How Does Gender Stereotype Affect the Memory of Advertisements? A Behavioral and Electroencephalography Study

Shih-Yu Lo, J.t. King, Chin‐Teng LinFrontiers in Psychology 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how gender stereotypes in advertisements influence memory and purchase intention. It found that advertisements violating gender stereotypes (incongruent) are better remembered, likely due to deeper cognitive processing. Interestingly, stereotype-congruent ads, especially with celebrity endorsers, led to higher purchase intentions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles the inconsistent findings in previous research regarding whether unusual or atypical events are more memorable than typical ones. The authors hypothesize that this inconsistency might stem from the use of recall tasks, which can allow participants to infer answers based on their existing schemas (like stereotypes) rather than purely recalling the presented information. They aim to clarify this by using a recognition memory task and exploring the specific impact of gender stereotypes in advertisements on both memory and consumer behavior.

Methods

The study employed a multi-pronged approach across three experiments:

  • Experiments 1 & 2 (Behavioral): These experiments used a recognition memory task. Participants viewed advertisements that were either stereotype-congruent (e.g., a woman endorsing a perfume) or stereotype-incongruent (e.g., a woman endorsing a car). After a delay, they were tested on their ability to distinguish between ads they had seen before and new ones. Experiment 1 used real advertisements, while Experiment 2 used synthesized ads to control for endorser popularity. Purchase intention was also measured.
  • Experiment 3 (EEG): This experiment used electroencephalography (EEG) to measure brain activity during the recognition task. The focus was on the "parietal old/new effect," a brain signal associated with recollection, to investigate the neural mechanisms underlying memory for stereotype-congruent versus incongruent advertisements.

Key methodological choices included:

  • Recognition Task: To minimize inference and focus on actual memory.
  • Varying Presentation Times (83ms vs. 977ms): To explore different stages of visual attention processing.
  • EEG and ERP Analysis: To provide a neuroscientific basis for memory processes, specifically distinguishing between familiarity and recollection.

Datasets

The study utilized two types of advertisement datasets:

  • Experiment 1: Advertisements were downloaded from the internet, including products like perfumes, scooters, shampoos, alcohol, cars, facial creams, rice cookers, laundry powders, and phones.
  • Experiment 2: Advertisements were synthesized using images from an online database (Shutterstock). This experiment excluded phone advertisements as they were considered gender-neutral.
  • Experiment 3: Similar synthesized advertisements were used, with a focus on controlling for low-level visual features like luminance and contrast.

No new benchmarks were introduced; the study relied on existing advertisement materials and synthesized ones.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Incongruity Enhances Memory: Advertisements that violate gender stereotypes are more memorable. This suggests that unexpected or atypical information captures attention and is processed more deeply.
  • Deep Encoding Hypothesis: The enhanced memory for incongruent ads is attributed to deeper cognitive encoding during the initial exposure. This means the brain invests more resources in processing information that challenges existing schemas.
  • Stereotype Congruence and Purchase Intention: While incongruent ads are better remembered, congruent ads, particularly those featuring celebrities, can lead to higher purchase intentions. This highlights a potential dissociation between memory and persuasion.
  • Neural Correlates of Memory: EEG data revealed that stereotype-incongruent advertisements elicited larger positive amplitudes in the left parietal region for repeated items, supporting the deep encoding hypothesis. This suggests a distinct neural pathway for processing and remembering stereotype-violating information.
  • Familiarity vs. Recollection: The study attempted to disentangle familiarity from recollection, with EEG findings suggesting that while congruent ads might feel more familiar, this familiarity doesn't necessarily translate to better recollection.

Key Results

  • Recognition Performance (Experiments 1 & 2): Participants consistently showed higher discriminability (Pr values) for stereotype-incongruent advertisements compared to stereotype-congruent ones. This effect was more pronounced with longer stimulus presentation times (977ms).
  • Purchase Intention (Experiment 1): Participants reported higher purchase intention for stereotype-congruent advertisements, especially when celebrity endorsers were used. This effect was less pronounced with synthesized, non-celebrity endorsers in Experiment 2.
  • EEG Results (Experiment 3): A significant "parietal old/new effect" was observed, with repeated advertisements eliciting higher amplitudes than new ones. Crucially, for repeated advertisements, the left parietal electrodes showed significantly higher amplitudes for incongruent ads compared to congruent ads, supporting the deep encoding hypothesis.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Stimulus Control: While efforts were made to control for low-level features, the authors acknowledge that the stimuli in Experiment 1 were not strictly controlled, and endorser popularity could have been a confounding factor.
  • Generalizability: The study used a limited range of product types, and the findings might not generalize to all advertising contexts.
  • Laboratory Setting: Purchase intention was measured via self-report in a lab setting, which may not fully reflect real-world purchasing behavior. Future work could involve more realistic scenarios with simulated funds.
  • Sample Size: For future research on gender effects, a larger sample size is recommended to increase statistical power.
  • EEG Noise: The EEG waveforms in Experiment 3 were noted as being somewhat noisy, suggesting a need for larger sample sizes per condition to ensure reliability.
  • Quasi-Experimental Design: For future studies on gender effects, a quasi-experimental design with matched participants across gender groups could provide stronger causal inferences.

Summary updated

Abstract

Previous studies have shown equivocal results about whether atypical or unusual events, compared with typical ones, facilitate or inhibit memory. We suspect that the indefinite findings could be partly due to the recall task used in these studies, as the participants might have used inference instead of recall in their responses. In the present study, we tested the recognition memory for real (Experiment 1) and fabricated (Experiment 2) advertisements, which could be congruent or incongruent with gender stereotypes. In congruent advertisements, a female endorser presented a traditionally considered feminine product or a male endorser presented a traditionally considered masculine product, whereas the gender-product type matching reversed in incongruent advertisements. The results of both behavioral experiments revealed that the participants' memory performance for stereotype-incongruent advertisements was higher than for congruent ones. In the event-related potential (ERP) recordings in Experiment 3, larger positive amplitudes were found for stereotype-incongruent advertisements than for congruent advertisements on the left parietal sites, suggesting a deeper encoding process for stereotype-incongruent information than for stereotype-congruent information.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lo2020how,
  author = {Shih-Yu Lo and J.T. King and Chin‐Teng Lin},
  title = {{How Does Gender Stereotype Affect the Memory of Advertisements? A Behavioral and Electroencephalography Study}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2020.01580},
}
Figure