How Visualization PhD Students Cope with Paper Rejections

Shivam Agarwal, Shahid Latif, Fabian BeckarXiv 2020 · arXiv

Abstract

Paper rejection is a ubiquitous hurdle in academic research, yet its impact on junior researchers remains under-explored. This study investigates how PhD students in the data visualization community navigate the emotional and practical challenges of negative peer reviews. Through a qualitative survey of 24 participants, we identify key coping mechanisms, including social support, strategic resubmission tactics, and a cognitive reframing of rejection as a constructive learning opportunity.

Introduction

For PhD students, publications are the primary currency of progress, influencing graduation timelines and future career prospects. In the visualization community, which possesses a distinct reviewing culture and specific publication cycles, the "sting" of rejection can be particularly acute. This research aims to understand how these junior researchers perceive negative feedback, the emotional toll it exacts, and the strategies they employ to persist and eventually publish their work.

Methodology

The study utilized an online questionnaire targeting visualization PhD students who had experienced at least one rejection. Responses were collected from 24 participants at various stages of their doctoral journey, representing 10 different countries.

Distribution of participants across different stages of their PhD programs.

To analyze the qualitative data, researchers employed an open coding process. Two independent coders iteratively refined a set of 25 authoritative codes to categorize coping mechanisms and emotional responses. This systematic approach allowed for the identification of dominant themes in how students handle academic setbacks.

Results

The analysis revealed several core themes regarding the rejection experience, supported by the frequency of specific codes identified in the survey responses.

Social and Collaborative Support

Discussing reviews with collaborators and peers emerged as the most critical coping strategy. Nineteen participants reported that these discussions helped mitigate "imposter syndrome" by normalizing the experience of rejection. Beyond emotional venting, these interactions often led to concrete action: nine participants formulated specific resubmission plans directly following collaborative review sessions.

Resubmission Strategies: Improve vs. Downgrade

When faced with a rejection, students typically adopt one of two tactical approaches. Some choose to "downgrade" the work—submitting to a lower-ranked venue or shortening the paper into a poster—while others opt for significant improvements, such as adding new user studies or refining the technical implementation, to target a similarly prestigious venue.

Frequency of codes identified in participant responses across four survey questions (Q1-Q4).

The Emotional Arc of Reviewing

While the initial encounter with negative reviews is frequently described as painful or distressing, the study found that time significantly alters these perceptions. Half of the participants (12) reported that their impression of the feedback improved as the initial emotional sting faded, eventually recognizing the critiques as fair and constructive. Notably, some students actively reframed the rejection as a positive event that ultimately enhanced the quality of their final publication.

Discussion and Limitations

The findings suggest a high level of resilience among visualization PhD students; none of the participants reported abandoning a project due to rejection. However, the study's geographic concentration—with 50% of participants from the USA and Germany—may limit the generalizability of these findings to other academic cultures. Future research should explore how these coping strategies evolve as students transition into senior researcher roles and how reviewers can be trained to provide more constructive, less emotionally taxing feedback.

Summary updated

Abstract

We conducted a questionnaire study aimed towards PhD students in the field of visualization research to understand how they cope with paper rejections. We collected responses from 24 participants and performed a qualitative analysis of the data in relation to the provided support by collaborators, resubmission strategies, handling multiple rejects, and personal impression of the reviews. The results indicate that the PhD students in the visualization community generally cope well with the negative reviews and, with experience, learn how to act accordingly to improve and resubmit their work. Our results reveal the main coping strategies that can be applied for constructively handling rejected visualization papers. The most prominent strategies include: discussing reviews with collaborators and making a resubmission plan, doing a major revision to improve the work, shortening the work, and seeing rejection as a positive learning experience.
BibTeX
@misc{agarwal2020how,
  author = {Shivam Agarwal and Shahid Latif and Fabian Beck},
  title = {{How Visualization PhD Students Cope with Paper Rejections}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2009.00406},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2009.00406},
}
Figure