Hunting for extra dimensions in the shadow of Sagittarius A*

Di WuarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper leverages the recent groundbreaking image of Sagittarius A (SgrA) from the Event Horizon Telescope to place a new, significantly tighter constraint on the size of extra dimensions predicted by some theories of gravity. The findings suggest that these extra dimensions are smaller than previously estimated, improving the accuracy of such measurements by three orders of magnitude.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The existence of extra spatial dimensions beyond the familiar three is a theoretical possibility explored in various physics models, most notably in Kaluza-Klein (KK) theories and braneworld scenarios like the Randall-Sundrum (RS) model. These models propose that our observable universe is a "brane" embedded in a higher-dimensional "bulk." A key parameter in these theories is the curvature radius of the extra dimension, denoted by $l$. Detecting or constraining the size of these extra dimensions is crucial for validating or refuting these theoretical frameworks. Previous attempts to constrain $l$ have relied on laboratory experiments (yielding limits around 1 mm) or astronomical observations, such as the analysis of the shadow of the black hole M87. However, the recent capture of the SgrA shadow by the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) presents a new, high-resolution observational target that could potentially offer a more precise constraint on $l$. This paper aims to exploit this new data to refine the upper limit on $l$.

Methods

The authors build upon previous work that related the quadrupole moment of a black hole to the presence of extra dimensions. In the Randall-Sundrum (RS) scenario, the gravitational potential of a rotating black hole is modified by a "tidal charge" $\beta$, which encodes information about the extra dimension and its curvature radius $l$. This modification leads to a deviation in the black hole's quadrupole moment compared to standard General Relativity predictions.

The paper first reviews the calculation of the quadrupole moment for Kerr black holes in four dimensions and then extends this to the five-dimensional RS scenario. They derive an expression for the deviation in the quadrupole moment, $\Delta Q$, and its relative deviation, $\epsilon$, as a function of $l$ and the black hole's properties (mass $M$ and angular momentum parameter $a$).

Crucially, they utilize the observational data from the EHT's SgrA image. Specifically, they use the constraint on the deviation from circularity of the SgrA shadow, which is related to the quadrupole moment. While the EHT collaboration provides a general constraint on deviations, the authors adopt a conservative upper bound of $\epsilon \leq 4$ (based on similar constraints for M87) to derive their limit on $l$. They also incorporate the estimated mass of SgrA from EHT observations to translate the constraint on $l$ into a physical distance in astronomical units (AU).

Datasets

The primary "dataset" used in this paper is the observational data from the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) collaboration, specifically the first image of the shadow of Sagittarius A (SgrA). The paper references multiple EHT publications detailing the observations, data processing, and initial analysis of the SgrA shadow. The authors also utilize the estimated mass of SgrA ($4.0 \pm 1.1 \times 10^6 M_\odot$) derived from these EHT observations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • SgrA* Shadow as a Probe of Extra Dimensions: The paper demonstrates that the detailed imaging of SgrA*'s shadow, a phenomenon directly influenced by the black hole's spacetime geometry, can be used to probe fundamental physics beyond the Standard Model, such as the existence of extra dimensions.
  • Improved Precision: By using the SgrA* data, the authors achieve a significant improvement in the precision of the upper limit on the extra dimension curvature radius $l$, surpassing previous astronomical constraints by three orders of magnitude.
  • Independent Constraint: The derived limit on $l$ is independent of laboratory-based constraints, offering a complementary and valuable piece of evidence in the search for physics beyond General Relativity.
  • Braneworld Model Validation: The study provides a quantitative test for specific braneworld models, showing that the observed SgrA* shadow is consistent with these models only if the extra dimensions are sufficiently small.

Key Results

The paper derives a new upper limit on the AdS$_5$ curvature radius $l$ from the SgrA* shadow data:

  • $l \lesssim 0.097$ AU (where 1 AU is one astronomical unit).

This result represents a significant improvement in accuracy by three orders of magnitude compared to the previous limit derived from the M87* shadow ($l \lesssim 170$ AU). While this limit is still not as stringent as laboratory-based constraints (around 1 mm), it is a valuable and independent astronomical constraint.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assumptions on Black Hole Model: The analysis relies on the assumption that SgrA can be accurately described by a Kerr black hole metric, which is a standard assumption but might have limitations if SgrA possesses significant deviations from this ideal model.
  • EHT Constraint Interpretation: The paper uses a conservative interpretation of the EHT's constraint on the deviation from circularity ($\epsilon \leq 4$), acknowledging that the EHT collaboration has not yet provided a precise upper limit for SgrA*. Future, more refined analyses of the EHT data could potentially yield even tighter constraints.
  • Future EHT Observations: The authors express optimism that future observations from the EHT and next-generation telescopes will image more black holes, allowing for further tests of fundamental physics and potentially even tighter constraints on extra dimensions. They also highlight the exciting prospect of using these observations to explore alternative theories of gravity and the structure of spacetime.

Summary updated

Abstract

Recently, Vagnozzi and Visinelli's work [Phys. Rev. D 100, 024020 (2020)] reveals that M87*'s shadow establishes an upper limit of $l \lesssim 170$ AU, where $l$ is the AdS$_5$ curvature radius and 1 AU is one astronomical unit. The Event Horizon Telescope, on the other hand, just captured the first image of the shadow of Sagittarius A* (SgrA*), the Galactic center source associated with a supermassive black hole. In this paper, we are motivated to comprehensively explore a new upper limit of $l$ with the shadow of SgrA*, and the findings suggest that $l \lesssim 0.097$ AU. Our results improve accuracy by three orders of magnitude. This is also one of the first quantifiable limitations on exotic physics derived from the remarkable first image of the shadow of SgrA*.
BibTeX
@misc{wu2022hunting,
  author = {Di Wu},
  title = {{Hunting for extra dimensions in the shadow of Sagittarius A*}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2205.07207},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.07207},
}

Loading related content...

Figure