Homo naledi: a new species of hominin from the Dinaledi Chamber, South Africa

Darryl J. de Ruiter, Lee R. Berger, John Hawks, S. E. Churchill, Peter Schmid, Lucas K. Delezene, Tracy L. Kivell, H. M. Garvin, Scott A. Williams, Jeremy M. DeSilva, Matthew M. Skinner, Charles M. Musiba, Noël Cameron, Trenton W. Holliday, William E. H. Harcourt‐Smith, R. Ackermann, Markus Bastir, Barry Bogin, Debra R. Bolter, Juliet K. Brophy, Zachary Cofran, Kimberly A. Congdon, Abner Dean, Mana Dembo, Michelle S.m. Drapeau, Marina Elliott, Elen Feuerriegel, Daniel García‐Martínez, D. J. Green, Alia Gurtov, Joel D. Irish, Ashley Krüger, Myra F. Laird, Damiano Marchi, Marc R. Meyer, Shahed Nalla, Enquye W. Negash, Caley M. Orr, Davorka Radovčić, Lauren Schroeder, Jeremiah E. Scott, Zachary Throckmorton, Matthew W. Tocheri, Caroline VanSickle, Christopher S. Walker, Pianpian Wei, Bernhard ZipfelPaleoAnthropology 2016

TL;DR

A new species of extinct hominin, Homo naledi, has been discovered in South Africa, characterized by a mosaic of primitive and derived features. This discovery, based on the largest assemblage of a single hominin species found in Africa, challenges our understanding of early human evolution by revealing a small-brained hominin with human-like hands and feet, suggesting complex behaviors may not have required large brains.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the challenge of understanding the evolutionary trajectory of the genus Homo. For decades, the prevailing view was that key hominin traits like increased brain size, advanced tool use, and efficient bipedalism evolved as a package. However, discoveries like Australopithecus sediba and now Homo naledi demonstrate that these traits evolved independently and in varying combinations, complicating the picture of hominin diversification. Specifically, this paper aims to formally describe Homo naledi, a species that exhibits a unique blend of features previously thought to be exclusive to different stages of hominin evolution, thus requiring a re-evaluation of the relationships and evolutionary pathways within the Homo genus.

Methods

The primary method employed is detailed morphological analysis of a large fossil assemblage. This involved:

  • Comparative Anatomy: Extensive comparison of H. naledi specimens with known fossils from various hominin species (e.g., Australopithecus, Homo habilis, Homo erectus) and modern humans. This comparison was based on direct examination of original fossils and casts, as well as published data.
  • Virtual Reconstruction: 3D scanning and virtual reconstruction of fragmented cranial specimens (DH1-DH4) to create composite crania. This allowed for the estimation of cranial capacity and a more comprehensive analysis of cranial morphology.
  • Biometric Analysis: Measurement of various skeletal elements (femur, tibia, hand bones, teeth) to quantify differences and similarities with other hominin species. This included developing regression equations to estimate body mass and stature.

Datasets

The study is based on a newly discovered fossil assemblage from the Dinaledi Chamber in the Rising Star cave system, South Africa. This assemblage comprises over 1700 hominin specimens, representing at least 15 individuals. The paper also references and utilizes data from numerous previously described fossil hominin specimens from various sites worldwide for comparative purposes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Mosaic Evolution: Homo naledi is a prime example of mosaic evolution, exhibiting a mix of primitive (australopith-like) and derived (Homo-like) traits across its skeleton. This reinforces the idea that different parts of the hominin body evolved at different rates.
  • Brain Size vs. Behavior: The small endocranial volume (similar to australopiths) contrasted with human-like hand and wrist morphology for manipulation is particularly striking. This suggests that complex behaviors like tool use and object manipulation might not have been solely dependent on large brain size in early hominins.
  • Unique Combination of Traits: H. naledi possesses features not seen in any other known hominin species, such as specific pillar formations in the femoral neck and unique aspects of hand morphology.
  • Implications for Hominin Phylogeny: The discovery challenges existing phylogenetic trees, suggesting that the genus Homo was more diverse and that evolutionary pathways were more complex than previously understood.

