How Do Internet Enterprises Obtain Sustainable Development of Organizational Ecology? A Case Study of LeEco Using Institutional Logic Theory

Hao Ren, Rongrong Wang, Suopeng Zhang, An ZhangSustainability 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how internet enterprises achieve sustainable growth by integrating diverse industries, using LeEco as a case study. It identifies resource and information barriers as key challenges and proposes a "rigid/flexible" institutional practice model to overcome them, ultimately building legitimacy and fostering ecological growth.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The rapid growth of internet enterprises, characterized by their integration of various industries (e.g., Google's Alphabet, Apple's ecosystem, LeEco's diverse ventures), presents a unique challenge: how do these companies achieve sustainable development when operating across vastly different sectors? Traditional organizational ecology theories often focus on macro-level phenomena like birth and death rates of organizations or inter-organizational relationships. However, they often overlook the internal dynamics and the complex interplay of different "institutional logics" within a single, diversified internet enterprise. This paper aims to fill this gap by exploring the micro-level mechanisms through which internet companies manage internal conflicts arising from industry integration and achieve sustainable growth, using LeEco's ambitious expansion as a prime example.

Methods

The study employs an exploratory single case study approach, focusing on LeEco. This method was chosen because the research aims to answer "how" questions regarding sustainable development and to explore a relatively new phenomenon (internet enterprise ecosystems) where existing knowledge is limited. The researchers conducted in-depth interviews with LeEco personnel, gathered internal and external materials, and performed field investigations. Data was triangulated to ensure reliability. The analysis framework is built upon institutional logic theory, which posits that different logics (e.g., cultural vs. manufacturing) shape organizational behavior and can lead to conflicts.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on qualitative data gathered through interviews, internal documents, and field observations of LeEco.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dual Logics in Internet Ecosystems: Internet enterprises like LeEco often operate with at least two coexisting institutional logics: a "cultural logic" (driven by creativity, inspiration, and user experience, typical of content industries) and a "manufacturing logic" (driven by technical realization, efficiency, and product quality, common in hardware industries).
  • Resource and Information Barriers: The integration of these different logics creates significant internal challenges, primarily manifesting as:
  • Resource Barriers: Disagreements over the distribution of work resources (funding, personnel, materials) between different industry branches.
  • Information Barriers: Communication difficulties arising from differing knowledge structures and professional languages between employees from distinct industry backgrounds.
  • The "Rigid/Flexible" Mechanism: To overcome these barriers, LeEco employs a novel approach that combines "rigid" (implementation, incentive) and "flexible" (communication, cultural) mechanisms. This dual approach is crucial for reconciling conflicting logics.
  • Legitimacy as the Key: Sustainable development hinges on achieving both product legitimacy (e.g., successful "content + terminal" products like LeSuper TV) and organizational legitimacy (establishing a robust and adaptable organizational structure).
  • "Lion-and-Wolf" Culture: LeEco's unique "lion-and-wolf" culture, which embraces collaboration despite inherent differences, is a critical flexible mechanism for fostering understanding and synergy between diverse teams.

Key Results

  • LeEco's organizational ecology is characterized by the interplay of cultural logic (content) and manufacturing logic (terminals).
  • Product assortment conflicts and organizational coordination conflicts arise from these dual logics, leading to resource and information barriers.
  • LeEco successfully navigates these conflicts through:
  • Project Management Organizations: Used as an implementation mechanism to transform resource barriers into resource synergy.
  • Multi-level Meeting System: Acts as a communication mechanism to break down information barriers, fostering information synergy.
  • "Highest Cross-Shareholding" Incentive Mechanism: A rigid mechanism to address resource barriers in performance rewards.
  • "Lion-and-Wolf" Culture: A flexible mechanism to address information barriers stemming from cultural differences.
  • These institutional practices lead to the construction of product and organizational legitimacy, driving the sustainable development of LeEco's organizational ecology.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Case Specificity: The study is based on a single case (LeEco), which has a large-scale internet background and significant resources. The authors acknowledge that the findings might not directly apply to small and medium-sized internet companies and suggest further research with more diverse cases.
  • Qualitative Approach: The research relies on an exploratory case study without empirical tests, building a model based on interview data and theoretical analysis. Future work should involve quantitative testing of the proposed model.
  • Generalizability: While the paper provides a valuable model for internet enterprises, further research is needed to explore how other companies can adapt and implement these strategies.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study explores how Internet enterprises integrate different industries to sustainably develop organizational ecology, using institutional logic theory and an exploratory case study of LeEco, a famous Chinese Internet enterprise. The findings are as follows: (1) There are two main barriers to sustainable development of internal organizational ecology: resource barriers and information barriers. To overcome these obstacles, managers should carry out a series of institutional practices so that the organizational ecology obtains both product and institutional legitimacy; (2) A new institutional practice, the rigid/flexible method, is proposed, which includes implementation, communication, incentive, and cultural mechanisms. This method can help reconcile institutional logic conflicts caused by multiple logic coexistences in the organizational ecology; (3) A sustainable development model of organizational ecologies for Internet enterprises is presented, based on institutional logic, for closed-loop analysis of the ecological growth path. Based on a case study of China’s Internet environment, this paper opens up the “black box” of the internal growth of Internet enterprises at the micro level, complementing the macro studies in the literature. This study enriches organizational ecology theory and institutional logic theory. In addition, the case study of LeEco provides sufficient information on sustainable development to serve as a model for other Internet enterprises.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ren2017how,
  author = {Hao Ren and Rongrong Wang and Suopeng Zhang and An Zhang},
  title = {{How Do Internet Enterprises Obtain Sustainable Development of Organizational Ecology? A Case Study of LeEco Using Institutional Logic Theory}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/su9081375},
}
Figure