TL;DR
This paper explores how firms decide on the number of IT suppliers they work with, moving beyond simple cost considerations to incorporate trust, repeated interactions, and the specific types of IT used. They found that while technologies reducing search costs encourage more suppliers, vendor-specific IT and the need for trust lead to fewer, more specialized relationships.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Firms constantly grapple with how many suppliers to use for their IT needs. Traditional economic theories offer conflicting advice: some suggest more suppliers increase competition and choice, while others argue fewer suppliers foster trust and encourage investment in specialized services. Existing research often overlooks the crucial role of repeated interactions and the nuanced impact of different types of IT. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a comprehensive model that integrates these factors and tests it with a large-scale global dataset.
Methods
The authors developed a multi-period game theory model that accounts for:
- Search and Coordination Theory: How IT can reduce the costs of finding and working with suppliers.
- Transaction Cost Economics: The costs associated with market transactions and the need to manage opportunism.
- Incomplete Contracts Theory: How to incentivize suppliers to make non-contractible investments when contracts can't cover every contingency.
- Repeated Game Theory: The impact of long-term relationships, trust, and reputation on supplier behavior.
They then empirically tested their model using a survey of 1355 firms across 12 countries.
Datasets
The study utilized a newly collected, global web-based survey of IT sourcing decisions from 1355 firms. This dataset captured information on:
- Number of IT vendors
- Nature of relationships (repeated vs. one-off)
- Organizational and technological determinants (asset specificity, IT use, contract codifiability, etc.)
- Firm characteristics (size, industry, location)
Key Insights and Ideas
- Trust is a Big Deal: Repeated interactions are crucial for building trust, which in turn incentivizes suppliers to make specialized investments, even when contracts are incomplete.
- IT Isn't Monolithic: Different types of IT have opposite effects. Technologies that reduce search and coordination costs (like extranets) lead to more suppliers, while vendor-specific IT (like custom portals) leads to fewer.
- The "Fit" Factor: When firms have unique or diverse needs, they tend to use more suppliers to find the best "fit."
- Trade-offs Abound: Firms constantly balance the benefits of a wider supplier pool (better fit, bargaining power) against the benefits of a smaller pool (trust, incentives for specialization).
Key Results
- Fewer Suppliers, More Repetition: Firms with fewer suppliers are more likely to engage in repeated relationships.
- Asset Specificity Drives Trust: Higher asset specificity (where suppliers need unique knowledge/skills) is strongly correlated with a greater fraction of repeated relationships.
- Coordination IT Boosts Supplier Count: Using coordination technologies (extranets, project management software) is associated with a significant increase in the number of suppliers.
- Vendor-Specific IT Shrinks the Pool: Conversely, using vendor-specific IT (custom portals, vendor management tools) is associated with fewer suppliers.
- Global Differences: Japanese firms tend to have fewer suppliers and more repeated relationships compared to US firms. High-tech sectors generally use more suppliers than low-tech sectors.
Limitations and Future Work
- No Supplier Market Data: The study lacks data on the structure of supplier markets, which could influence firm choices.
- Not Longitudinal: The data captures trends but not the same firms' decisions over time, limiting causal claims.
- Future Work: The authors suggest collecting data on supply-side market structure and conducting longitudinal studies to better understand causal mechanisms.
Summary updated