How Environmental Regulation Affects Rural Residents’ Willingness to Pay for Sustainable Domestic Sewage Treatment: Mediating and Interaction Effects

Jian Jiao, Zihong Yang, Boyang Shi, Thomas Dogot, Hossein Azadi, Ke Xu, Changbin YinWater 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how different types of environmental regulations influence rural residents' willingness to pay (WTP) for domestic sewage treatment in China. It finds that guiding and incentive regulations are effective, while binding regulations are not, and that residents' environmental cognition plays a crucial mediating role. The research highlights the importance of combining regulations strategically, suggesting substitution between guiding and incentive approaches, and complementarity between guiding/incentive and binding regulations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Rural domestic sewage treatment (RDST) is a significant environmental challenge, particularly in developing countries like China, where a large portion of sewage is released untreated. This leads to water pollution, soil degradation, and threats to human health. While government investment is crucial, it's insufficient to cover the costs of RDST, especially for operation and maintenance. To address this, establishing effective payment mechanisms where rural residents contribute is essential. However, understanding what drives rural residents' willingness to pay (WTP) and their actual payment levels for RDST is complex. This paper aims to unravel the influence of various environmental regulations on this WTP, exploring not just their direct effects but also the underlying mechanisms and how different regulatory approaches interact.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted econometric approach to analyze their data. They used:

  • Binary Logit Regression: To model the binary outcome of rural residents' willingness to pay (Yes/No) for RDST.
  • Tobit Model: To analyze the continuous variable of the payment level rural residents are willing to contribute monthly, accounting for the censored data where some respondents refused to pay.
  • Mediation Effect Model (using KHB method): To test how rural residents' environmental cognition acts as a mediator between environmental regulations and their WTP/payment level. This method is particularly useful for nonlinear models.
  • Interaction Effect Model: To examine how different combinations of environmental regulations (guiding, incentive, binding) interact with each other to influence WTP and payment.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from a survey of 744 rural residents in Jilin, Shandong, and Gansu provinces in northern China between September and November 2020. The selection of these provinces was based on their representation of different economic development levels and geographical regions within northern China.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Regulation Type Matters: Not all environmental regulations are created equal when it comes to influencing rural residents' WTP. Guiding and incentive approaches seem to be the most effective.
  • Cognition is Key: Rural residents' understanding and awareness of environmental issues (their "cognition") are critical intermediaries. Regulations that boost this cognition are more likely to translate into WTP.
  • Synergy and Substitution: Environmental regulations don't operate in isolation. Understanding their interplay is crucial for effective policy design. The findings suggest that some regulations can substitute for each other, while others can amplify each other's effects.
  • Binding Regulations' Limited Impact: The study's finding that binding regulations (like fines) had a limited impact is particularly interesting, suggesting that punitive measures alone may not be sufficient or even counterproductive in this context.

Key Results

  • High WTP, Low Payment: A significant majority of rural residents (83.5%) expressed a willingness to pay for sustainable RDST. However, their actual payment levels were relatively low, averaging CNY 8.14/month, which covers about 47.55% of maintenance costs.
  • Guiding & Incentive Regulations Boost WTP: Both guiding (e.g., public awareness campaigns) and incentive (e.g., subsidies) regulations positively and significantly increased rural residents' WTP and payment levels. Guiding regulations showed a stronger effect.
  • Binding Regulations Ineffective: Binding regulations had a non-significant impact on rural residents' WTP and payment levels.
  • Cognition Mediates Effects: Rural residents' cognition significantly mediated the positive effects of guiding and incentive regulations on their WTP and payment. For WTP, the indirect effect through cognition accounted for 27.25% (guiding) and 18.26% (incentive) of the total effect.
  • Interaction Effects:
    • Guiding and incentive regulations showed a substitution relationship, meaning one could potentially compensate for the weakness of the other.
  • Guiding and binding regulations, as well as incentive and binding regulations, demonstrated a complementary relationship, suggesting they work better together.
  • The interaction of all three regulations together had no significant effect, implying that an excessive combination might lead to diminishing returns or "policy failure."

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Zero Payment Refusal: The study couldn't fully explore the reasons behind respondents who refused to pay (zero payment level), suggesting future research should delve into this.
  • Alternative Mechanisms: The study explored one mediating mechanism (cognition), but other effect mechanisms of environmental regulations on WTP might exist and warrant further investigation.
  • Regional Heterogeneity: The study focused on northern China. Future research should explore the appropriateness and impact of different regulatory combinations across diverse regions with varying economic development and institutional levels.

The authors suggest that future work should investigate these areas to provide more comprehensive insights for policy development.

Summary updated

Abstract

Exploring the construction of effective payment mechanisms for rural residents could break the dilemma of the value of a single investment by the government in environmental governance and promote the process of sustainable rural domestic sewage treatment (RDST). The effects of environmental regulations have been roughly approved; however, their influence mechanisms on rural residents’ willingness to pay (WTP) and payment level for sustainable RDST have not been fully revealed. Based on a database of 744 respondents, an integrated model was developed to verify the heterogeneous effects of three environmental regulations on rural residents’ WTP and further explore their interaction effects and impact mechanisms. In addition, there is an urgent necessity to explore the effectiveness of implementing different combinations of environmental regulations. Our results indicated that, firstly, the guiding regulation and incentive regulation promoted rural residents’ WTP and payment level, whereas the binding regulation had a limited impact on individuals. Secondly, rural residents’ cognition mediated the effect of the environmental regulations on their WTP and payment level. Lastly, the guiding and incentive regulations showed a substitution relationship, while both guiding and binding regulations as well as incentive and binding regulations revealed a complementary relationship. The implications of these results indicate the importance of strengthening the public attention on the environmental and health hazards of rural domestic sewage and effectively raising rural residents’ environmental cognition and environmental protection awareness, thereby increasing their WTP and payment level for sustainable RDST. This study provides credible references and recommendations for environmental regulations’ formulation and policy optimization for RDST, as well as for the construction of payment systems for rural residents, and inspiration for rural environment management in other developing countries.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{jiao2024how,
  author = {Jian Jiao and Zihong Yang and Boyang Shi and Thomas Dogot and Hossein Azadi and Ke Xu and Changbin Yin},
  title = {{How Environmental Regulation Affects Rural Residents’ Willingness to Pay for Sustainable Domestic Sewage Treatment: Mediating and Interaction Effects}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/w16050761},
}
Figure