How to Write a Bias Statement: Recommendations for Submissions to the Workshop on Gender Bias in NLP

Christian Hardmeier, Marta R. Costa-jussà, Kellie Webster, Will Radford, Su Lin BlodgettarXiv 2021 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper provides guidance on how to write effective bias statements for NLP research, encouraging authors to explicitly consider the social implications of their work. It highlights the importance of clarifying the types of harm that can arise from biased NLP systems and offers concrete recommendations for authors to articulate these concerns.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the challenge of ensuring that Natural Language Processing (NLP) research is conducted with a critical awareness of its potential social impacts, particularly concerning gender bias. While NLP systems are increasingly integrated into society, their development often overlooks the broader context of how they might perpetuate or even exacerbate existing societal inequalities. The authors aim to provide a structured way for researchers to articulate how their work relates to these social implications, making the discussion of bias more explicit and actionable. This is crucial because NLP technologies can lead to "allocational harms" (unfair distribution of resources/opportunities) and "representational harms" (negative stereotyping or erasure of social groups).

Methods

The paper doesn't present a novel algorithmic method but rather a methodological recommendation for researchers. The core "method" is the requirement for authors to include an explicit "bias statement" in their submissions. This statement should clarify:

  • The nature of the bias: Why are certain system behaviors considered "bias" and harmful?
  • The type of harm: What specific harms (e.g., allocational, representational) might arise?
  • The affected groups: Who suffers from these harms?
  • Normative reasoning: The underlying values and assumptions guiding the assessment of harm.

The authors suggest making this a dedicated section in papers and encourage critical reflection on the chosen definition of "bias." They also highlight the value of having reviewers with social science and humanities backgrounds to provide feedback on these statements.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bias statements are a tool for critical reflection: They serve as a mechanism to condense and make explicit the discussion around the social implications of NLP research, encouraging a more thoughtful approach from the outset.
  • Understanding types of harm is crucial: Differentiating between allocational harms (e.g., a recruitment system favoring one gender) and representational harms (e.g., stereotyping in language models) helps in articulating the specific risks associated with NLP systems.
  • Normative judgments are inherent: Acknowledging that identifying bias involves making value judgments (e.g., that equal treatment is right) is essential for transparency and evaluation.
  • Social science perspectives enrich NLP review: Including reviewers from humanities and social sciences can provide valuable insights into the real-world impact of NLP technologies and help authors refine their bias statements.
  • The bias statement is a starting point, not an end: The ultimate goal is to integrate this critical thinking throughout the research process, not just as a post-hoc addition.

Key Results

The paper reports on the positive reception of the bias statement requirement at the GeBNLP 2020 workshop. Authors who submitted papers found the requirement helpful, with several receiving useful suggestions and literature hints from the bias reviewers. This positive feedback led the organizers to plan on continuing this feature in future editions of the workshop.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that their schema for categorizing harms is not exhaustive and is intended to spark imagination rather than enforce strict adherence. They encourage authors to adapt the approach to their specific work. Future work implicitly involves continuing to refine the process of incorporating bias statements into the NLP research and review pipeline, fostering a more socially conscious research community.

Summary updated

Abstract

At the Workshop on Gender Bias in NLP (GeBNLP), we'd like to encourage authors to give explicit consideration to the wider aspects of bias and its social implications. For the 2020 edition of the workshop, we therefore requested that all authors include an explicit bias statement in their work to clarify how their work relates to the social context in which NLP systems are used. The programme committee of the workshops included a number of reviewers with a background in the humanities and social sciences, in addition to NLP experts doing the bulk of the reviewing. Each paper was assigned one of those reviewers, and they were asked to pay specific attention to the provided bias statements in their reviews. This initiative was well received by the authors who submitted papers to the workshop, several of whom said they received useful suggestions and literature hints from the bias reviewers. We are therefore planning to keep this feature of the review process in future editions of the workshop.
BibTeX
@misc{hardmeier2021how,
  author = {Christian Hardmeier and Marta R. Costa-jussà and Kellie Webster and Will Radford and Su Lin Blodgett},
  title = {{How to Write a Bias Statement: Recommendations for Submissions to the Workshop on Gender Bias in NLP}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2104.03026},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2104.03026},
}
Figure