How Does the Experience of Forest Recreation Spaces in Different Seasons Affect the Physical and Mental Recovery of Users?

Rui Chen, Yu Gao, Ruixin Zhang, Zhi Zhang, Weikang Zhang, Huan Meng, Tong ZhangInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that forest recreation spaces offer significant physical and mental recovery benefits, with the effectiveness varying by landscape type and season. The research highlights that "natural form" is particularly crucial for recovery in spring, while "natural attributes" play a more direct role in autumn, suggesting a nuanced approach to designing restorative forest environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As urbanization increases, access to nature diminishes, breaking the vital connection between humans and the natural world. This disconnect has led to a growing interest in understanding how natural environments, specifically forests, can positively impact human health. While previous research has established the restorative effects of forests, there's a need for a deeper understanding of how different types of forest landscapes and their seasonal variations influence both physical and mental well-being. This paper aims to bridge this gap by exploring the nuanced relationship between landscape perception, seasonal characteristics, and the restorative outcomes experienced by individuals in forest recreation spaces.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to investigate the impact of forest recreation spaces. They utilized virtual reality (VR) videos to simulate different forest landscapes, allowing participants to experience these environments without the logistical challenges of in-person visits. Physiological measures, including blood pressure (systolic and diastolic) and heart rate, were recorded to assess physical recovery. Psychological states were evaluated using the Mood Check List-Short form.2 (MCL-S.2), which measures pleasantness, relaxation, and anxiety. Landscape perception was assessed through questionnaires measuring perceived naturalness, environmental preference, and perceived restorativeness. Statistical analyses included paired-samples t-tests, one-way ANOVAs, independent-samples t-tests, and structural equation modeling (SEM) to analyze the relationships between these variables and to understand the underlying mechanisms of recovery.

Datasets

The study did not introduce new benchmark datasets. Instead, it utilized existing forest recreation areas as study sites. These sites were selected based on expert evaluation of their physical characteristics and included six distinct types of forest landscapes: dynamic water, static water, lookout, coniferous forest, broadleaved forest, and mixed forest. The VR videos were created from these actual locations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Seasonality Matters, A Lot: The study strongly emphasizes that the season significantly alters how we perceive and recover in forest spaces. This isn't just about aesthetics; it directly impacts our physiological and psychological states.
  • "Natural Form" vs. "Natural Attributes": The research distinguishes between the physical structure and elements of a landscape ("natural form") and its inherent qualities like vegetation density or soundscape ("natural attributes"). The relative importance of these shifts seasonally, with "natural form" being more critical in spring.
  • Gradual Restoration Process: Recovery isn't instantaneous. It's a journey that moves from initial cognitive appraisal of the environment to emotional responses, and then to physiological and psychological benefits.
  • Water and Lookout Views Reign Supreme (Generally): Landscapes featuring water and scenic viewpoints consistently scored higher in terms of perception and recovery compared to dense in-forest settings. This aligns with theories suggesting a preference for open spaces and expansive views.
  • The Unexpected Impact of Wildlife: The study hints that encountering insects or small animals can provide unexpected positive boosts to recovery, suggesting that biodiversity can play a role in enhancing the restorative experience.

Key Results

  • Physiological Benefits: Viewing forest VR videos led to significant decreases in blood pressure and heart rate, indicating a positive physiological impact.
  • Psychological Benefits: Participants reported increased pleasantness and relaxation, along with decreased anxiety, after experiencing the forest environments.
  • Landscape Type Differences: Water and lookout landscapes showed significantly higher restoration effects compared to in-forest landscapes.
  • Seasonal Differences:
    • Dynamic water landscapes showed significantly higher physiological recovery in spring than in autumn.
  • Mixed forest landscapes in autumn promoted SBP recovery, while broadleaved forest landscapes in autumn promoted DBP recovery.
  • Overall, water and lookout landscapes generally led to better BP recovery in spring, while in-forest landscapes showed better BP recovery in autumn.
  • Perception Differences:
    • Water and lookout landscapes generally received higher perceptual evaluations than in-forest landscapes.
  • Perceived naturalness was generally higher in autumn, while environmental preference for waterscapes was higher in spring.
  • Perceived restorativeness was higher in spring for dynamic water and mixed forest landscapes.
  • SEM Findings: Landscape perception significantly impacts physical and mental recovery. Perceived naturalness influences psychological recovery through environmental preference and perceived restorativeness. In autumn, natural attributes directly impact physiological recovery, whereas in spring, natural form mediates this effect.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Limited Dimensions of Perceived Naturalness: The study used a specific set of indicators for perceived naturalness and suggests future research could incorporate more objective measures like visible green index, tree age, and species diversity.
  • Focus on Spring and Autumn: The research only explored spring and autumn. The recovery effects of forest spaces in summer and winter, particularly in northern China, require further investigation.
  • Visual Bias: Landscape perception is multisensory. Future studies should incorporate other sensory preferences, such as hearing and smell, to provide a more comprehensive understanding.
  • Demographic Factors: The study's demographic scope was limited. Future research should include a wider range of participants to explore how factors like gender, occupation, and educational background influence landscape perception and preferences.

Summary updated

Abstract

(1) The restoration effect and perception of forest recreation spaces on people are influenced by space types and seasonal factors. (2) People's restoration from forest environments is a gradual process from spatial cognition to emotional response. (3) The perception of the natural attributes and form of the recreation space plays a key role in the restorative effect of the environment to people, while the natural form is more important in spring than autumn. Based on the above conclusions, we suggest that the characteristic factors of the landscape environment and their different restoration effects for users in different dimensions should be considered when planning forest recreation space.
BibTeX
@article{chen2023how,
  author = {Rui Chen and Yu Gao and Ruixin Zhang and Zhi Zhang and Weikang Zhang and Huan Meng and Tong Zhang},
  title = {{How Does the Experience of Forest Recreation Spaces in Different Seasons Affect the Physical and Mental Recovery of Users?}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph20032357},
}
Figure