Human Health Risk Levels and Distribution of PAHs in Soil Environment of a Coking Chemical Plant Located in Beijing, China

Jianli Jia, Haibin He, Zihao Wang, Shenwei Zhao, Linying Me, Jialin Liu, Shihai Zhang, Cunzhen Liang, Yinghua ZhangJournal of Bioremediation & Biodegradation 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This study quantifies the human health risks posed by Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs) in the soil surrounding a coking plant in Beijing. The research reveals significantly elevated PAH levels, with oral intake identified as the primary exposure route contributing to carcinogenic risk, highlighting the urgent need for targeted remediation and protective measures.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Coking plants are significant sources of Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons (PAHs), a group of persistent organic pollutants known for their carcinogenic properties. While the presence and distribution of PAHs in industrial areas are well-documented, a comprehensive assessment of the human health risks associated with these contaminants, particularly considering multiple exposure pathways, remains crucial. This paper addresses the gap in understanding the specific health risks faced by individuals living and working near coking facilities, focusing on how PAHs in the soil can enter the human body and the relative contributions of different exposure routes (oral intake, skin contact, inhalation) to overall risk. This knowledge is vital for developing effective environmental management strategies and ensuring public safety.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-step approach to assess PAH contamination and associated health risks. Soil samples were collected from various locations and depths around a coking plant in Beijing. These samples were then analyzed using Soxhlet extraction followed by Gas Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry (GC-MS) to quantify the concentrations of 16 priority PAHs.

For the human health risk assessment, a model was developed based on established guidelines (e.g., RBCA, Csoil, CLEA, HERA, and China's Technical Guidelines for Risk Assessment of Contaminated Sites). This model evaluated carcinogenic risk and hazard quotients for four primary exposure routes:

  1. Oral intake: Ingestion of contaminated soil.
  2. Skin contact: Direct contact with contaminated soil.
  3. Inhalation of outdoor air pollutants from the soil surface: Breathing in airborne particles released from the topsoil.
  4. Inhalation of outdoor air pollutants from the soil lower layer: Breathing in airborne particles released from deeper soil layers.

The study calculated both carcinogenic risk (CR) and hazard quotient (HQ) for each pathway and for the total PAH burden. Risk contribution rates for each pathway were also determined to identify the most significant routes of exposure.

Datasets

The study utilized soil samples collected from a coking plant located in Chaoyang District, Beijing. The sampling was conducted on March 10, 2017, at five different sampling points, with soil profiles analyzed at depths ranging from 0 to 120 cm. The data generated from the GC-MS analysis of these soil samples served as the primary dataset for the risk assessment. No pre-existing public datasets were used for training or evaluation; the study generated its own empirical data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ubiquitous Contamination: All 16 priority PAHs were detected in every soil sample, indicating widespread contamination around the coking facility.
  • Oral Intake Dominance: The oral intake pathway emerged as the most significant contributor to carcinogenic risk, accounting for a staggering 99.3% of the total carcinogenic risk. This suggests that accidental ingestion of soil is a major concern.
  • High Hazard Quotients: The hazard quotients for PAHs in the coking plant soil were found to be significantly elevated, exceeding the acceptable level of 1. This indicates a substantial non-carcinogenic health risk to individuals exposed to these soils.
  • Hotspot Identification: The 100-meter sampling point consistently showed the highest concentrations of PAHs and the most severe carcinogenic risks and hazard quotients, pinpointing a critical remediation "hotspot."
  • Specific PAH Concerns: Benzo[a]anthracene (Baa), Benzo[b]fluoranthene (Bbf), and Benzo[a]pyrene (Bap) were identified as the three most prevalent and concerning PAH pollutants, contributing significantly to both carcinogenic risk and hazard quotients.

Key Results

  • PAH Levels: Total PAH content in the soil ranged from 0.88 to 447.24 mg/kg, with the highest concentration of Baa (447.24 mg/kg) and Bbf (380.29 mg/kg) found at the 100m sampling point.
  • Carcinogenic Risk: The total carcinogenic risk of PAHs in the soil samples ranged from 5.92 × 10⁻³ to 4.9 × 10⁻², significantly exceeding the acceptable level of 1 × 10⁻⁶.
  • Hazard Quotient: The total hazard quotient for PAHs ranged from 19.84 to 160.64, far exceeding the acceptable limit of 1.
  • Pathway Dominance: The oral intake pathway was 498 times more carcinogenic than skin contact and 198 times more carcinogenic than inhalation of soil particles from the surface. Inhalation from the lower soil layer contributed almost zero to carcinogenic risk.
  • Combined Pathway Risk: Oral intake and inhalation of outdoor air from the soil surface together accounted for approximately 90% of the total hazard quotient.
  • Major Pollutant Contribution: Baa, Bbf, and Bap collectively accounted for 55.26% of the total carcinogenic risk and 26.65% of the total hazard quotient.

Limitations and Future Work

The study acknowledges that the risk assessment was primarily focused on adult exposure, as the site was classified as industrial land and not a sensitive area for child exposure. Future work could expand to include child exposure scenarios. The authors also suggest that the findings provide a basis for targeted bioremediation and the selection of key technologies for site repair, implying that further research into specific remediation strategies for this coking plant environment is warranted. The direct proportionality between carcinogenic risk and hazard quotient, while noted, is described as "non-fixed function," suggesting that further investigation into the precise relationship and influencing factors could be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this study, the polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) organic pollutants in soil samples were determined by Soxhlet extraction- GCMS methods. Human health risks of as for 5 different sampling sites in the coking chemical plant were evaluated in four major Exposure routes, including oral intake, skin contact, inhalation the air pollutants of outdoor which from the soil surface, and inhalation the air pollutants of outdoor which from the soil lower layer. The results showed that the detection rate of 16 kinds precedent- controlled PAHs in the US Environmental Protection Agency was 100%. The three main pollutants are Baa, Bbf, Bap. The ΣPAHs comprehensive carcinogenicity risk of the oral exposure pathway is 498 times the carcinogenic risk of the skin exposure pathway, and 198 times the rate of carcinogenic risk of inhalation of soil particle Exposure route. And the rate of carcinogenic risk of Inhalation the air pollutants of outdoor which from the soil lower layer is almost 0. The hazard quotient of soil ΣPAHs main air pollutants pathway are oral intake and inhalation of outdoor air from the soil surface. The sum of them is close to 90%, The hazard quotient of soil ΣPAHs in the coking plant area is seriously exceeded. The risk of ΣPAHs in the soil of coking plant was mainly exposed to oral intake, and the contribution rate of carcinogenic risk was 99.3103%. Combined with the development characteristics of China's coking industry, regional climate and geological characteristics, make a human health risk assessment to ΣPAHs.
BibTeX
@article{jia2017human,
  author = {Jianli Jia and Haibin He and Zihao Wang and Shenwei Zhao and Linying Me and Jialin Liu and Shihai Zhang and Cunzhen Liang and Yinghua Zhang},
  title = {{Human Health Risk Levels and Distribution of PAHs in Soil Environment of a Coking Chemical Plant Located in Beijing, China}},
  journal = {Journal of Bioremediation \& Biodegradation},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.4172/2155-6199.1000407},
}
Figure