How Does the Relevance of Firm-Generated Content to Products Affect Consumer Brand Attitudes?

Yao Li, Ying Yin, Zhiqiang WangJ. Theor. Appl. Electron. Commer. Res 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This research reveals that firm-generated content (FGC) that is highly relevant to product attributes significantly boosts consumer brand attitudes, with brand authenticity acting as a key mediator. The impact of this relevance is further amplified for time-honored brands and consumers with an analytic thinking style.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In today's digital landscape, brands increasingly rely on social media to connect with consumers. Firm-generated content (FGC) – content created by companies themselves – is a prominent tool in this strategy. While previous research has explored FGC's effectiveness in areas like brand engagement and equity, its direct impact on consumer brand attitudes, a crucial factor for long-term relationships, remains underexplored. Specifically, the paper identifies a gap in understanding how the relevance of FGC to actual product attributes influences these attitudes, and what factors might amplify or diminish this effect.

Methods

The study employs a series of four experimental studies to investigate the relationship between FGC's product relevance and consumer brand attitudes.

  • Experimental Design: A between-subjects design was used across all studies, manipulating FGC's relevance to products as either "high" or "low."
  • Mediator Analysis: Brand authenticity was tested as a mediating factor in the relationship between FGC relevance and brand attitudes.
  • Moderator Analysis: Two key moderators were examined:
  • Brand Type: Differentiating between "time-honored" brands with established heritage and "new" brands focused on innovation.
  • Consumer Thinking Style: Categorizing participants into "analytic" (focusing on parts and rules) and "holistic" (focusing on relationships and context) thinkers.
  • Stimuli: Fictitious brands ("Mo Bai" for liquor, "Lanmi" for mobile phones) were used to control for brand familiarity. Stimuli included text-based and image-based FGC, carefully selected based on pre-tests to ensure distinct levels of product relevance.
  • Measures: Standardized scales were used to measure FGC relevance, brand authenticity, and brand attitudes.
  • Statistical Analysis: ANOVA was used for main effects and interaction analyses, while mediation was tested using bootstrapping.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on experimental stimuli created by the researchers, not pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Relevance is King (for Attitudes): The core finding is that simply making FGC about the product matters. Content that directly highlights product attributes has a stronger positive impact on how consumers feel about a brand than content that is more abstract or narrative.
  • Authenticity as the Bridge: Brand authenticity isn't just a nice-to-have; it's the mechanism through which product-relevant FGC translates into better brand attitudes. High product relevance seems to signal a brand's genuine commitment, fostering authenticity.
  • Heritage Matters: Time-honored brands benefit more from highly product-relevant FGC. This aligns with consumer expectations for brands with a long history, where tradition and quality are paramount. For newer brands, there's more flexibility, and the impact of product relevance is less pronounced.
  • Thinking Style Shapes Perception: Analytic thinkers are more swayed by product-relevant FGC, using it as a key piece of information. Holistic thinkers, however, seem to integrate FGC relevance into a broader set of considerations, making them less directly influenced by it alone.

Key Results

  • H1 Confirmed: FGC's relevance to products positively affects consumer brand attitudes across all studies.
  • H2 Supported: Brand authenticity mediates the effect of FGC's relevance to products on consumer brand attitudes.
  • H3 Supported: Brand type moderates the effect. High product-relevant FGC had a significantly stronger positive impact on brand attitudes and authenticity for time-honored brands compared to new brands.
  • H4 Supported: Consumer thinking style moderates the effect. Analytic thinkers showed significantly higher brand attitudes and authenticity with high product-relevant FGC, while holistic thinkers showed no significant difference.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample Demographics: The study primarily used younger, highly educated participants. Future research should include diverse age groups, education levels, and cultural backgrounds to broaden generalizability.
  • Product Categories: The experiments focused on liquor and mobile phones. Future work could explore other product types (symbolic vs. functional) to see if these findings hold across industries.
  • Stimuli Format: The study used text and image-based FGC. Future research could investigate video or multimedia formats.
  • Real-World Data: Incorporating real-world brand data and consumer interactions would enhance the validation of these findings.
  • Measurement of FGC Relevance: Exploring alternative methods for measuring FGC relevance, such as qualitative approaches or text mining, could further strengthen the findings.
  • Additional Outcomes: Future studies could examine FGC's relevance on other outcomes like brand awareness or loyalty.
  • Other Moderators: Factors like cultural differences, consumer psychological traits, and prior brand experiences could also be explored as moderators.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{li2024how,
  author = {Yao Li and Ying Yin and Zhiqiang Wang},
  title = {{How Does the Relevance of Firm-Generated Content to Products Affect Consumer Brand Attitudes?}},
  journal = {J. Theor. Appl. Electron. Commer. Res.},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/jtaer20010019},
}
Figure