HSP70-binding motifs function as protein quality control degrons

Amanda B. Abildgaard, Vasileios Voutsinos, Søren D. Petersen, Fia B. Larsen, Caroline Kampmeyer, Kristoffer E. Johansson, Amelie Stein, Tommer Ravid, Claes Andréasson, Michael K. Jensen, Kresten Lindorff‐Larsen, Rasmus Hartmann‐PetersenbioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reveals that sequences that bind to Hsp70 chaperones, crucial for protein folding, can also act as "degrons" – signals that tag misfolded proteins for degradation. This discovery suggests a direct link between protein folding assistance and the cellular machinery that eliminates damaged proteins, offering a new perspective on how cells maintain proteome health.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cells have sophisticated systems to ensure proteins are correctly folded and functional. When proteins misfold, they can become toxic and lead to disease. The cell's "protein quality control" (PQC) system degrades these misfolded proteins to prevent their accumulation. While we know that chaperones like Hsp70 help proteins fold, and that a separate system (the ubiquitin-proteasome system, or UPS) degrades misfolded proteins, it's been unclear how the PQC system specifically identifies which proteins to degrade. PQC degrons are known to be hydrophobic and lack negative charges, features also found in regions that bind to chaperones. This paper investigates whether these chaperone-binding regions themselves can function as degrons, bridging the gap between protein folding assistance and degradation.

Methods

The researchers employed a yeast-based reporter system using a Ura3-HA-GFP fusion protein. When a "degron" sequence is fused to this reporter, it leads to the reporter's degradation, causing a measurable growth phenotype (resistance to 5-FOA). They used this system to test the degron activity of a known Hsp70-binding motif (the APPY peptide, specifically its RLLL core). They also performed:

  • Mutagenesis: Altering specific amino acids in the APPY peptide to see how it affects degron function.
  • Library screening: Creating a diverse library of APPY peptide variants with randomized sequences in the RLLL region to explore the "sequence space" compatible with degron activity.
  • Western blotting and microscopy: To measure protein levels and observe cellular phenotypes.
  • Co-immunoprecipitation: To confirm interactions between the reporter protein, Hsp70, and other relevant proteins.
  • Yeast genetics: Using deletion strains of various chaperones, co-chaperones, and E3 ligases to understand their roles in RLLL-mediated degradation.
  • Human cell experiments: Adapting the reporter system to human HEK293T cells to confirm the findings across species.
  • Bioinformatic analysis: Using the Limbo software to predict Hsp70 binding to peptides and correlating these predictions with proteome-wide protein abundance and half-life data.

Datasets

  • Yeast Proteome Data: Abundance and half-life data for yeast proteins were used for proteome-wide correlation analysis.
  • HEK293T Cell Line: A modified human cell line with a "landing pad" for site-specific integration was used for experiments in human cells.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Chaperone-binding motifs are degrons: The core finding is that sequences known to bind Hsp70 chaperones can directly function as degradation signals (degrons). This implies a direct link between the folding and degradation arms of protein quality control.
  • Degron function is context-dependent: While the RLLL motif is key, the surrounding amino acids in the APPY peptide significantly influence its degron activity. This suggests that the local sequence environment is crucial.
  • Vast sequence space for degrons: The library screening revealed that a wide range of sequences, not just the canonical RLLL, can function as effective degrons, provided they retain Hsp70-binding properties.
  • Hsp70 acts as a "triage" mechanism: The study proposes that Hsp70, by binding to exposed motifs on misfolded proteins, effectively flags them for either refolding or degradation, acting as an initial decision-maker.
  • Evolutionary advantage: Exploiting pre-existing chaperone-binding sites for degradation offers an efficient evolutionary strategy, leveraging a well-established protein recognition system.

