Hybrid Macro-Porous Titanium Ornamented by Degradable 3D Gel/nHA Micro-Scaffolds for Bone Tissue Regeneration

Bo Yin, Pei Ma, Jun Chen, Hai Wang, Gui Wu, Bo Li, Qiang Li, Zhifeng Huang, Guixing Qiu, Zhihong WuInternational Journal of Molecular Sciences 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel approach to enhance bone regeneration by creating hybrid macro-porous titanium scaffolds decorated with degradable gelatin/nano-hydroxyapatite (Gel/nHA) micro-scaffolds. The optimized Gel:nHA ratio of 1:1 significantly improved cell adhesion, proliferation, and differentiation in vitro, and demonstrated superior bone regeneration in a rabbit radius defect model, suggesting a promising clinical application for treating critical-sized bone defects.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Bone defects, particularly critical-sized ones resulting from trauma or tumor removal, pose a significant challenge in clinical practice. While autologous bone grafts are the gold standard, they come with drawbacks like donor-site morbidity and limited availability. Allogeneic bone grafts also have limitations, including immunogenicity and disease transmission. Tissue-engineered bone substitutes are a promising alternative, but many face issues such as insufficient mechanical strength and a mismatch between material degradation and new bone formation. Porous titanium is a well-established material for bone implants due to its mechanical properties and biocompatibility. However, its bio-inert nature limits its osteointegration capacity, necessitating modifications to promote bone growth. Existing modifications often focus on the 2D surface of the porous structure, leaving a gap in optimizing the 3D internal architecture for enhanced bone regeneration.

Methods

The researchers developed a novel method to create hybrid scaffolds by incorporating 3D micro-scaffolds within the pores of macro-porous titanium. This was achieved by preparing mixtures of gelatin (Gel) and nano-hydroxyapatite (nHA) in three different ratios: 1:0, 1:1, and 1:3. These mixtures were then used to fill the pores of pre-fabricated porous titanium scaffolds, followed by chemical crosslinking with glutaraldehyde and freeze-drying.

The study employed a multi-faceted approach to evaluate the performance of these hybrid scaffolds:

  • In vitro assessments:
    • Cell attachment and proliferation: MC3T3-E1 pre-osteoblast cells were cultured on the scaffolds, and their morphology was observed using Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM). Cell proliferation was quantified using a CCK-8 assay, and cell seeding efficiency was assessed via DAPI staining and ImageJ analysis.
  • Cell differentiation: Osteogenic differentiation was evaluated by measuring the expression of key markers such as alkaline phosphatase (ALP), collagen type 1 (Col-1), and osteocalcin (OCN) at both protein (ELISA) and gene (RT-PCR) levels. Vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) was also assessed as an angiogenic marker.
  • In vivo assessments:
    • Animal model: A critical-sized radius defect model was created in rabbits.
  • Bone regeneration: After 12 weeks, bone regeneration was quantitatively assessed using micro-CT scans to determine the percentage of bone volume within the total volume (BV/TV).
  • Histological analysis: Histomorphometry and Van Gieson staining were performed to examine the interface between bone and titanium, bone morphology, and the extent of new bone formation.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized commercially available cell lines (MC3T3-E1) and materials.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • 3D Micro-Scaffolding within Macro-Pores: The core innovation is the creation of a hierarchical structure where degradable micro-scaffolds are integrated within the existing macro-porous titanium structure. This goes beyond surface modifications to optimize the internal 3D environment for bone growth.
  • Synergistic Effect of Gelatin and Nano-Hydroxyapatite: The study highlights that a specific ratio of Gel:nHA (1:1) is crucial for optimal performance. This suggests a synergistic interaction between the biodegradable, cell-friendly gelatin and the osteoconductive nano-hydroxyapatite.
  • Optimizing Pore Structure for Cell Behavior: The Gel:nHA = 1:1 ratio resulted in a multi-hierarchical pore structure with an average pore size (156 ± 86 µm) that was found to be most conducive to cell adhesion, proliferation, and differentiation, mimicking natural bone more closely than other ratios.
  • Translational Potential: The successful demonstration of enhanced bone regeneration in a clinically relevant animal model (rabbit radius defect) strongly suggests the potential for this hybrid scaffold to be translated into clinical applications for treating bone defects.

Key Results

  • In Vitro:
    • The Gel:nHA = 1:1 hybrid scaffold group showed significantly enhanced cell adhesion and proliferation compared to other groups and the control. Cells exhibited elongated and plump morphology with abundant filopodias.
  • Osteogenic marker expression (ALP, Col-1, OCN) was significantly upregulated in the Gel:nHA = 1:1 group at both protein and gene levels.
  • The Gel:nHA = 1:1 group demonstrated the best performance in vitro.
  • In Vivo:
    • After 12 weeks, the Gel:nHA = 1:1 group exhibited the highest percentage of bone volume (BV/TV) in the defect area (30.3% ± 1.6%), indicating superior bone regeneration.
  • Histological analysis confirmed that new bone formation was more extensive and filled the pores more completely in the Gel:nHA = 1:1 group compared to other groups and the control.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study acknowledges that other factors, such as the specific distribution and topology of nHA, might influence cell response and require further investigation.
  • While VEGF was assessed, its role in promoting neovascularization within the hybrid scaffold was not extensively explored.
  • Future Work:
    • Further optimization of the Gel/nHA micro-scaffold composition and structure is suggested.
  • The authors propose using the hybrid scaffold as a carrier for bioactive factors like VEGF to further enhance neovascularization and bone regeneration.
  • More in-depth studies are needed to fully understand the influence of nHA distribution and topology on cell responses.

Summary updated

Abstract

Porous titanium is a kind of promising material for bone substitution, while its bio-inert property results in demand of modifications to improve the osteointegration capacity. In this study, gelatin (Gel) and nano-hydroxyapatite (nHA) were used to construct 3D micro-scaffolds in the pores of porous titanium in the ratios of Gel:nHA = 1:0, Gel:nHA = 1:1, and Gel:nHA = 1:3, respectively. Cell attachment and proliferation, and gene and protein expression levels of osteogenic markers were evaluated in MC3T3-E1 cells, followed by bone regeneration assessment in a rabbit radius defect model. All hybrid scaffolds with different composition ratio were found to have significant promotional effects in cell adhesion, proliferation and differentiation, in which the group with Gel:nHA = 1:1 showed the best performance in vitro, as well as the most bone regeneration volume in vivo. This 3D micro-scaffolds modification may be an innovative method for porous titanium ornamentation and shows potential application values in clinic.
BibTeX
@article{yin2016hybrid,
  author = {Bo Yin and Pei Ma and Jun Chen and Hai Wang and Gui Wu and Bo Li and Qiang Li and Zhifeng Huang and Guixing Qiu and Zhihong Wu},
  title = {{Hybrid Macro-Porous Titanium Ornamented by Degradable 3D Gel/nHA Micro-Scaffolds for Bone Tissue Regeneration}},
  journal = {International Journal of Molecular Sciences},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.3390/ijms17040575},
}
Figure