How do Chaperones Bind (Partly) Unfolded Client Proteins?

Iva Sučec, Beate Bersch, Paul SchandaFrontiers in Molecular Biosciences 2021 · DOI

Abstract

Molecular chaperones are central to cellular protein homeostasis. Dynamic disorder is a key feature of the complexes of molecular chaperones and their client proteins, and it facilitates the client release towards a folded state or the handover to downstream components. The dynamic nature also implies that a given chaperone can interact with many different client proteins, based on physico-chemical sequence properties rather than on structural complementarity of their (folded) 3D structure. Yet, the balance between this promiscuity and some degree of client specificity is poorly understood. Here, we review recent atomic-level descriptions of chaperones with client proteins, including chaperones in complex with intrinsically disordered proteins, with membrane-protein precursors, or partially folded client proteins. We focus hereby on chaperone-client interactions that are independent of ATP. The picture emerging from these studies highlights the importance of dynamics in these complexes, whereby several interaction types, not only hydrophobic ones, contribute to the complex formation. We discuss these features of chaperone-client complexes and possible factors that may contribute to this balance of promiscuity and specificity.

Introduction: The Paradox of Chaperone Binding

In the crowded environment of a cell, proteins are at constant risk of misfolding and aggregating, especially when they are newly synthesized or under stress. Molecular chaperones serve as the primary "quality control" agents to prevent these outcomes. However, a fundamental paradox exists: how can a single chaperone recognize and bind hundreds of different unfolded proteins (promiscuity) while maintaining enough selectivity to perform specific cellular tasks (specificity)?

Traditional "lock-and-key" models of protein binding, which rely on rigid structural complementarity, fail to explain this phenomenon because unfolded clients lack a fixed three-dimensional shape. Recent advances in structural biology have resolved this by describing chaperone-client interactions as dynamic ensembles rather than static structures.

Methodological Advances in Structural Biology

Understanding these dynamic interactions requires high-resolution biophysical techniques capable of capturing transient states. NMR spectroscopy, particularly relaxation-dispersion NMR, has been instrumental in visualizing the millisecond-scale "dancing" of client proteins as they interconvert between different states while bound to a chaperone. Complementary methods like Small-Angle X-ray/Neutron Scattering (SAXS/SANS) and Single-Molecule FRET provide insights into the overall shape and conformational dynamics of these complexes. Furthermore, Molecular Dynamics (MD) simulations allow researchers to create "explicit ensembles"—computational models representing the many possible shapes a dynamic client can take. This review specifically focuses on ATP-independent interactions, often referred to as "holdase" activity, where binding is driven by the intrinsic physico-chemical properties of the protein surfaces.

Structural diversity of molecular chaperones categorized by their functional roles as foldases, disaggregases, and holdases.

The "Fuzzy Complex": A New Paradigm

A key insight from recent studies is the concept of the "fuzzy complex." Unlike typical protein-protein interactions, the client protein often remains highly disordered and dynamic even when bound to the chaperone. High overall binding stability is often achieved through avidity—the sum of many individually weak, short-lived interactions—rather than a single strong "hotspot." This allows the client to "slide" within the chaperone's binding pocket.

While hydrophobic interactions are the classic "glue" for unfolded proteins, electrostatic and hydrophilic interactions are now recognized as critical for initial recruitment and fine-tuning client preference. Furthermore, for partially folded proteins, chaperones like Spy appear to target regions of "local frustration"—energetically unstable parts of the native fold—thereby stabilizing the protein while it searches for its correct shape.

The energy landscape of protein folding, showing how chaperones stabilize unfolded states (A) to prevent aggregation (B) and facilitate the transition through dynamic complexes (C) toward the native conformation (D).

Thermodynamic Drivers and System-Specific Insights

Specific chaperone systems illustrate these principles in action:

  • TIM Chaperones: Differences in the polarity of the binding cleft between TIM9·10 and TIM8·13 explain their distinct preferences for hydrophobic membrane proteins versus more hydrophilic "tails."
  • Spy Chaperone: Binding of the client Im7 to Spy is entropy-driven; the release of structured water molecules from the chaperone's surface provides the thermodynamic push for binding, rather than just the formation of new chemical bonds.
  • Hsp90 and Tau: Hsp90 utilizes a scattered pattern of hydrophobic residues to bind the disordered protein Tau, preventing aggregation while keeping it extended and accessible for other cellular processes.
  • Skp Chaperone: The client is held in a "fluid globule" state—compact enough for protection but dynamic enough to prevent it from getting "stuck" in a misfolded state.

Future Perspectives in Chaperone Research

Despite these advances, several challenges remain. Most current atomic-level data comes from "model" clients or artificially unfolded proteins; future research must determine if these rules apply to complex, multi-domain proteins in nature. Additionally, understanding how these interactions change in the presence of lipid membranes or "insertase" machinery is a major upcoming frontier. Finally, moving from studying single chaperone-client pairs to understanding the "handover" mechanisms in complex cellular networks will be essential for a complete picture of protein homeostasis.

Summary updated

Abstract

Molecular chaperones are central to cellular protein homeostasis. Dynamic disorder is a key feature of the complexes of molecular chaperones and their client proteins, and it facilitates the client release towards a folded state or the handover to downstream components. The dynamic nature also implies that a given chaperone can interact with many different client proteins, based on physico-chemical sequence properties rather than on structural complementarity of their (folded) 3D structure. Yet, the balance between this promiscuity and some degree of client specificity is poorly understood. Here, we review recent atomic-level descriptions of chaperones with client proteins, including chaperones in complex with intrinsically disordered proteins, with membrane-protein precursors, or partially folded client proteins. We focus hereby on chaperone-client interactions that are independent of ATP. The picture emerging from these studies highlights the importance of dynamics in these complexes, whereby several interaction types, not only hydrophobic ones, contribute to the complex formation. We discuss these features of chaperone-client complexes and possible factors that may contribute to this balance of promiscuity and specificity.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sucec2021how,
  author = {Iva Sučec and Beate Bersch and Paul Schanda},
  title = {{How do Chaperones Bind (Partly) Unfolded Client Proteins?}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Molecular Biosciences},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3389/fmolb.2021.762005},
}
Figure