How do servitization challenges affect business performance in servitized firms with different strategic focuses? – An empirical study based on companies adopting servitization in the UK

Wanrong ZhangWarwick 2018

Abstract

Servitization challenges have gained enormous attention from both academics and practitioners, as an increasing number of product-centric companies are actively seeking business growth by adopting a servitization strategy. Although prior studies investigate servitization challenges from multiple aspects, the performance implication of the challenges remains unclear. Moreover, the interplay between the challenges and different servitized businesses needs an in-depth investigation. The aim of this research project is to explore the impacts of servitization challenges on business performance and how they are different in servitized businesses with different strategic focuses. In so doing, a three-step methodology was used. First, a systematic literature review (SLR) was conducted on the servitization challenges, leading to the establishment of a theoretical model illustrating the underlying relationship between servitization challenges (described as organisational structure (OS), business model (BM), development process (DP), customer management (CM) and risk management (RM)), its benefits (in terms of strategic, financial and marketing) and the firm’s performance. Following this, a sequential explanatory mixed method was adopted, in which the quantitative (survey) and the qualitative (case study) studies were conducted in a sequential manner. The quantitative survey plays a dominant role that aims to validate the theoretical model with the engagement of managerial representatives from UK-based servitized companies. After this, a qualitative case study was carried out, as a supplement, to further explain the survey findings and explore how servitization challenges manifest differently in servitized businesses with different strategic focuses. This study generated two key findings: 1) The findings demonstrate that the servitized companies overcoming organisational structure (OS) and business model (BM) challenges have positive impacts on the firm’s performance, while the impact of the other challenges is unsupported. 2) The study suggests that the manifestation of servitization challenges is different in servitized business with different strategic focuses. Particularly, those companies with the intention of supporting the customer’s operation through integrated solutions face more challenges. Overall, this study contributes to the advancement of servitization research by illustrating the performance implication of servitization challenges, and further advances our understanding of how different servitization types interact with the challenges.

Introduction: The "Service Paradox" in Manufacturing

For decades, manufacturers in developed economies have transitioned toward servitization—a strategic shift from selling standalone products to providing integrated product-service systems. A classic example is Rolls-Royce’s "Power by the Hour" model. The primary motivation for this shift is to escape the "commodity trap" of low-cost competition by creating higher value for customers. However, many firms encounter the "service paradox," where the expansion of service offerings leads to increased costs and complexity without a commensurate increase in profitability.

While previous literature has identified various hurdles—ranging from mindset shifts to risk management—research has often been fragmented. There is a lack of empirical evidence connecting specific organizational challenges directly to business performance. This study addresses two critical gaps:

  1. The Performance Link: Identifying which specific challenges (e.g., organizational structure, development processes) directly impact the realization of strategic, financial, and marketing benefits.
  2. The Strategic Context: Determining if these challenges vary between "Product Suppliers" (who offer basic services like spare parts) and "Integrated Solution Providers" (who manage entire customer operations).

Methodology

This research utilized a three-step, sequential explanatory mixed-method approach to ensure both statistical rigor and contextual depth.

1. Systematic Literature Review (SLR)

An analysis of 48 core papers was conducted to construct a theoretical model grounded in the Theory of Constraints (TOC). This model categorized servitization challenges into five domains:

  • Organizational Structure (OS): Internal hierarchy and departmental alignment.
  • Business Model (BM): Value proposition and revenue mechanisms.
  • Development Process (DP): The lifecycle of service creation.
  • Customer Management (CM): Relationship building and co-creation.
  • Risk Management (RM): Mitigating financial and operational liabilities.

2. Quantitative Phase

A web-based survey was distributed to senior decision-makers in 96 UK-based servitized companies across manufacturing and IT sectors. Data analysis was performed using Partial Least Squares Structural Equation Modeling (PLS-SEM), which is particularly effective for exploratory models and smaller sample sizes.

3. Qualitative Phase

To provide depth to the quantitative findings, 13 semi-structured interviews (totaling 9.5 hours) were conducted with senior managers. These interviews helped explain "the why" behind the statistical results and allowed for a comparison between Integrated Solution (IS) providers and Product Suppliers (PS).

Key Findings and Discussion

Strategic Benefits as the Primary Mediator

A pivotal finding of this study is that financial and marketing benefits do not automatically translate into improved business performance. Instead, their impact is mediated by Strategic Benefits (such as product differentiation and the creation of competitive barriers). If a service initiative does not strengthen the firm's strategic position, it is unlikely to improve Return on Investment (ROI).

