Humor Affects Fairness Considerations in the Gain and Loss Contexts

Zhong Yang, Di Fu, Yue Qi, Ya Zheng, Qi Li, Xun LiuFrontiers in Psychology 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Human decision-making behaviors in social contexts are largely driven by fairness considerations. The dual-process model suggests that in addition to cognitive processes, emotion contributes to economic decision-making. Although humor, as an effective emotional regulation strategy to induce positive emotion, may influence an individual's emotional state and decision-making behavior, previous studies have not examined how humor modulates fairness-related responses in the gain and loss contexts simultaneously. This study uses the Ultimatum Game (UG) in gain and loss contexts to explore this issue. The results show, in the gain context, viewing humorous pictures compared to humorless pictures increased acceptance rates and this effect was moderated by the offer size. However, we did not find the same effect in the loss context. These findings indicate that humor's affection for fairness considerations may depend on the context and provide insight into the finite power of humor in human sociality, cooperation and norm compliance.

Introduction

Human decision-making is rarely a purely rational exercise. Instead, it is often a tug-of-war between cognitive logic and emotional reactions—a framework known as the dual-process model. A classic tool for studying this interaction is the "Ultimatum Game" (UG). In a standard UG, a "Proposer" offers a split of a resource, and a "Responder" can either accept or reject it. If rejected, neither player receives anything. Rationally, a Responder should accept any non-zero offer, but in practice, people frequently reject unfair offers to punish greed, even at a personal cost.

While positive emotions are known to "grease the wheels" of social interaction and increase tolerance for unfairness, most research has focused exclusively on gain contexts (e.g., splitting a profit). This study addresses a critical gap: Does humor—a potent tool for emotional regulation—maintain its influence when the stakes involve losses (e.g., splitting a debt)? According to Prospect Theory, losses "loom larger" than gains, suggesting that the emotional sting of an unfair loss might be too potent for a simple joke to override.

Methods

The researchers recruited 99 university students to participate as "Responders" in a modified Ultimatum Game. The experiment utilized a 2 (Context: Gain vs. Loss) × 2 (Humor: Humorous vs. Humorless) × 3 (Offer Type: Fair, Unfair, Highly Unfair) within-subjects design.

Experimental Procedure

Participants were presented with a series of trials. In each trial, they first viewed a comic strip (either humorous or humorless) to induce a specific emotional state. Following this, they were presented with a proposal for splitting ¥10. In the Gain Context, they split a reward; in the Loss Context, they split a debt. If the Responder rejected a loss-context offer, both players were penalized the full ¥10.

The experimental procedure for the loss context, illustrating the sequence from fixation to response.

Stimuli and Validation

The study used a set of 209 comic pictures (rage comics) pre-rated by an independent group of 32 participants. The researchers selected the top and bottom 23% of these ratings to serve as the humorous and humorless stimuli, respectively.

Results

Mood Induction

The humor manipulation was successful. Self-reported affect ratings confirmed that humorous pictures significantly increased positive affect compared to both baseline and humorless pictures across both experimental contexts ($p < 0.001$).

Self-reported affect ratings showing that humorous stimuli successfully induced positive affect in both gain and loss contexts.

Acceptance Rates

The primary finding was a significant interaction between humor and context:

  • Gain Context Success: Humor acted as a social lubricant. Participants viewing humorous comics were significantly more likely to accept offers ($67.55\%$) than those viewing humorless ones ($61.91\%$). This effect was most pronounced for unfair offers, where acceptance rates jumped from $53.06\%$ to $59.74\%$.
  • Loss Context Failure: Humor failed to influence decision-making. There was no significant difference in acceptance rates between the humorous ($61.09\%$) and humorless ($61.56\%$) conditions.
  • Fairness Dominance: Regardless of the emotional state or context, acceptance rates plummeted as offers became more unfair ($p < 0.001$), confirming that fairness remains a primary driver of human social behavior.

Discussion

The results highlight the "finite power" of humor. While humor can shift participants toward a more utilitarian mindset in gain contexts (i.e., "any money is better than no money"), it is ineffective when defending against a "hit" to resources. This supports Prospect Theory's assertion that the negative emotion triggered by a loss is more intense and "stubborn" than that of a missed gain. Humor provides a "benign violation" perspective—making a situation seem less serious—but an unfair financial loss appears too serious to be laughed off.

Limitations and Future Directions

The study's reliance on comic strips may have induced a level of humor insufficient to counter the high emotional arousal of financial loss. Future research might utilize more intense stimuli, such as video clips. Additionally, the sample was limited to Chinese university students; given that humor and fairness norms are culturally sensitive, broader demographic sampling is necessary to generalize these findings. Finally, future work should clarify whether the observed effects are specific to "mirth" or are a general byproduct of positive affect.

Summary updated

Abstract

Human decision-making behaviors in social contexts are largely driven by fairness considerations. The dual-process model suggests that in addition to cognitive processes, emotion contributes to economic decision-making. Although humor, as an effective emotional regulation strategy to induce positive emotion, may influence an individual's emotional state and decision-making behavior, previous studies have not examined how humor modulates fairness-related responses in the gain and loss contexts simultaneously. This study uses the Ultimatum Game (UG) in gain and loss contexts to explore this issue. The results show, in the gain context, viewing humorous pictures compared to humorless pictures increased acceptance rates and this effect was moderated by the offer size. However, we did not find the same effect in the loss context. These findings indicate that humor's affection for fairness considerations may depend on the context and provide insight into the finite power of humor in human sociality, cooperation and norm compliance.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2019humor,
  author = {Zhong Yang and Di Fu and Yue Qi and Ya Zheng and Qi Li and Xun Liu},
  title = {{Humor Affects Fairness Considerations in the Gain and Loss Contexts}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2018.02679},
}
Figure