Human and Monkey Striatal Interneurons Are Derived from the Medial Ganglionic Eminence But Not from the Adult Subventricular Zone

Qianxi Wang, Yanhui You, Dunyi Qi, Xiaofang Zhou, Lihui Wang, Wei Shen, Zhuangzhi Zhang, Wei Huang, Zhongfan Liu, F. Liu, Lan Ma, Zaili YangJournal of Neuroscience 2014 · DOI

Abstract

In adult rodent and monkey brains, newly born neurons in the subventricular zone (SVZ) migrate into the olfactory bulb (OB). While some studies suggested the adult human striatum also receives new interneurons from the SVZ, this research challenges that claim. By tracking the continuous expression of Sp8 from the neuroblast stage through differentiation, the authors found that the adult human SVZ does not generate new interneurons for the striatum. Most neuroblasts in the human SVZ and rostral migratory stream (RMS) express Sp8 and are likely destined for the OB. In contrast, the vast majority of striatal interneurons express markers of the medial ganglionic eminence (MGE), indicating they are generated during embryonic development.

Introduction

Adult neurogenesis—the birth of new neurons in the adult brain—remains a subject of intense debate in neuroscience. In rodents, the SVZ produces neuroblasts that migrate to the olfactory bulb. However, a high-profile 2014 study proposed that in humans, the SVZ also contributes a significant stream of new neurons to the striatum, estimating a 25% annual turnover. This study seeks to verify this claim, as robust self-renewal in the human striatum would have profound implications for treating neurodegenerative diseases like Huntington’s.

Methods and Materials

The researchers employed a "molecular fingerprinting" approach across human and rhesus monkey tissues. Key markers included Sp8, which is expressed in SVZ-born neuroblasts and remains active in mature olfactory bulb neurons, and Nkx2-1 and Sox6, which are specific to the embryonic Medial Ganglionic Eminence (MGE).

The study utilized high-quality primary tissue samples:

  • Human Tissue: Fetal samples (Gestation Week 18) and adult brains (ages 35–60) from the Chinese Brain Bank Center.
  • Primate Tissue: Rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulatta) at various stages, from newborn to adult (6–10 years).
  • BrdU Labeling: Rhesus monkeys were injected with BrdU to "date-stamp" new neurons, tracked for up to 15 weeks.

Results

The Sp8 Marker as a Lineage Tracer

The researchers found that while the adult human SVZ contains neuroblasts (Dcx+), nearly all of them express Sp8. These cells are part of the pathway leading to the olfactory bulb.

Sp8 expression in neuroblasts within the adult human SVZ and RMS.

Crucially, Sp8-positive cells are extremely rare in the adult striatum (<1% of Calretinin interneurons). This mismatch suggests that SVZ neuroblasts are destined for the olfactory bulb, not the striatum.

Embryonic Origins of Striatal Interneurons

Most striatal interneurons, including those expressing Parvalbumin (PV), Somatostatin (SOM), and ChAT, were found to express MGE markers like Nkx2-1 and Sox6.

Expression of Sox6 in the striatum, indicating an embryonic MGE origin.

Since the MGE is an embryonic structure that disappears after birth, the presence of these markers in adult neurons indicates they were generated during gestation. In juvenile monkeys, nearly 100% of ChAT+ and >98% of PV+ striatal neurons expressed Nkx2-1.

Lack of Adult Neurogenesis in the Striatum

BrdU tracking in adult monkeys yielded zero BrdU-labeled mature neurons (NeuN+) in the striatum after 15 weeks. This directly contradicts the hypothesis of high neuronal turnover in the adult primate striatum.

Discussion

The findings align primate neurobiology more closely with rodent models, suggesting that the embryonic origin of striatal interneurons from the MGE is a conserved developmental blueprint. While a small population of neuroblasts exists in the adult human SVZ, they appear to be a dwindling population that fails to integrate into the striatum.

The study acknowledges limitations, such as the difficulty of detecting Nkx2-1 in adult human tissue due to lipofuscin accumulation. However, the monkey data provides strong confirmatory evidence. The discrepancy with previous Carbon-14 dating studies remains to be fully resolved, though it is possible those studies detected non-neuronal turnover or extremely rare cell subtypes. Ultimately, this research suggests that the healthy adult human striatum does not undergo significant neuronal replenishment.

Summary updated

Abstract

In adult rodent and monkey brains, newly born neurons in the subventricular zone (SVZ) in the wall of the lateral ventricle migrate into the olfactory bulb (OB) via the rostral migratory stream (RMS). A recent study reported that interneurons are constantly generating in the adult human striatum from the SVZ. In contrast, by taking advantage of the continuous expression of Sp8 from the neuroblast stage through differentiation into mature interneurons, we found that the adult human SVZ does not generate new interneurons for the striatum. In the adult human SVZ and RMS, very few neuroblasts were observed, and most of them expressed the transcription factor Sp8. Neuroblasts in the adult rhesus monkey SVZ-RMS-OB pathway also expressed Sp8. In addition, we observed that Sp8 was expressed by most adult human and monkey OB interneurons. However, very few Sp8+ cells were in the adult human striatum. This suggests that neuroblasts in the adult human SVZ and RMS are likely destined for the OB, but not for the striatum. BrdU-labeling results also revealed few if any newly born neurons in the adult rhesus monkey striatum. Finally, on the basis of transcription factor expression, we provide strong evidence that the vast majority of interneurons in the human and monkey striatum are generated from the medial ganglionic eminence during embryonic developmental stages, as they are in rodents. We conclude that, although a small number of neuroblasts exist in the adult human SVZ, they do not migrate into the striatum and become mature striatal interneurons.
BibTeX
@article{wang2014human,
  author = {Qianxi Wang and Yanhui You and Dunyi Qi and Xiaofang Zhou and Lihui Wang and Wei Shen and Zhuangzhi Zhang and Wei Huang and Zhongfan Liu and F. Liu and Lan Ma and Zaili Yang},
  title = {{Human and Monkey Striatal Interneurons Are Derived from the Medial Ganglionic Eminence But Not from the Adult Subventricular Zone}},
  journal = {Journal of Neuroscience},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.1523/jneurosci.1758-14.2014},
}
Figure