Key Results

  • The canonical Hsp70-binding motif RLLL, within the APPY peptide, functions as a dose-dependent PQC degron in both yeast and human cells.
  • Degradation of the reporter protein correlated with Hsp70-binding ability; mutations reducing Hsp70 affinity (RAAA, DAAA) decreased or abolished the degron effect.
  • The RLLL motif induced insolubility of the reporter protein, and this insolubility correlated with degron activity.
  • Degradation of the RLLL degron required specific chaperones (Hsp70, Hsp110), co-chaperones (Fes1, Sse1/2), and the E3 ligase Ubr1.
  • Proteome-wide analysis showed that proteins with more exposed Hsp70-binding sites tend to have lower abundance and shorter half-lives.
  • In human cells, the APPY peptide also acted as a chaperone-dependent degron, with its degradation affected by Hsp70 inhibition.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model system vs. natural misfolding: The authors acknowledge that their reporter system, where degrons are artificially grafted, differs from the natural process of protein misfolding where degron exposure is a consequence of structural changes. Future work could explore these complexities in full-length proteins.
  • Specificity of E3 ligases: While Ubr1 was identified as a key E3 ligase, the paper suggests that other E3s might also target these degrons, potentially through broad specificity mechanisms. Further investigation into the E3 ligase landscape for these degrons is warranted.
  • Role of intrinsic disorder: The study touches upon intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs) and suggests that degron motifs in such proteins might require activation or lead to instability. This area could be further explored.
  • Proteasome interaction: While the degradation pathway is outlined, the precise mechanisms of how Hsp70-bound substrates are delivered to the proteasome, and the roles of specific co-chaperones and E3s in this process, could be further elucidated.
  • Evolutionary trajectory: The paper hints at the evolutionary advantage of this system. Further studies could delve deeper into the evolutionary history and selection pressures that led to this overlap between chaperone binding and degradation signaling.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Protein quality control (PQC) degrons are short protein segments that target misfolded proteins for proteasomal degradation, and thus protect cells against the accumulation of potentially toxic non-native proteins. Studies have shown that PQC degrons are hydrophobic and rarely contain negatively charged residues, features which are shared with chaperone-binding regions. Here we explore the notion that chaperone-binding regions may function as PQC degrons. When directly tested, we found that a canonical Hsp70-binding motif (the APPY peptide) functioned as a dose-dependent PQC degron both in yeast and in human cells. In yeast, Hsp70, Hsp110, Fes1, and the E3 Ubr1 target the APPY degron. Screening revealed that the sequence space within the chaperone-binding region of APPY that is compatible with degron function is vast. We find that the number of exposed Hsp70-binding sites in the yeast proteome correlates with a reduced protein abundance and half-life. Our results suggest that when protein folding fails, chaperone-binding sites may operate as PQC degrons, and PQC-linked degradation therefore overlaps in specificity with chaperone binding. This sheds new light on how the PQC system has evolved to exploit the intrinsic capacity of chaperones to recognize misfolded proteins, thereby placing them at the nexus of protein folding and degradation. Significance Statement It is broadly accepted that misfolded proteins are often rapidly degraded by the ubiquitin-proteasome system, but how cells specifically recognize this immensely diverse group of proteins is largely unknown. Here we show that upon uncoupling of protein folding from protein degradation, a canonical chaperone-binding motif doubles as a degradation signal (degron), and that within the context of a Hsp70-binding region, many sequences are compatible with degron function. We find that degradation is correlated with the number of Hsp70-binding sites within a protein, and that the number of exposed Hsp70-binding sites in the yeast proteome correlates with more rapid degradation.
BibTeX
@misc{abildgaard2021hsp,
  author = {Amanda B. Abildgaard and Vasileios Voutsinos and Søren D. Petersen and Fia B. Larsen and Caroline Kampmeyer and Kristoffer E. Johansson and Amelie Stein and Tommer Ravid and Claes Andréasson and Michael K. Jensen and Kresten Lindorff‐Larsen and Rasmus Hartmann‐Petersen},
  title = {{HSP70-binding motifs function as protein quality control degrons}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.12.22.473789},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure