Hybrid-chain: An Innovative and Efficient Mixed Blockchain Architecture

Yunpeng Wang, Hui Zhao, Tao Li, Fan Zhang, Zhiyong Li2018 · DOI

Abstract

The blockchain architecture with distributed and decentralized as the main features often face problems such as long transaction confirmation time, low system throughput, and waste of computing resources. These problems are exactly what the traditional centralized architecture can solve. In order to effectively take advantage of the high security, high reliability of the blockchain, and high efficiency of traditional centralized architectures, this paper presents an innovative hybrid blockchain approach, Hybrid-chain. This architecture consists of three node types: service center nodes for efficient transaction confirmation, dynamic transaction verification nodes participating in transactions, and random verification nodes responsible for fairness verification. Experiments show that compared with traditional blockchain architecture, Hybrid-chain reduces transaction sending time by 96%, shortens confirmation time by 95%, and reduces block information storage space by 79%.

Introduction

Traditional blockchains like Bitcoin face a "scalability trilemma." Because every node in the network must verify and store every single transaction, the system becomes sluggish. In peak periods, Bitcoin confirmation times can spike significantly, while centralized processors like Visa handle thousands of transactions per second. Conversely, while centralized systems are fast, they lack transparency and are susceptible to data manipulation. The Hybrid-chain architecture seeks to bridge this gap, providing the traceability of a blockchain without the bottleneck of global consensus.

Architecture and Methods

The Hybrid-chain model categorizes nodes into three distinct roles to streamline processing and reduce redundant verification:

  1. Service Center Nodes: A small cluster (which can be centralized or a mini-blockchain) that acts as the primary billing and coordination hub.
  2. Dynamic Transaction Verification Nodes: These are the actual parties involved in a transaction (sender and receiver). Unlike standard blockchains, these nodes only record and verify transactions relevant to them.
  3. Random Verification Nodes: Nodes selected at random to act as "auditors" to ensure fairness and prevent collusion between the service center and the transacting parties.
The Hybrid-chain architecture featuring Center Nodes, Client Nodes, and Random Proof Nodes.

Mixed Consensus and Selective Storage

The system utilizes a mixed consensus approach, selecting mechanisms based on transaction characteristics (e.g., PoW for the central cluster to maintain security and PoS for verification nodes to ensure speed).

To address storage bloat, Hybrid-chain uses a "need-to-know" model. Instead of every node storing the entire multi-gigabyte history of the chain, individual nodes store their own transaction history and the cryptographic hashes of the blocks immediately before and after theirs to maintain the integrity of the chain.

Hierarchical structure of the Hybrid-chain, showing the relationship between the Main Blockchain and sub-chains.

Evaluation and Results

The researchers evaluated the architecture using p2pSim, simulating 6,000 nodes and 10,000 transactions. The results showed massive performance leaps over traditional blockchain architectures:

  • Latency: Transaction sending time was reduced by 96%, and confirmation time dropped by 95% (from ~500 seconds down to ~18 seconds in the simulation).
  • Storage: The total space occupied by the blockchain across all nodes was reduced by 79% (from 52,800 MB down to 11,003 MB).
  • Synchronization: Block synchronization between nodes took only 2 seconds, compared to 30 seconds in the traditional model.

Key Insights and Limitations

The core innovation of Hybrid-chain is relevance-based verification. By limiting verification to the involved parties plus a few random auditors, the "network noise" is drastically reduced. The architecture acknowledges that total decentralization is often overkill for business applications, treating decentralization as a spectrum rather than a binary choice.

However, the "Service Center" remains a more centralized point of failure than a truly global network. Future work is required to explore the optimal number of random nodes needed to prevent localized attacks and to test the system under real-world network conditions involving varying node uptimes and malicious actors.

Summary updated

Abstract

The blockchain architecture with distributed and decentralized as the main features often face problems such as long transaction confirmation time, low system throughput, and waste of computing resources. These problems are exactly what the traditional centralized architecture can solve. At the same time, in order to improve the distributed consensus efficiency, consensus algorithms such as Proof of stake, delegated proof of stake, proof of space, proof of authority, and PBFT have emerged from Bitcoin's Pow consensus mechanism. These consensus algorithms have their own advantages and Disadvantages. Disadvantages, such as Pos, DPos can improve transaction efficiency, PBFT can improve the fairness of voting, but at the same time POS also bring benefits and voting rights to hold a lot of user tilt issues to a small number of tokens, PBFT brings about a low cost of malicious user attacks and other issues. In order to effectively take advantage of the high security, high reliability of the blockchain, and high efficiency of traditional centralized architectures, and fully utilizing existing consensus mechanisms, this paper presents an innovative hybrid blockchain approach, which mixed the blockchain architecture, Hybrid-chain, consists of the following three type nodes in the architecture: service center nodes responsible for efficient transaction confirmation, dynamic transaction verification nodes participating in transactions, and random verification nodes responsible for transaction fairness verification. On the consensus mechanism, the consensus algorithm selects the corresponding consensus mechanism according to the transaction characteristics. Experiments show that compared with the traditional blockchain architecture, hybrid chain has obvious performance advantages in transaction sending, transaction confirmation and block information storage, which can greatly reduce the transaction sending time by 96%, shorten the confirmation time by 95%, and reduce the number of 79. % Block information storage space, etc.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2018hybrid,
  author = {Yunpeng Wang and Hui Zhao and Tao Li and Fan Zhang and Zhiyong Li},
  title = {{Hybrid-chain: An Innovative and Efficient Mixed Blockchain Architecture}},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.2991/eame-18.2018.55},
}
Figure