Abstract
Green home renovation is a socio-technical process involving homeowners and professionals. Homeowners undertaking a green renovation encounter unfamiliar terms and must navigate potentially conflicting information from different sources. These challenges prevent some homeowners from being fully engaged in the renovation process, which can lead to less than optimal homeowner satisfaction and failure to use green features to their greatest extent. This paper details the information requirements of homeowners, drawing on seven interviews that were conducted with those who have done a green home renovation. We put forward suggestions that can be used to improve the green home design process, contributing to higher uptake, more satisfied homeowners, and more environmentally friendly use of renovated homes. We also conclude that there is a need for homeowners to be contributors to the knowledge base surrounding green renovations. Finally, we propose a model for an ICT platform to satisfy the needs identified in our research.
Introduction
Buildings represent approximately one-third of global greenhouse gas emissions, primarily driven by energy consumption during their operational lifespans. While technological advancements in "smart home" automation and government-led financial incentives aim to curb this impact, these top-down strategies often overlook the central actor in the renovation process: the homeowner.
Green renovation is not merely a technical upgrade but a complex socio-technical process. Homeowners frequently face a barrage of technical jargon, conflicting advice, and "greenwashing"—marketing that exaggerates environmental benefits. When homeowners are alienated by these complexities, they may fail to utilize green features correctly or abandon sustainable options entirely. This research seeks to identify the specific information requirements needed to transform homeowners from passive consumers into engaged participants, thereby maximizing the environmental benefits of residential retrofits.
Methodology
The study employed a qualitative approach rooted in requirements engineering and participatory design. The researchers conducted seven semi-structured interviews with ten participants in Toronto, Canada, all of whom had recently completed green home renovations.
To analyze the data, the researchers utilized an open iterative coding strategy inspired by grounded theory. This method allowed themes—such as waste diversion, material health, and local sourcing—to emerge organically from the participants' experiences. By focusing on early adopters, the study aimed to identify the hurdles faced by those most motivated to pursue sustainability, providing a roadmap for broader adoption.
Key Findings: The Homeowner Perspective
Comfort and Values over ROI
Contrary to common assumptions that financial return is the primary driver for green upgrades, the study found that for homeowners planning long-term residency, Return on Investment (ROI) was often secondary. Instead, "comfort"—defined as consistent indoor temperatures and the psychological satisfaction of environmental stewardship (the "warm fuzzy feeling")—was a more significant motivator. Features like green roofs were valued for their aesthetic and emotional impact as much as their thermal performance.
The "House as a System" Challenge
One of the most significant hurdles identified was the difficulty homeowners faced in understanding holistic building science. Participants struggled to grasp how individual components, such as increased insulation, affected the entire house system. They often became overwhelmed by component-level technicalities when they actually required a high-level architectural view to make informed decisions.
Navigating Greenwashing
Participants reported a heavy reliance on professionals to act as "bullshit detectors." Without specialized expertise, homeowners found it nearly impossible to distinguish between truly sustainable products and those making superficial claims (e.g., spray foam marketed as "green" due to negligible soy content). This highlights a critical need for authoritative, transparent information sources.
Homeowners as Knowledge Producers
A pivotal insight from the interviews was that homeowners do not wish to be mere recipients of information; they want to be contributors. Many participants viewed themselves as "validators" or role models, expressing a strong desire to share their successes and failures via community platforms to help others navigate the renovation process.
Proposed ICT Platform Model
Based on the identified information needs, the authors propose a model for an Information and Communication Technology (ICT) platform designed to support the green renovation ecosystem. The platform includes four core functions:
- Authoritative Information: A system that links product reviews to specific user profiles (e.g., contractors vs. homeowners) to provide context-aware, credible appraisals.
- Material Marketplace: A localized marketplace for advertising and obtaining salvaged materials (such as copper pipes or vintage fixtures), supporting waste diversion and reducing costs.
- Community Mobilization: A tool for organizing homeowners to advocate for sustainable government policies and collective action.
- Professional Guidance Tools: Resources designed to help homeowners ask the right questions of their contractors, ensuring the final design aligns with their specific sustainability values (e.g., non-toxic materials or local sourcing).
Conclusion and Future Work
This study underscores that the success of green renovations depends on the active engagement of homeowners. By addressing the information gap and providing tools for community-driven knowledge sharing, we can improve homeowner satisfaction and environmental outcomes.
As an exploratory study with a small sample size in Toronto, the findings are an initial probe into the socio-technical dynamics of green renovations. Future research should focus on testing the proposed ICT platform and expanding the study to include more diverse housing types, socioeconomic backgrounds, and geographic regions to engage the "early majority" of homeowners.
Summary updated