TL;DR
This study investigates how repeated viewings of forest landscapes affect young people's visual attention and cognitive evaluations. It reveals that while overall cognitive evaluations remain stable, visual behavior shifts towards exploring new areas, and a positive correlation exists between landscape attractiveness and fixation coincidence.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
As urban populations grow and people seek nature closer to home, understanding how individuals interact with suburban forest landscapes becomes crucial for effective design and sustainable management. While previous research has explored single-viewing behaviors, the impact of repeated visits on visual attention and cognitive appraisal, especially in the context of varying landscape preferences, remained underexplored. This paper aims to fill this gap by examining how familiarity gained through repeated viewings influences how young people visually engage with and evaluate forest environments.
Methods
The study employed a combination of eye-tracking technology and psychological evaluations. Participants (52 Chinese undergraduate and graduate students) underwent two viewing sessions of selected forest landscape images, separated by a week. Eye-tracking data was analyzed using cross-recurrence analysis (CRA) to quantify the coincidence of visual behavior (fixation points) between the two viewings. Key CRA metrics included REC (recurrence rate), DET (determinism), LAM (laminarity), and CORM (correlation). Psychological evaluations were conducted using Likert scales and multiple-choice questions to assess participants' perceptions of spatial characteristics, color, landscape change, and overall preference. Statistical analyses included non-parametric tests (K-W, Wilcoxon Signed-Rank) and Spearman correlation to compare differences and explore relationships between visual behavior and cognitive evaluations.
Datasets
The study utilized 56 photographs of five forest parks in eastern Liaoning Province, China, as experimental stimuli. These photos were categorized into high-preference (HP) and low-preference (LP) landscapes based on an initial preference survey. Specifically, three high-preference landscapes (dynamic waterscape HP1, static waterscape HP2, lookout landscape HP3) and three low-preference landscapes (broadleaf forests LP1, LP2, LP3) were selected.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Exploration over Repetition: With repeated viewings, participants showed a tendency to explore new areas rather than fixating on previously seen spots, suggesting a shift from familiarization to discovery.
- Stable Cognition, Shifting Behavior: While participants' overall cognitive evaluations of the landscapes didn't significantly change after a week, their visual behavior patterns did evolve, indicating that familiarity primarily influences how we look, not necessarily what we think of it overall.
- Attractiveness Drives Fixation: A strong positive correlation was found between higher psychological evaluations (liking) of a landscape and a greater degree of fixation coincidence. This suggests that more appealing landscapes lead to more consistent visual attention patterns upon repeated viewing.
- Lookout Landscapes Gain Favor: While waterscapes were generally preferred, lookout landscapes showed a notable increase in participants' favorite elements and positive evaluations with repeated viewings, suggesting their potential for sustained engagement.
Key Results
- Visual Behavior: At the second viewing, participants were more inclined to explore new areas, and the degree of fixation behavior coincidence was generally low across all landscapes, with notable differences between them. Dynamic and static waterscapes showed higher coincidence than lookout and broadleaf forests.
- Cognitive Evaluation: Participants' feature evaluations and comprehensive evaluations of landscapes did not change significantly with increased familiarity. However, the number of favorite elements in the high-preference lookout space noticeably increased at the second viewing.
- Correlation: A significant positive correlation was observed between psychological evaluations and the degree of fixation coincidence. Specifically, distant clarity and overall fixation coincidence were strongly linked.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several limitations:
- Stimulus Selection: While high-preference landscapes were diverse, the low-preference landscapes showed less significant differences, potentially limiting comparative analysis.
- Seasonal Effects: The study focused on spring; seasonal changes in color and vegetation could influence visual behaviors, warranting future investigation.
- On-site vs. Photos: The use of photos instead of on-site surveys might introduce differences in results.
- Participant Demographics: The study focused on young people; future research should include a broader age range.
- Viewing Frequency: Only two viewings were analyzed; exploring the effects of more frequent or spaced-out viewings is suggested.
- CRA Limitations: The CRA method effectively measures similarity but doesn't detail how parts of the visual behavior differ.
Future work could explore these limitations, investigate the impact of seasonal changes, and employ more advanced methods to analyze finer-grained differences in visual behavior.
Summary updated