced emissions. The soil's natural buffering capacity effectively neutralized the initial acidity of the HC. Furthermore, simulation experiments revealed that as HC "ages" in the soil, its pH rises toward neutrality, eliminating any short-term acidification benefits.

The Impact of Labile Nitrogen and Feedstock

A critical factor in the increased PAV observed with hydrochar was the input of labile nitrogen and dissolved organic matter. Hydrochar, particularly when derived from wheat straw (WHC), contains substantially higher levels of water-extractable nitrogen and Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD) compared to pyrochar.

Total Nitrogen (a) and Chemical Oxygen Demand (b) in water extracts of different biochar types, highlighting the high labile content in hydrochars.

The high-rate wheat hydrochar (WHC-1.5%) resulted in the highest cumulative PAV (~19.71 kg N/ha), significantly exceeding the control (~13.26 kg N/ha). This suggests that the addition of HC inadvertently provided more "fuel" for the volatilization process. In contrast, high-rate pyrochar (WPC-1.5%) showed a slight, though non-significant, trend toward reducing total PAV, likely due to its higher stability and lower labile N content.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that "raw" hydrochar is not an effective tool for reducing ammonia volatilization in rice paddies and may even exacerbate nitrogen loss at higher application rates. The failure of HC to suppress PAV is due to a combination of soil buffering, rapid biochar aging, and the introduction of significant amounts of labile nitrogen. For hydrochar to be a viable soil amendment in nitrogen-sensitive environments, future research must focus on stabilization pretreatments, such as pre-aging or chemical modification, to mitigate these adverse effects.

Summary updated

Abstract

Pyrochar (PC) is always with high pH value, and improper application might increase rice paddy ammonia volatilization (PAV), which is the main nitrogen loss through air during rice production. Differently, hydrochar (HC) takes the advantages of high productive rate and always with lower pH value compared with PC. However, effect pattern and mechanism of HC on PAV are still unclear. In the present study, soil column experiments were conducted to investigate the effect of PC and HC application on PAV. In total, treatments with four types of biochar (WPC, SPC, WHC and SHC, i.e., PC and HC prepared with wheat straw and sawdust, respectively) and two application rates (0.5% and 1.5%, w/w) were set up and non-biochar application was used as control. Results showed that, application of HC with low pH value could not reduce PAV compared with PC. Total PAV increased significantly as the increase of HC application rate (especially for WHC). The increment of PAV under high rate HC application might be due to the strong buffer capacity of soil, the aging of biochar, the high nitrogen from HC. The results indicated that HC should be pretreatment before utilization in agricultural environment considering PAV reduction.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2020hydrochar,
  author = {Xiaoyu Liu and Yueqin Cheng and Yang Liu and Danyan Chen and Chen Yin and Yueman Wang},
  title = {{Hydrochar did not reduce rice paddy NH3 volatilization compared to pyrochar in a soil column experiment}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-020-76213-z},
}
Figure