Homogeneity in Regression

Zheng Tracy Ke, Jianqing Fan, Yichao WuarXiv 2013 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This paper explores the homogeneity of coefficients in high-dimensional regression, a concept that extends the traditional sparsity framework to a more general and applicable structure. Homogeneity occurs when regression coefficients for neighboring geographical regions or similar clusters of covariates are approximately identical. While sparsity is a special case of homogeneity (where the shared value is zero), exploring homogeneity allows for more nuanced modeling. We propose a new method, Clustering Algorithm in Regression via data-driven Segmentation (CARDS), to identify these structures. We establish the asymptotic normality of the CARDS estimator, demonstrating that it achieves superior estimation accuracy compared to methods that ignore homogeneity. When combined with sparsity exploration, CARDS provides significant gains in efficiency, as illustrated through simulation studies and real-world applications in finance and genomics.

Introduction

In high-dimensional statistics, the "sparsity" assumption—the idea that only a small subset of variables has a non-zero effect—has long been the standard for model regularization. However, in many practical applications, variables often act in coordination. In fields such as genetics, finance, or meteorology, predictors often share similar levels of influence due to underlying biological pathways, industrial sectors, or spatial proximity.

This paper introduces the concept of homogeneity as a broader alternative to sparsity. By identifying clusters of identical regression coefficients, researchers can reduce the effective dimensionality of a problem without necessarily discarding variables. We present CARDS, a data-driven framework designed to discover these hidden patterns efficiently.

The CARDS Framework

Existing methods for finding homogeneous groups, such as the Fused Lasso, typically require a predefined ordering of variables (e.g., a time series or a physical map). Methods that attempt to find these groups automatically often face a "combinatorial explosion," requiring $O(p^2)$ comparisons for $p$ variables. CARDS overcomes this by using a multi-stage, data-driven approach.

1. bCARDS (Basic CARDS)

The basic version of the algorithm utilizes a preordering strategy. It begins with a preliminary estimate of the coefficients (such as OLS or Lasso). By sorting these estimates, the algorithm creates a sequence where potentially identical coefficients are likely to be adjacent. A fused penalty is then applied only to these adjacent pairs, reducing the computational complexity from $O(p^2)$ to $O(p)$.

2. aCARDS (Advanced CARDS)

To improve robustness against noise in the initial estimate, aCARDS employs Ordered Segmentation. Instead of a strict linear order, it groups coefficients into segments. It then applies a hybrid penalty: an exhaustive pairwise penalty within each segment (where the exact order is uncertain) and a fused penalty between adjacent segments. This allows the model to correct for minor ordering errors in the initial stage.

3. sCARDS (Sparsity-aware CARDS)

This variation simultaneously explores both homogeneity and sparsity. It pushes coefficients toward each other (clustering) while also pushing the clusters toward zero, effectively combining the strengths of the Lasso and the CARDS framework.

Theoretical Insights: The Power of Noise Averaging

A central contribution of this research is the mathematical proof of the "Noise Averaging" effect. The estimation error in CARDS is shown to depend on the number of underlying groups ($K$) rather than the total number of variables ($p$). By correctly grouping coefficients, the estimator effectively averages the noise across all variables within a cluster, leading to significantly higher precision.

Furthermore, the authors establish that CARDS possesses the Oracle Property. Under specific conditions, the algorithm performs as well as if the true group structures were known to the researcher beforehand.

Empirical Evidence

Simulation Studies

In high-dimensional settings ($p=60$ to $100$) with four distinct coefficient groups, both bCARDS and aCARDS consistently outperformed standard OLS and Fused Lasso. Using Normalized Mutual Information (NMI) as a metric, aCARDS demonstrated a superior ability to recover the true underlying group structure even in the presence of significant noise.

Financial Sectoring (S&P 500)

The authors applied CARDS to the daily returns of 410 stocks in the S&P 500. By analyzing factor loadings, the algorithm successfully identified clusters of stocks within the "Utilities" sector. This data-driven grouping resulted in a lower cumulative squared error compared to standard regression models, proving that industrial sectors share homogeneous responses to market factors.

Genomic Prediction (PASes)

In a study of Polyadenylation Signals (PASes) involving 170 predictors, aCARDS achieved a prediction error of 0.2449, significantly lower than the 0.2757 achieved by Total Variation penalties. Crucially, aCARDS produced a much simpler, more interpretable model with only approximately 5.5 non-zero coefficient groups, highlighting the biological coordination inherent in DNA sequence characteristics.

Conclusion

Homogeneity represents a powerful yet underutilized structural property in high-dimensional regression. The CARDS framework provides a computationally efficient and theoretically sound method for exploring this property. By moving beyond simple sparsity, CARDS allows researchers to uncover the collective behavior of variables, leading to more accurate predictions and deeper structural insights across a wide range of scientific disciplines.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper explores the homogeneity of coefficients in high-dimensional regression, which extends the sparsity concept and is more general and suitable for many applications. Homogeneity arises when one expects regression coefficients corresponding to neighboring geographical regions or a similar cluster of covariates to be approximately the same. Sparsity corresponds to a special case of homogeneity with a known atom zero. In this article, we propose a new method called clustering algorithm in regression via data-driven segmentation (CARDS) to explore homogeneity. New mathematics are provided on the gain that can be achieved by exploring homogeneity. Statistical properties of two versions of CARDS are analyzed. In particular, the asymptotic normality of our proposed CARDS estimator is established, which reveals better estimation accuracy for homogeneous parameters than that without homogeneity exploration. When our methods are combined with sparsity exploration, further efficiency can be achieved beyond the exploration of sparsity alone. This provides additional insights into the power of exploring low-dimensional strucuture in high-dimensional regression: homogeneity and sparsity. The newly developed method is further illustrated by simulation studies and applications to real data.
BibTeX
@misc{ke2013homogeneity,
  author = {Zheng Tracy Ke and Jianqing Fan and Yichao Wu},
  title = {{Homogeneity in Regression}},
  year = {2013},
  eprint = {1303.7409},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1303.7409},
}
Figure