HumGut: A comprehensive Human Gut prokaryotic genomes collection filtered by metagenome data

Pranvera Hiseni, Knut Rudi, Robert C. Wilson, Finn Terje Hegge, Lars SnipenbioRxiv 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed "HumGut," a comprehensive and curated collection of over 30,000 prokaryotic genomes specifically from the healthy human gut. This new reference database significantly improves the accuracy and efficiency of metagenomic analysis, outperforming existing databases and addressing a critical bottleneck in microbiome research.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The study tackles a major hurdle in human gut microbiome research: the lack of a standardized, comprehensive, and highly relevant reference database for identifying microbial communities. Current methods often struggle with accurately classifying the vast number of prokaryotic genomes present in gut metagenomes, leading to a high percentage of unclassified reads and potentially inaccurate conclusions. Previous efforts have increased the number of available genomes, but a curated collection focused on the prevalent genomes in healthy individuals, suitable for robust reference-based analysis, was missing. This gap hinders our ability to understand gut microbiome composition, its role in health and disease, and the development of standardized analytical methods.

Methods

The authors developed a multi-step process to create the HumGut collection:

  1. Genome Screening: They screened over 490,000 publicly available prokaryotic genomes (from RefSeq and the UHGG collection) against more than 5,700 healthy human gut metagenomes.
  2. Containment Threshold: Genomes were considered "contained" if they shared at least 0.95 sequence identity with at least one healthy metagenome, using MASH for rapid screening.
  3. Scoring and Ranking: Qualified genomes were scored based on their average sequence identity across all healthy metagenomes. This score was used to rank genomes by their prevalence in the healthy gut.
  4. Clustering: Genomes were clustered at two resolutions: 97.5% and 95% average nucleotide identity (ANI), corresponding roughly to subspecies and species resolution, respectively. This was done using a greedy approach with MASH and fastANI for distance calculations, selecting a representative genome for each cluster.
  5. Taxonomic Annotation: Genomes were annotated using GTDB-Tk and NCBI taxonomy.

Datasets

  • Input Genomes: Over 490,000 prokaryotic genomes from the Unified Human Gut Genomes (UHGG) collection and NCBI RefSeq.
  • Reference Metagenomes: 5,737 healthy human gut metagenome samples (collected as MetHealthy) from 74 BioProjects.
  • Evaluation Metagenomes: An additional 963 metagenome samples from patients with Irritable Bowel Disease (IBD) (collected as MetIBD).
  • Primate Metagenomes: 95 samples used as an outgroup for comparison.

The paper introduces the HumGut collection itself, comprising over 30,000 genomes at subspecies resolution (HumGut_97.5) and a subset of 5,170 genomes at species resolution (HumGut_95).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Prevalence is Key: The core idea is that a reference database should prioritize genomes actually found and frequently present in the target environment (healthy human gut), rather than just a large collection of all known genomes.
  • Beyond UHGG: By incorporating RefSeq genomes that showed no similarity to UHGG genomes, HumGut captures a broader spectrum of relevant human gut prokaryotes.
  • Efficiency Matters: HumGut databases are significantly smaller than the standard Kraken2 database, leading to reduced computational resource requirements for analysis.
  • Standardization is Crucial: The authors emphasize that a standardized reference collection is vital for the field of microbiome research, which currently suffers from a lack of methodological consistency.

Key Results

  • The HumGut collection contains over 30,000 genomes (HumGut_97.5) clustered at subspecies resolution, ranked by prevalence in healthy human gut metagenomes.
  • HumGut demonstrated superior performance in metagenomic read classification compared to the standard Kraken2 database and the UHGG collection.
  • HumGut_97.5 classified an average of 94.5% of reads, compared to 86% for UHGG and 44% for the standard Kraken2 database.
  • HumGut databases are smaller: HumGut_95 (15.9 GB) and HumGut_97.5 (24.9 GB) are considerably smaller than the standard Kraken2 database (42.1 GB).
  • The HumGut collection is also effective for classifying metagenomes from IBD patients, indicating its broad applicability beyond healthy individuals.
  • Analysis revealed a core set of ~50 bacterial species present in over 70% of healthy adult samples, with regional differences in Prevotella and Bacteroides abundance.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Nomenclature Inconsistency: A significant challenge remains the inconsistent nomenclature of species across different databases (GTDB and NCBI), leading to discrepancies between the number of clusters and the number of unique names. The authors provide custom "taxonomy IDs" to address this for their database.
  • Future Work: The authors plan to extend their approach to include more disease-associated genomes and metagenomes, and to screen for gut genomes expected to be published in the future. They also aim to further refine the database and its utility.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background A major bottleneck in the use of metagenome sequencing for human gut microbiome studies has been the lack of a comprehensive genome collection to be used as a reference database. Several recent efforts have been made to re-construct genomes from human gut metagenome data, resulting in a huge increase in the number of relevant genomes. In this work, we aimed to create a collection of the most prevalent healthy human gut prokaryotic genomes, to be used as a reference database, including both MAGs from the human gut and ordinary RefSeq genomes. Results We screened > 5,700 healthy human gut metagenomes for the containment of > 490,000 publicly available prokaryotic genomes sourced from RefSeq and the recently announced UHGG collection. This resulted in a pool of > 379,000 genomes that were subsequently scored and ranked based on their prevalence in the healthy human metagenomes. The genomes were then clustered at subspecies resolution, and cluster representatives were retained to comprise the HumGut collection. Using the Kraken2 software for classification, we find superior performance in the assignment of metagenomic reads, classifying on average 94.5% of the reads in a metagenome, as opposed to 86% with UHGG and 44% when using standard Kraken2 database. HumGut, half the size of standard Kraken2 database and directly comparable to the UHGG size, outperforms them both. Conclusions The HumGut collection contains > 30,000 genomes clustered at subspecies resolution and ranked by human gut prevalence. We demonstrate how metagenomes from IBD-patients map equally well to this collection, indicating this reference is relevant also for studies well outside the metagenome reference set used to obtain HumGut. We believe this is a valuable resource in a field in dire need of method standardization. All data and metadata, as well as helpful code, are available at http://arken.nmbu.no/~larssn/humgut/ .
BibTeX
@misc{hiseni2020humgut,
  author = {Pranvera Hiseni and Knut Rudi and Robert C. Wilson and Finn Terje Hegge and Lars Snipen},
  title = {{HumGut: A comprehensive Human Gut prokaryotic genomes collection filtered by metagenome data}},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1101/2020.03.25.007666},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure