How can we reduce the rate of Violent-Sexual Crimes? An attempt at street design

Y. P. Zhang, Zikai Jin, Shu Zhuang, Shengjie Zhao, Li LingPLoS 2026 · DOI

TL;DR

This study proposes and validates a novel framework for assessing street design's impact on Violent-Sexual Crimes (VSC). By integrating expert opinions with streetscape analysis, they found a strong negative correlation between well-designed streets and VSC rates, suggesting that urban planning can be a powerful tool for crime reduction.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Urban street design is known to influence crime rates, but existing research often focuses on single environmental factors. This paper addresses the gap in understanding how a comprehensive set of street design elements, considered together, impacts Violent-Sexual Crimes (VSC), a significant public order concern. The authors aim to develop and test a framework that integrates multiple environmental factors to provide a more holistic approach to crime prevention through urban design.

Methods

The study employs a two-pronged approach:

  1. Fuzzy Delphi Method (FDM): This technique was used to gather and synthesize expert opinions on street design factors influencing VSC. By using fuzzy set theory, the FDM accounts for ambiguity in expert judgments, allowing for the development of robust street design guidelines and scoring criteria.
  2. Streetscape Analysis: Google Street View (GSV) imagery and Semantic Segmentation were used to capture detailed environmental data for fifteen selected streets in London. This data was then scored based on the FDM-derived criteria.
  3. Statistical Analysis: A Pearson correlation analysis was performed to assess the relationship between the aggregated street design scores and actual VSC rates. ANOVA was used to analyze differences in crime rates across the streets.

Datasets

  • Crime Data: Reported crime data for Violent-Sexual Crimes (VSC) from January 2021 to May 2025, sourced from the Metropolitan Police (Police.uk database). This data was anonymized and publicly available.
  • Streetscape Data: Google Street View (GSV) panoramic images captured at 50m intervals in four cardinal directions for fifteen selected streets in North Lambeth, London. Semantic segmentation was applied to classify urban elements within these images.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Holistic Design Matters: The study strongly suggests that it's not just one or two factors, but the combination of well-designed environmental elements that contributes to safer streets.
  • Expert Consensus is Key: The Fuzzy Delphi Method proved effective in distilling complex expert opinions into actionable design guidelines, highlighting the value of integrating qualitative insights with quantitative analysis.
  • Visual Cues of Neglect Signal Risk: Factors like litter, potholes, and dilapidated exteriors (indicators of "broken windows") are linked to higher crime rates, reinforcing the idea that visible signs of disorder can foster a sense of neglect and encourage criminal activity.
  • Lighting and Surveillance are Critical: Street lighting and surveillance cameras emerged as highly correlated with lower VSC rates, aligning with established CPTED principles.
  • The Ambiguity of "Neutral" Spaces: Factors like "bus stops" and "stores" showed ambiguous associations with VSC, suggesting their impact can be context-dependent, potentially increasing risk during low-activity periods or offering surveillance during busy times.

Key Results

  • A statistically significant and strong negative correlation (r = -0.847, p < 0.0001) was found between the aggregated street design score and the VSC rate. This means streets with higher composite environmental scores had lower VSC rates.
  • ANOVA confirmed statistically significant differences in crime rates among the fifteen studied streets, indicating that crime distribution is not random but linked to environmental factors.
  • The study identified a three-tier structure of crime distribution: a high-crime cluster (Streets A, B, C, O), a medium-crime cluster, and a low-crime cluster (Streets E, H).
  • Key factors most strongly correlated with VSC were "street surveillance," "street lights," and "nightclubs/bars."

Limitations and Future Work

  • Context Specificity: The findings are based on a specific area in London and may not be directly generalizable to all urban environments due to variations in culture, urban layout, and socio-demographic factors.
  • Sample Size: The study used a relatively small sample of fifteen streets, which might limit the statistical power to detect subtle relationships.
  • Crime Metrics: The analysis used raw crime counts rather than rates normalized by street length or pedestrian activity, which could affect precision.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest future research should:
  • Incorporate normalized crime metrics (e.g., crimes per kilometer or per pedestrian-hour).
  • Apply the framework across multiple cities to assess broader utility and generalizability.
  • Integrate broader interdisciplinary perspectives to deepen the understanding of VSC risk factors.
  • Explore the impact of transient populations and other confounding factors.

Summary updated

Abstract

Well-designed streets can foster a harmonious social environment. Street crime rates are closely related to street design, and Violent-Sexual Crime (VSC) is a significant public order concern. While most existing studies address the impact of single environmental factors on street crime, a comprehensive assessment that integrates multiple factors is lacking. As an exploratory study, this research aims to propose and preliminarily validate a multi-factor street design framework aimed at mitigating VSC. First, the Fuzzy Delphi Method (FDM) was used to construct street design guidelines that affect the Violent-Sexual Crime rate, with scoring criteria for street design factors formulated based on the FDM results. Subsequently, Google Street View (GSV) and Semantic Segmentation were utilized to capture the streetscape of the study area. To empirically test this framework, the study conducted an in-depth analysis of fifteen streets, randomly selected from a focused area in London using QGIS. The results indicated a negative correlation between higher environmental scores and lower VSC rates within the studied setting, providing initial, context-specific evidence for the potential utility of the proposed design guidelines. Although findings are primarily applicable to similar urban environments, the methodology offers a transferable model for future research in broader contexts.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2026how,
  author = {Y. P. Zhang and Zikai Jin and Shu Zhuang and Shengjie Zhao and Li Ling},
  title = {{How can we reduce the rate of Violent-Sexual Crimes? An attempt at street design}},
  booktitle = {PLoS},
  year = {2026},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pone.0341372},
}
Figure