How Early is Infants' Attention to Objects and Actions Shaped by Culture? New Evidence from 24-Month-Olds Raised in the US and China

Sandra R. Waxman, Xiaolan Fu, Brock Ferguson, Kathleen Geraghty, Erin M. Leddon, Jing Liang, Min-Fang ZhaoFrontiers in Psychology 2016 · DOI

Abstract

Researchers have proposed that the culture in which we are raised shapes the way that we attend to the objects and events that surround us. What remains unclear, however, is how early any such culturally-inflected differences emerge in development. Here, we address this issue directly, asking how 24-month-old infants from the US and China deploy their attention to objects and actions in dynamic scenes. By analyzing infants' eye movements while they observed dynamic scenes, the current experiment revealed striking convergences, overall, in infants' patterns of visual attention in the two communities, but also pinpointed a brief period during which their attention reliably diverged. This divergence, though modest, suggested that infants from the US devoted relatively more attention to the objects and those from China devoted relatively more attention to the actions in which they were engaged. This provides the earliest evidence for strong overlap in infants' attention to objects and events in dynamic scenes, but also raises the possibility that by 24 months, infants' attention may also be shaped subtly by the culturally-inflected attentional proclivities characteristic of adults in their cultural communities.

Introduction

Psychologists have long observed that the culture in which an individual is raised significantly influences their cognitive processing and attentional focus. Adults from Western cultures, such as the United States, typically exhibit an "analytic" cognitive style, focusing on focal objects and their properties. In contrast, adults from East Asian cultures, such as China or Japan, often display a "holistic" style, attending more to the context, background, and the relationships or actions connecting objects.

While these cultural differences are well-documented in adults and older children, the developmental timeline of their emergence remains a subject of intense debate. Does this "cultural lens" develop only after years of formal education and complex language acquisition, or is it integrated into early perceptual development? Previous research has identified these differences in children as young as three or four years old. This study pushes the boundary further, investigating whether 24-month-old infants already show signs of culturally-inflected attentional proclivities during the critical window of early word learning.

Methodology

The researchers utilized a high-resolution eye-tracking paradigm to monitor the real-time gaze patterns of 40 monolingual 24-month-old infants (20 from the US and 20 from China). To ensure comparability, vocabulary sizes were assessed using the MacArthur-Bates Communicative Development Inventories (MCDI for the US and PCDI for China), confirming that all participants fell within the normal range for their respective regions.

Experimental Design

The experiment consisted of a familiarization phase followed by a test phase. During familiarization, infants watched dynamic videos of an actor performing a specific action on a specific object.

Example of a familiarization scene where an actor performs a consistent action on an object.

In the subsequent test phase, infants were presented with two new scenes side-by-side:

  1. New Object—Familiar Action: The same actor performed the familiar action on a novel object.
  2. New Action—Familiar Object: The same actor performed a novel action on the familiar object.
Example of a test scene illustrating a 'New Action' performed on a familiar object.

Data Analysis

The study moved beyond simple average looking times, employing Growth Curve Analysis (GCA) and cluster-based permutation analysis. These advanced statistical methods allowed the researchers to identify precisely when during the 5-second test window infants' attention diverged, providing a granular view of cognitive processing.

Results and Key Insights

The findings revealed a complex interplay between universal developmental foundations and early cultural shaping.

Convergence and the "Native Looker"

The most prominent result was the high degree of similarity between the two groups. For the majority of the trial duration, infants from both the US and China deployed their attention in nearly identical patterns. This suggests a robust, universal foundation for processing dynamic events in early childhood.

However, the study also provided evidence for the "native looker" hypothesis. Much as infants transition from "citizens of the world" to "native listeners" in phonology, they appear to be becoming "native lookers" by 24 months.

Statistical Divergence

The GCA revealed a significant interaction between culture and time (specifically the cubic time parameter, $p = 0.034$). A cluster-based permutation analysis pinpointed a specific window between 2.20 and 3.05 seconds into the test trial where the two groups' gaze patterns reliably diverged.

During this window, US infants showed a relative preference for the new object scene, while Chinese infants showed a relative preference for the new action scene. This divergence aligns with the object-oriented vs. action-oriented divide observed in adults from these respective cultures. Notably, this divergence occurred during a "baseline" period following a neutral linguistic prompt ("Now look, they're different"), suggesting a default attentional bias independent of specific naming cues.

Discussion and Future Directions

This research provides the earliest evidence to date of culturally-inflected differences in visual attention. While the effect was modest and transient (lasting approximately one second), its statistical robustness and alignment with theoretical predictions are significant.

Limitations

The study's primary limitation is its sample size (N=40). Future research should aim to replicate these findings with larger and more socioeconomically diverse cohorts. Additionally, the exact trigger for the 2-second divergence remains unclear—it may reflect the time required to compute scene differences or be a response to the offset of the audio prompt.

Future Work

The "starting point" of this cultural shaping remains unknown; testing infants at 12 or 18 months could help identify the earliest emergence of these patterns. Furthermore, while the authors hypothesize that parental communication styles (e.g., US parents emphasizing nouns vs. Chinese parents emphasizing verbs) drive this development, direct measurement of parent-child interactions is needed to confirm this link.

Summary updated

Abstract

Researchers have proposed that the culture in which we are raised shapes the way that we attend to the objects and events that surround us. What remains unclear, however, is how early any such culturally-inflected differences emerge in development. Here, we address this issue directly, asking how 24-month-old infants from the US and China deploy their attention to objects and actions in dynamic scenes. By analyzing infants' eye movements while they observed dynamic scenes, the current experiment revealed striking convergences, overall, in infants' patterns of visual attention in the two communities, but also pinpointed a brief period during which their attention reliably diverged. This divergence, though modest, suggested that infants from the US devoted relatively more attention to the objects and those from China devoted relatively more attention to the actions in which they were engaged. This provides the earliest evidence for strong overlap in infants' attention to objects and events in dynamic scenes, but also raises the possibility that by 24 months, infants' attention may also be shaped subtly by the culturally-inflected attentional proclivities characteristic of adults in their cultural communities.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{waxman2016how,
  author = {Sandra R. Waxman and Xiaolan Fu and Brock Ferguson and Kathleen Geraghty and Erin M. Leddon and Jing Liang and Min-Fang Zhao},
  title = {{How Early is Infants' Attention to Objects and Actions Shaped by Culture? New Evidence from 24-Month-Olds Raised in the US and China}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2016.00097},
}
Figure