How Deep Is Your SNARC? Interactions Between Numerical Magnitude, Response Hands, and Reachability in Peripersonal Space

Johannes Lohmann, Philipp A. Schroeder, Hans‐Christoph Nuerk, Christian Plewnia, Martin V. ButzFrontiers in Psychology 2018 · DOI

Abstract Spatial, physical, and semantic magnitude dimensions can influence action decisions in human cognitive processing and interact with each other. For example, in the spatial-numerical associations of response code (SNARC) effect, semantic numerical magnitude facilitates left-hand or right-hand responding dependent on the small or large magnitude of number symbols. SNARC-like interactions of numerical magnitudes with the radial spatial dimension (depth) were postulated from early on. Usually, the SNARC effect in any direction is investigated using fronto-parallel computer monitors for presentation of stimuli. In such 2D setups, however, the metaphorical and literal interpretation of the radial depth axis with seemingly close/far stimuli or responses are not distinct. Hence, it is difficult to draw clear conclusions with respect to the contribution of different spatial mappings to the SNARC effect. In order to disentangle the different mappings in a natural way, we studied parametrical interactions between semantic numerical magnitude, horizontal directional responses, and perceptual distance by means of stereoscopic depth in an immersive virtual reality (VR). Two VR experiments show horizontal SNARC effects across all spatial displacements in traditional latency measures and kinematic response parameters. No indications of a SNARC effect along the depth axis, as it would be predicted by a direct mapping account, were observed, but the results show a non-linear relationship between horizontal SNARC slopes and physical distance. Steepest SNARC slopes were observed for digits presented close to the hands. We conclude that spatial-numerical processing is susceptible to effector-based processes but relatively resilient to task-irrelevant variations of radial-spatial magnitudes.

Introduction

For decades, cognitive psychologists have studied the SNARC effect (Spatial-Numerical Association of Response Codes), a phenomenon where individuals typically respond faster to small numbers with their left hand and large numbers with their right hand. This suggests the existence of a "mental number line" where numerical magnitude is spatially coded.

However, traditional research has been largely confined to 2D computer screens. This creates a conflation problem: on a flat screen, is a stimulus "up" or is it "far away"? Is it "down" or "close"? This study sought to disentangle these dimensions by placing participants in a true 3D environment using immersive Virtual Reality (VR). The researchers specifically investigated the radial axis (depth) to determine if "close" maps to small numbers and "far" to large ones, and how physical reachability—the boundary of peripersonal space—modulates numerical processing.

Methods and Experimental Design

The study utilized two experiments combining an Oculus Rift DK2 headset with high-precision Leap Motion hand tracking. This setup allowed for a naturalistic interaction where participants' physical movements were mirrored by virtual "skeleton" hands.

The physical setup using Leap Motion (left) and the corresponding immersive VR environment (right).

The Task

Participants stood in a virtual meadow and were presented with digits (1–4 and 6–9). Their task was to classify these digits as "smaller" or "larger" than 5. Unlike traditional button-press studies, participants responded by clenching their fist. This allowed for the measurement of both Reaction Time (RT) and kinematic parameters, such as "Maximum Hand Closure" (MHC). MHC is particularly useful for detecting "motor leakage," where the incorrect hand begins to clench slightly before the correct hand completes the action, providing a window into the internal conflict caused by incongruent numerical-spatial mappings.

Spatial Manipulation

Stimuli were presented at various depths along the radial axis. Experiment 1 tested 16 right-handed participants across 10 equidistant spatial displacements, ranging from the immediate vicinity of the body to the "extrapersonal space" beyond reach. Experiment 2 refined this by focusing on the four most critical distances identified in the first study to better map the relationship between reachability and the SNARC effect.

Top-down schematic of the experimental workspace, illustrating the sensor location and the boundary of reachable space.

Key Results

The "Hand-Centric" Sweet Spot

The most significant finding was a non-linear relationship between depth and the SNARC effect. While the horizontal SNARC effect (left/right) was present across all distances ($p < 0.001$), it was not uniform. The SNARC slope was significantly steeper when digits were presented near the hands (~27.8 ms/bin) compared to when they were close to the body (~19.9 ms/bin) or at the outer border of reach (~18.1 ms/bin). This suggests that our mental number line is most active within the functional space where we interact with objects.

Radial Resilience

Despite theoretical predictions of a "radial SNARC" (where close = small and far = large), the study found no evidence for such a mapping. The horizontal mapping appears to be so dominant that task-irrelevant variations in depth did not trigger a new radial association. This indicates that while numerical processing is embodied, it is also resilient to certain spatial variations.

Kinematic Evidence of Conflict

The kinematic data confirmed that the SNARC effect is not merely a delay in cognitive decision-making but a physical conflict in the motor system. In incongruent trials (e.g., a large number requiring a left-hand response), the "wrong" hand often showed measurable twitching or partial closure, demonstrating that the mental number line directly influences motor planning.

Discussion and Conclusion

These findings support the Theory of Magnitude (ATOM), suggesting that the brain processes numbers using the same sensorimotor systems used for planning physical actions. Numerical cognition is "grounded" in the space immediately surrounding our effectors (the hands).

Limitations and Future Work: The study focused on positive integers. Future research might explore if including negative numbers—which imply a different spatial direction—could trigger the elusive radial SNARC effect. Additionally, "virtual body swapping" experiments could determine if the SNARC "sweet spot" follows the visual representation of the hand in VR or the physical location of the user's actual hand. These insights could eventually inform clinical approaches to spatial neglect or dyscalculia by leveraging the link between reachability and numerical processing.

Summary updated

Abstract

Spatial, physical, and semantic magnitude dimensions can influence action decisions in human cognitive processing and interact with each other. For example, in the spatial-numerical associations of response code (SNARC) effect, semantic numerical magnitude facilitates left-hand or right-hand responding dependent on the small or large magnitude of number symbols. SNARC-like interactions of numerical magnitudes with the radial spatial dimension (depth) were postulated from early on. Usually, the SNARC effect in any direction is investigated using fronto-parallel computer monitors for presentation of stimuli. In such 2D setups, however, the metaphorical and literal interpretation of the radial depth axis with seemingly close/far stimuli or responses are not distinct. Hence, it is difficult to draw clear conclusions with respect to the contribution of different spatial mappings to the SNARC effect. In order to disentangle the different mappings in a natural way, we studied parametrical interactions between semantic numerical magnitude, horizontal directional responses, and perceptual distance by means of stereoscopic depth in an immersive virtual reality (VR). Two VR experiments show horizontal SNARC effects across all spatial displacements in traditional latency measures and kinematic response parameters. No indications of a SNARC effect along the depth axis, as it would be predicted by a direct mapping account, were observed, but the results show a non-linear relationship between horizontal SNARC slopes and physical distance. Steepest SNARC slopes were observed for digits presented close to the hands. We conclude that spatial-numerical processing is susceptible to effector-based processes but relatively resilient to task-irrelevant variations of radial-spatial magnitudes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{lohmann2018how,
  author = {Johannes Lohmann and Philipp A. Schroeder and Hans‐Christoph Nuerk and Christian Plewnia and Martin V. Butz},
  title = {{How Deep Is Your SNARC? Interactions Between Numerical Magnitude, Response Hands, and Reachability in Peripersonal Space}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2018.00622},
}
Figure