How honeybees respond to heat stress from the individual to colony level

Jitesh Jhawar, Jacob D. Davidson, Anja Weidenmüller, Benjamin Wild, David M Dormagen, Tim Landgraf, Iain D. Couzin, Michael L. SmithJournal of The Royal Society Interface 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses automated tracking of thousands of individual honeybees to reveal how a colony collectively responds to heat stress. They found that bees reorganize spatially, increase activity, and that individual responses are influenced by age and prior behavior, but the colony quickly recovers once the stress is removed.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Maintaining a stable internal environment (homeostasis) is crucial for the survival and reproduction of social insect colonies. For honeybees, this includes regulating nest temperature, especially during periods of heat stress. While we know individual bees engage in specific thermoregulatory behaviors like fanning and water collection, there's a significant gap in understanding how these individual actions are coordinated at the colony level and how an individual bee's past behavior influences its response to a sudden environmental challenge like heat. This paper aims to bridge this gap by examining responses from the individual bee to the entire superorganism.

Methods

The researchers employed an advanced automated tracking system called "BeesBook" to monitor thousands of individually tagged honeybees within a three-frame observation hive. They experimentally induced heat stress by raising the room temperature to approximately 45°C for a three-hour period on multiple days.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • High-throughput Tracking: Bees were individually marked with unique tags, allowing for continuous, long-term tracking of thousands of individuals.
  • Behavioral Metrics: A comprehensive set of behavioral metrics were calculated for each bee, including time spent in different nest areas (brood, honey, exit frame), time observed, time outside the nest, number of outside trips, speed, and dispersion (a measure of how far a bee ranges within the nest).
  • Spatial Mapping: The nest was meticulously mapped into distinct regions (brood, honey, pollen, etc.) to analyze spatial reorganization.
  • Principal Component Analysis (PCA) and Clustering: These statistical techniques were used to reduce the dimensionality of the behavioral data and identify distinct behavioral groups (clusters) of bees, both before and during heat stress. This allowed for a generalized analysis of individual responses.
  • Correlation Analysis: The study analyzed the correlation of behavioral metrics over time to assess the duration of heat stress effects on individual bee behavior.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from a single honeybee colony housed in a three-frame observation hive over the summer of 2019. Thousands of individual bees were tracked, with data collected on control days (normal conditions) and during experimental heat stress trials. The paper also references and builds upon data from previous studies using similar tracking methodologies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Colony-Level Reorganization is Key: The most striking insight is that a heat stress doesn't just cause individual bees to fan harder; it triggers a significant spatial reorganization of the entire colony. Bees move away from the brood areas (where temperature regulation is critical) towards honey stores, and some even exit the nest.
  • Individual Responses Vary, But Are Coordinated: While not all bees respond identically, the overall trend is an increase in activity and dispersion. This suggests a coordinated, colony-wide shift in behavior rather than isolated individual actions.
  • Age and Prior Behavior Matter: An individual bee's response to heat stress is not random. Age plays a role, with older bees being more likely to exit the nest. Furthermore, a bee's behavior before the heat stress (e.g., being near the exit) predicts its behavior during the heat stress.
  • Resilience and Rapid Recovery: Despite the significant behavioral shifts during heat stress, the colony demonstrates remarkable resilience. Once the heat stress is removed, behavioral correlations return to baseline levels relatively quickly, indicating that the perturbation doesn't have a long-lasting impact on individual trajectories.

Key Results

  • Spatial Shift: During heat stress, bees spent less time in central brood areas and more time in honey storage areas at the top of the nest.
  • Increased Activity: Nearly all bees showed an increase in average speed and dispersion, indicating a general rise in activity levels and ranging behavior.
  • Reduced "Specialists": The number of bees consistently occupying specific nest substrates (termed "specialists") decreased, likely due to increased dispersion.
  • Age-Related Exit Behavior: Bees that exited the nest during heat stress tended to be older and were already located near the nest exit or outside before the stress began.
  • Brood Care to Honey Stores: Bees engaged in brood care in the morning tended to move to honey areas during heat stress, effectively clearing the brood nest.
  • Behavioral Correlation Recovery: The correlation coefficient of behavioral metrics returned to pre-heat stress levels by the evening of the heat stress days, demonstrating rapid recovery.

Limitations and Future Work

  • "Specialist" Definition: The study notes that their definition of "specialist" is based on spatial location, not observed task performance, which is a limitation in directly inferring task-specific behavior.
  • Generalizability: While the study used a single colony, future work could explore variations across different colonies or environmental conditions.
  • Targeted Manipulations: The authors suggest future research could use targeted manipulations (e.g., removing older/younger bees, altering nest structure) to further investigate the influence of age distribution and within-nest structure on colony responses.
  • Beyond Age: Investigating other individual factors like gene expression or neuromodulatory factors could provide deeper insights into heat response mechanisms.
  • Behavioral Event Detection: Combining automated tracking with machine learning to detect specific behavioral events (like fanning) could offer more granular analysis of switching dynamics.

Summary updated

Abstract

A honey bee colony functions as an integrated collective, with individuals coordinating their behaviour to adapt and respond to unexpected disturbances. Nest homeostasis is critical for colony function; when ambient temperatures increase, individuals switch to thermoregulatory roles to cool the nest, such as fanning and water collection. While prior work has focused on bees engaged in specific behaviours, less is known about how responses are coordinated at the colony level, and how previous tasks predict behavioural changes during a heat stress. Using BeesBook automated tracking, we follow thousands of individuals during an experimentally induced heat stress, and analyse their behavioural changes from the individual to colony level. We show that heat stress causes an overall increase in activity levels and a spatial reorganization of bees away from the brood area. Using a generalized framework to analyse individual behaviour, we find that individuals differ in their response to heat stress, which depends on their prior behaviour and correlates with age. Examining the correlation of behavioural metrics over time suggests that heat stress perturbation does not have a long-lasting effect on an individual's future behaviour. These results demonstrate how thousands of individuals within a colony change their behaviour to achieve a coordinated response to an environmental disturbance.
BibTeX
@article{jhawar2023how,
  author = {Jitesh Jhawar and Jacob D. Davidson and Anja Weidenmüller and Benjamin Wild and David M Dormagen and Tim Landgraf and Iain D. Couzin and Michael L. Smith},
  title = {{How honeybees respond to heat stress from the individual to colony level}},
  journal = {Journal of The Royal Society Interface},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1098/rsif.2023.0290},
}
Figure