Key Results

  • New Species: Formal description of Homo naledi, a new species of extinct hominin.
  • Large Assemblage: The Dinaledi Chamber yielded the largest assemblage of a single hominin species discovered in Africa, providing unprecedented data for analysis.
  • Body Mass & Stature: Estimated body mass ranges from 39.7 to 55.8 kg, with an estimated stature of 144.5 to 147.8 mm, similar to small-bodied modern humans.
  • Cranial Capacity: Endocranial volume estimates are approximately 560cc (larger composite) and 465cc (smaller composite), overlapping with australopith ranges.
  • Unique Morphology: Detailed descriptions of unique features in the cranium, mandible, dentition, hand, foot, femur, and tibia, highlighting its distinctiveness.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Undated Fossils: A significant limitation is that the geological age of the Dinaledi fossils remains unknown. Dating the remains is a critical next step to understand the temporal context of H. naledi and its implications for human evolution.
  • Phylogenetic Placement: While the paper argues for placement within Homo, its precise phylogenetic relationship to other Homo species requires further investigation, especially given the incomplete fossil record of some key taxa.
  • Behavioral Interpretation: While morphology suggests manipulative capabilities, direct evidence of behavior (e.g., tool use) is not presented in this paper. Future research could explore potential behavioral implications.
  • Further Excavation and Analysis: The authors anticipate that future excavations and analyses will uncover more specimens and refine our understanding of H. naledi's anatomy and evolutionary position.

Summary updated

Abstract

Homo naledi is a previously unknown species of extinct hominin discovered within the Dinaledi Chamber of the Rising Star cave system, Gauteng, South Africa. This species is characterized by body mass and stature similar to small-bodied human populations, with a small endocranial volume similar to australopiths. Cranial morphology of H. naledi is unique, but most similar to early Homo species including H. erectus, H. habilis, or H. rudolfensis. While primitive, the dentition is generally small and simple in occlusal morphology. H. naledi has humanlike manipulatory adaptations of the hand and wrist. It also exhibits a humanlike leg and foot. These humanlike aspects are contrasted in the postcrania with a more primitive or australopith-like trunk, shoulder, fingers, pelvis, and proximal femur. Nonetheless, the shared derived features that connect H. naledi with other members of Homo occupy most regions of the H. naledi skeleton and represent distinct functional systems, including locomotion, manipulation, and mastication. With at least 15 individuals and most skeletal elements represented by multiple specimens, this is the largest assemblage of a single species of hominins yet discovered in Africa. To date we have recovered more than 1, 700 specimens, with comprehensive representation of skeletal elements across the lifespan, and from multiple individuals. Regardless of the fact that the Dinaledi Chamber is currently undated, H. naledi highlights gaps in our understanding of ancient Homo across the vast geographic span of the African continent. The tree of Homo-like hominins is far from complete: we have missed key transitional forms and lineages that persisted for hundreds of thousands of years.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ruiter2016homo,
  author = {Darryl J. de Ruiter and Lee R. Berger and John Hawks and S. E. Churchill and Peter Schmid and Lucas K. Delezene and Tracy L. Kivell and H. M. Garvin and Scott A. Williams and Jeremy M. DeSilva and Matthew M. Skinner and Charles M. Musiba and Noël Cameron and Trenton W. Holliday and William E. H. Harcourt‐Smith and R. Ackermann and Markus Bastir and Barry Bogin and Debra R. Bolter and Juliet K. Brophy and Zachary Cofran and Kimberly A. Congdon and Abner Dean and Mana Dembo and Michelle S.M. Drapeau and Marina Elliott and Elen Feuerriegel and Daniel García‐Martínez and D. J. Green and Alia Gurtov and Joel D. Irish and Ashley Krüger and Myra F. Laird and Damiano Marchi and Marc R. Meyer and Shahed Nalla and Enquye W. Negash and Caley M. Orr and Davorka Radovčić and Lauren Schroeder and Jeremiah E. Scott and Zachary Throckmorton and Matthew W. Tocheri and Caroline VanSickle and Christopher S. Walker and Pianpian Wei and Bernhard Zipfel},
  title = {{Homo naledi: a new species of hominin from the Dinaledi Chamber, South Africa}},
  booktitle = {PaleoAnthropology},
  year = {2016},
}
Figure