The "IS vs. PS" Divide

The research highlights a clear distinction in how firms experience challenges based on their strategic focus:

  • Integrated Solution (IS) Providers: These firms face systemic, high-stakes challenges. Their focus on managing customer operations requires significant business model modification and carries higher financial risks due to upfront investments and potential contract penalties.
  • Product Suppliers (PS): These firms primarily face cultural hurdles. A common issue is the "silo" mentality, where traditional sales teams are reluctant to sell intangible services alongside physical products.

Mindset and Structure as Binding Constraints

Consistent with the Theory of Constraints, the study identifies Organizational Structure and Business Model modifications as the primary bottlenecks. Until these core structural issues are resolved, improvements in peripheral areas like development processes or customer management yield negligible impacts on the bottom line.

Results Summary

  • Direct Impacts: Overcoming Business Model (BM) challenges showed a strong positive correlation with both Strategic and Marketing benefits.
  • Performance Drivers: Strategic Benefits (SB) was the only construct with a statistically significant direct path to Business Performance (BP) (path coefficient ≈ 0.379).
  • The "Early Stage" Effect: Challenges in the Development Process (DP) and Risk Management (RM) did not show a significant statistical link to performance. Qualitative data suggests this is because many firms are still in the early stages of integration and have not yet reached the maturity level required to see a performance payoff from these specific areas.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This research provides a roadmap for manufacturers navigating the transition to services. By focusing on organizational structure and business model alignment, firms can better position themselves to reap the strategic rewards of servitization.

However, the study has limitations that suggest avenues for future work:

  • Sample Expansion: Future studies should aim for larger sample sizes to allow for more robust cross-industry generalizations.
  • Geographic Diversity: Replicating this study in emerging markets (e.g., Brazil, China) could reveal how different economic contexts influence servitization success.
  • Broadening Performance Metrics: While this study focused on financial metrics like ROI and net profit, future research could incorporate non-financial indicators such as environmental sustainability or social impact.
  • Longitudinal Analysis: A longitudinal approach tracking firms over a decade would provide valuable insights into how the management of these challenges evolves as a company matures in its service journey.

Summary updated

Abstract

Servitization challenges have gained enormous attention from both academics and practitioners, as an increasing number of product-centric companies are actively seeking business growth by adopting a servitization strategy. Although prior studies investigate servitization challenges from multiple aspects, the performance implication of the challenges remains unclear. Moreover, the interplay between the challenges and different servitized businesses needs an in-depth investigation. The aim of this research project is to explore the impacts of servitization challenges on business performance and how they are different in servitized businesses with different strategic focuses. In so doing, a three-step methodology was used. First, a systematic literature review (SLR) was conducted on the servitization challenges, leading to the establishment of a theoretical model illustrating the underlying relationship between servitization challenges (described as organisational structure (OS), business model (BM), development process (DP), customer management (CM) and risk management (RM)), its benefits (in terms of strategic, financial and marketing) and the firm’s performance. Following this, a sequential explanatory mixed method was adopted, in which the quantitative (survey) (2nd step) and the qualitative (case study) (3rd step) studies were conducted in a sequential manner. The quantitative survey plays a dominant role that aims to validate the theoretical model with the engagement of managerial representatives from UK-based servitized companies. After this, a qualitative case study was carried out, as a supplement, to further explain the survey findings and explore how servitization challenges manifest differently in servitized businesses with different strategic focuses. This study generated two key findings: 1) The findings demonstrate that the servitized companies overcoming organisational structure (OS) and business model (BM) challenges have positive impacts on the firm’s performance, while the impact of the other challenges is unsupported. 2) The study suggests that the manifestation of servitization challenges is different in servitized business with different strategic focuses. Particularly, those companies with the intention of supporting the customer’s operation through integrated solutions face more challenges. Overall, this study contributes to the advancement of servitization research by illustrating the performance implication of servitization challenges, and further advances our understanding of how different servitization types interact with the challenges
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2018how,
  author = {Wanrong Zhang},
  title = {{How do servitization challenges affect business performance in servitized firms with different strategic focuses? – An empirical study based on companies adopting servitization in the UK}},
  booktitle = {Warwick},
  year = {2018},
}
Figure