Human Capital Planning of Faculties in Higher Education Institutions with Analytic Hierarchy Process Model

Ling Zhang, Yu Xia, Zhen Yang, Qing DuJournal of Human Resource and Sustainability Studies 2014 · DOI

Abstract

This paper proposes a human capital planning model based on the analytic hierarchy process (AHP), designed to determine the optimal faculty size for university departments based on performance assessments in teaching, research, and service. By utilizing pair-wise comparisons and judgmental matrices, the model establishes a relationship between human capital and departmental achievement. The application of this system is demonstrated through a case study, providing a data-driven reference for university authorities when making staffing decisions.

Introduction

Determining the appropriate number of faculty members for specific academic departments is a perennial administrative challenge. Traditionally, higher education institutions have relied on historical "fixed-number" staffing or reactive hiring—replacing retirees or adding positions only when new fields emerge. However, these methods often fail to account for the actual strategic output or the varying missions of diverse departments.

To address this, researchers have developed a dynamic, performance-based model using the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP). This framework moves beyond arbitrary allocation, aligning human resource planning with the core pillars of academia: teaching, research, and service.

Methodology: The Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP)

The core of this research is the application of AHP, a structured technique for organizing and analyzing complex decisions. The process involves breaking down the goal of human capital planning into a multi-level hierarchy of criteria and indicators.

The hierarchical structure of the human capital planning assessment model, showing the breakdown from the primary goal to specific performance indicators.

The Hierarchical Framework

As illustrated in the hierarchy, the model is organized into four distinct levels:

  1. Goal: The overarching assessment of human capital planning (A).
  2. Criteria: The primary pillars of Teaching (B1) and Research (B2).
  3. Sub-criteria: Categories such as Undergraduate/Graduate teaching, Research Funds, Patents, and Publications (C1–C9).
  4. Indicators: Specific, measurable metrics including SCI/EI papers, national-level teaching awards, and government-funded projects (D1–D19).

To ensure fairness across diverse academic fields, the researchers categorized schools into two groups: Category I (Engineering-focused, with higher emphasis on research infrastructure) and Category II (Architecture, Management, and Liberal Arts, with higher emphasis on teaching). A panel of 13 experts, including university presidents and deans, performed pair-wise comparisons to determine the relative weights of these metrics.

Case Study: Tianjin University

The model was validated using a case study of Tianjin University (TU) in China, involving 17 different schools and a total faculty pool of 1,778 positions. By inputting performance scores for each school across the 19 defined indicators, the model generated a mathematically defensible distribution of staff.

Key Results

The application of the model at TU successfully converted abstract performance metrics into concrete faculty numbers:

  • Distribution Range: The highest-performing department (School A) achieved a score of 100, resulting in an allocation of 212 faculty members (11.92% of the total pool).
  • The Long Tail: Conversely, the lowest-performing department (School Q) received a score of 9.5, translating to 20 faculty members (1.13%).

Discussion and Insights

One notable finding was the consolidation of "service" into research criteria. In the context of the studied institutions, service activities are often inextricably linked to research outputs, leading the authors to merge them for simplicity and accuracy.

Furthermore, the model highlights the importance of disciplinary nuance. By avoiding a "one-size-fits-all" approach, the framework ensures that Liberal Arts schools are not unfairly penalized for having fewer patents or lower research funding compared to Engineering departments. This creates an incentive loop where schools are rewarded with human capital for excellence within their specific strategic domains.

Limitations and Future Work

While the AHP model provides a rigorous mathematical framework, it is not without limitations. The initial weighting of criteria relies on expert judgment, which introduces a degree of subjectivity. Additionally, the model provides a snapshot of current performance; the authors suggest that these dimensions must be adjusted periodically to avoid staffing stagnation and to reflect evolving institutional goals. Future research may also explore how this model, tailored to the administrative structures of Chinese universities, can be adapted for Western or private institutions where "service" and "outreach" may carry different institutional weights.

Conclusion

The AHP-based human capital planning model offers a transparent, data-driven alternative to traditional staffing methods. By quantifying departmental output and accounting for disciplinary differences, it provides university leadership with a clear roadmap for the strategic distribution of faculty resources.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper proposed a human capital planning model based on the analytic hierarchy process (AHP), with which the dimension for faculty number of each school in university could be obtained according to the performance assessment of teaching, research, and service. Pair-wise comparisons and the judgmental matrix were carried out considering the relationship between human capital and achievement on evaluation items of different schools. The convenient application of this estimating system was thoroughly discussed via a given example, which provided helpful information and reference to authority department when deciding the dimension of faculties.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2014human,
  author = {Ling Zhang and Yu Xia and Zhen Yang and Qing Du},
  title = {{Human Capital Planning of Faculties in Higher Education Institutions with Analytic Hierarchy Process Model}},
  journal = {Journal of Human Resource and Sustainability Studies},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.4236/jhrss.2014.24023},
}
Figure