Human Limbal Progenitor Cell Characteristics are Maintained in Tissue Culture

Shaohui Liu, Jing Li, Chuanfu Wang, Donald Tan, Roger W. BeuermanAnnals 2006 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the characteristics of human limbal epithelial cells cultured in vitro to understand their potential as progenitor cells for ocular surface repair. The researchers found that these cells, when cultured with a specific medium and feeder layer, maintain key progenitor cell markers and can proliferate, suggesting their suitability for therapeutic applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The cornea, the transparent front part of the eye, is covered by a stratified squamous epithelium. This epithelium is constantly renewed, and the cells responsible for this renewal are thought to reside in the limbal region, a junctional zone between the cornea and the sclera. Damage to the ocular surface, often due to diseases like Stevens-Johnson syndrome, chemical burns, or tumors, can deplete these limbal stem cells, leading to severe vision impairment. Therapeutic approaches involve transplanting limbal tissue, but sometimes healthy limbal tissue is limited. Therefore, culturing and expanding limbal cells ex vivo offers a promising alternative to autografts, potentially avoiding immune rejection. However, a critical question remains: do these cultured cells retain their progenitor characteristics, or do they differentiate prematurely? This paper aims to address this by characterizing the phenotype of cultured human limbal epithelial cells.

Methods

The researchers isolated human limbal epithelial cells from cadaveric corneal rims. These cells were then cultured in a specialized medium called SHEM (supplemental hormonal epithelial medium) on a feeder layer of mitomycin C-treated 3T3 fibroblasts. This feeder layer is a standard technique to support the growth of various cell types.

To assess the cells' characteristics, several techniques were employed:

  • Immunohistochemistry and Immunocytochemistry: This involved using antibodies to detect specific proteins (markers) within the cells and tissues. They looked for markers of differentiation (cytokeratin 3 (K3), cytokeratin 12 (K12), involucrin) and markers of proliferation and progenitor cells (proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA), p63, connexin 43 (Cx43)).
  • Real-time Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR): This technique was used to quantify the mRNA levels of K3 and K12, providing insights into gene expression related to differentiation.
  • Clonal Analysis: This method assessed the colony-forming efficiency (CFE) of the primary cultured cells, a measure of their ability to proliferate and form colonies from single cells.
  • Airlifting Culture: A subset of cultured cells was subjected to an "airlifting" procedure, where the medium level was lowered to expose the cells to air. This is a known method to promote corneal epithelial differentiation.

Datasets

The study utilized human limbal tissue obtained from the Singapore Eye Bank. No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, the study focused on characterizing the cells themselves.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Progenitor Cell Maintenance: The 3T3 feeder layer and SHEM medium system appears effective in maintaining limbal epithelial cells in a relatively undifferentiated state, preserving their progenitor characteristics.
  • Differentiation Markers are Sparse: While some differentiation markers (K3, K12) were detected, their expression was significantly lower in cultured cells compared to in vivo limbal or corneal epithelium. This suggests that the culture conditions favor proliferation over rapid differentiation.
  • p63 as a Potential Proliferation Marker: The study found p63 to be strongly positive in the basal layer of limbal tissue and in most cultured limbal cell colonies. However, its co-expression with K3 (a differentiation marker) in some cells led the authors to suggest that p63 might be more of a proliferation marker than a definitive limbal stem cell marker, a notion supported by other research.
  • Airlifting Promotes Differentiation, but Incompletely: The airlifting technique did induce stratification and expression of some differentiation markers (involucrin, connexin 43) in suprabasal layers. However, K3 expression remained sparse, indicating that this system alone might not fully recapitulate the complex differentiation process seen in vivo. The authors hypothesize that cues present in natural environments like amniotic membranes might be missing in the 3T3 co-culture system.

Key Results

  • Colony-Forming Efficiency (CFE): The primary cultured (P0) cells showed a CFE of approximately 19.35% ± 6.46%.
  • K3 and K12 mRNA Levels: mRNA levels for K3 and K12 in cultured cells were significantly lower (10⁻³ to 10⁻⁵ times lower) than in freshly isolated limbal or central corneal epithelium (P<0.001).
  • K3 and K12 Protein Expression: Immunostaining revealed sparse K3 staining in cultured limbal cell colonies, with an estimated 95% of the population failing to stain. A small percentage of P0 colonies (1.99% ± 1.27%) and a slightly higher percentage of P1 colonies (3.96% ± 1.35%) were positive for K3.
  • PCNA and p63 Expression: PCNA (proliferation marker) was positive in all cells, indicating active proliferation. p63 was strongly positive in the basal layer of limbal tissue and in most cultured limbal cell colonies.
  • Airlifted Cell Sheets: After airlifting, cell sheets formed 3 to 5 epithelial layers. Involucrin was positive in suprabasal layers, connexin 43 was observed in the basal layer, and K3 was sparsely positive on the superficial layer.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limbal Stem Cell Marker Specificity: The study acknowledges the ongoing debate regarding the specificity of p63 as a limbal stem cell marker, suggesting it might also function as a proliferation marker.
  • Differentiation Cues: The 3T3 feeder layer system, while effective for maintaining progenitor characteristics, may lack the necessary differentiation cues found in other systems (e.g., amniotic membrane) to fully mature limbal cells into corneal epithelium.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that this culture system is useful for maintaining limbal epithelial cells in vitro and could be valuable for clinical applications and further studies on limbal stem cell mechanisms. Future work could explore how to better induce differentiation in these cultured cells, perhaps by incorporating different co-culture systems or growth factors.

Summary updated

Abstract

Human limbal cells isolated from cadaveric tissues were able to proliferate in vitro and exhibited a phenotype with characteristics similar to that of the limbal stem or progenitor cells.
BibTeX
@article{liu2006human,
  author = {Shaohui Liu and Jing Li and Chuanfu Wang and Donald Tan and Roger W. Beuerman},
  title = {{Human Limbal Progenitor Cell Characteristics are Maintained in Tissue Culture}},
  journal = {Annals},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.47102/annals-acadmedsg.v35n2p80},
}
Figure