How to Shrink Confidence Sets for Many Equivalent Discrete Distributions?

Odalric-Ambrym Maillard, Mohammad Sadegh TalebiarXiv 2024 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Estimating unknown probability distributions from samples is a fundamental task in machine learning. While distributions are typically treated as independent, many real-world scenarios involve "permutation-equivalent" distributions—those identical up to a shuffling of labels. This paper presents a novel method to exploit this hidden structure by pooling data across related distributions without prior knowledge of the specific permutations. We introduce a two-step algorithmic approach to prune incompatible matchings and refine confidence bounds. Our theoretical analysis shows that refined sets achieve faster convergence rates, and empirical results demonstrate significant performance gains in reinforcement learning tasks.

Introduction

In various applications, such as multi-agent systems or robotic navigation in similar environments, we encounter multiple unknown distributions that share the same underlying structure but differ in their labeling. For instance, different agents might use different indices for the same set of observations. Standard statistical methods treat these as distinct entities, failing to leverage the shared information.

This paper addresses the challenge of permutation-equivalence. If $K$ distributions are permutations of each other, the total available data is effectively $K$ times larger than for any single distribution. However, identifying the correct permutation is a computationally hard (NP-hard) problem. We propose a method to obtain tighter confidence sets that are statistically valid and computationally efficient, even without solving the exact matching problem.

Methodology: Refined Confidence Sets

Our approach consists of two primary algorithms designed to tighten initial confidence intervals by pooling samples across distributions.

1. Pruning Compatible Matchings

Instead of searching for a single true permutation, we maintain a set of "plausible" matchings. We construct a graph where edges represent potential correspondences between labels in different distributions. An edge is pruned if the initial (loose) confidence intervals for the corresponding labels do not overlap. To maintain computational efficiency, we introduce a parameter $L$ that limits the search depth, ensuring the algorithm runs in low-polynomial time.

2. Refinement and Pooling

Once plausible matchings are identified, we pool samples:

  • Singletons: If a label in one distribution matches exactly one label in another, their samples are combined directly, effectively increasing the sample size.
  • Ambiguity: In cases of multiple plausible matches, we employ a "union of intersections" strategy. This ensures that the resulting refined confidence set remains statistically sound while being significantly smaller than the original.
Comparison of original (left) and refined (right) confidence sets for two distributions. The refined sets (green) are visibly tighter around the true values (dots).

To facilitate theoretical analysis, we introduce Surrogate Confidence Intervals. These tools allow us to derive finite-time, high-probability bounds on the shrinkage of the refined sets, simplifying complex concentration inequalities into a more manageable form.

Key Results and Insights

The proposed method yields substantial improvements in both statistical precision and downstream task performance.

Asymptotic Convergence

A key theoretical insight is the gain in convergence rates. For points within the support of a distribution, the refined confidence set size shrinks at a rate of $O(1/\sqrt{\sum n_k})$, mimicking a scenario where all samples belong to a single distribution. For points outside the support (zero probability), the shrinkage is even faster: $O(1/\max n_k)$.

Empirical Performance

We evaluated our method on synthetic discrete distributions and standard reinforcement learning benchmarks.

Comparison of original (left) and refined (right) confidence sets for three distributions over a larger alphabet. The refinement process consistently produces tighter bounds across all distributions.

In synthetic tests, even with a minimal search depth ($L=1$), the algorithm reduced the size of confidence intervals by 1.1x to 1.8x on average. In the RiverSwim environment, we integrated our refinement strategy into the UCRL2B algorithm (C-UCRL2B). This led to a substantial reduction in cumulative regret, as the agent learned optimal policies faster by recognizing shared transition structures across different states.

Conclusion

This work demonstrates that permutation-equivalence can be effectively exploited to improve statistical estimation without incurring prohibitive computational costs. By pooling data through a "plausible matching" framework, we achieve tighter confidence sets and improved performance in reinforcement learning. Future research will explore extensions to continuous distributions and "near-equivalent" scenarios where distributions are similar but not identical permutations.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider the situation when a learner faces a set of unknown discrete distributions $(p_k)_{k\in \mathcal K}$ defined over a common alphabet $\mathcal X$, and can build for each distribution $p_k$ an individual high-probability confidence set thanks to $n_k$ observations sampled from $p_k$. The set $(p_k)_{k\in \mathcal K}$ is structured: each distribution $p_k$ is obtained from the same common, but unknown, distribution q via applying an unknown permutation to $\mathcal X$. We call this \emph{permutation-equivalence}. The goal is to build refined confidence sets \emph{exploiting} this structural property. Like other popular notions of structure (Lipschitz smoothness, Linearity, etc.) permutation-equivalence naturally appears in machine learning problems, and to benefit from its potential gain calls for a specific approach. We present a strategy to effectively exploit permutation-equivalence, and provide a finite-time high-probability bound on the size of the refined confidence sets output by the strategy. Since a refinement is not possible for too few observations in general, under mild technical assumptions, our finite-time analysis establish when the number of observations $(n_k)_{k\in \mathcal K}$ are large enough so that the output confidence sets improve over initial individual sets. We carefully characterize this event and the corresponding improvement. Further, our result implies that the size of confidence sets shrink at asymptotic rates of $O(1/\sqrt{\sum_{k\in \mathcal K} n_k})$ and $O(1/\max_{k\in K} n_{k})$, respectively for elements inside and outside the support of q, when the size of each individual confidence set shrinks at respective rates of $O(1/\sqrt{n_k})$ and $O(1/n_k)$. We illustrate the practical benefit of exploiting permutation equivalence on a reinforcement learning task.
BibTeX
@misc{maillard2024how,
  author = {Odalric-Ambrym Maillard and Mohammad Sadegh Talebi},
  title = {{How to Shrink Confidence Sets for Many Equivalent Discrete Distributions?}},
  year = {2024},
  eprint = {2407.15662},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2407.15662},
}
Figure