HIV-specific CD8 + T-cells in tonsils express exhaustive T RM -like signatures

Rabiah Fardoos, Sarah K. Nyquist, Osaretin E. Asowata, Samuel W. Kazer, Alveera Singh, Abigail Ngoepe, Jennifer Giandhari, Ntombifuthi Mthabela, Dirhona Ramjit, Samita Singh, Farina Karim, Søren Buus, Frank Anderson, J. Zachary Porterfield, Andile Lindokuhle Sibiya, Rishan Bipath, Kumeshan Moodley, Warren Kuhn, Bonnie Berger, Son Nguyen, Túlio de Oliveira, Thumbi Ndung’u, Philip Goulder, Alex K. Shalek, Alasdair Leslie, Henrik N. KløverprisbioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates HIV-specific CD8+ T-cells within tonsils, a key HIV reservoir site. They found these cells in HIV-infected individuals exhibit an "exhausted" phenotype, characterized by high PD-1 expression and reduced cytolytic activity, suggesting a potential target for immunotherapy to clear HIV reservoirs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

HIV establishes persistent reservoirs in lymphoid tissues, making complete eradication of the virus challenging even with effective antiretroviral therapy (ART). Tissue-resident memory (TRM) CD8+ T-cells are thought to play a crucial role in controlling viral infections within tissues. However, there's limited understanding of the phenotype and function of these TRM cells, particularly HIV-specific ones, within lymph nodes of people living with HIV (PLWH). This knowledge gap hinders the development of immunotherapies aimed at targeting these reservoirs.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Flow Cytometry: To analyze the surface protein expression of CD8+ T-cells from blood and tonsils, focusing on markers like CD69, CD103 (TRM markers), PD-1 (exhaustion marker), and CD127 (cytokine receptor).
  • Single-cell RNA Sequencing (scRNA-seq): Using the Seq-Well S3 platform, they profiled the gene expression of bulk CD8+ T-cells from tonsils and blood to identify distinct transcriptional signatures.
  • Fluorescent Immunohistochemistry: To visualize the spatial localization of CD8+ T-cells and specific markers (like HIV-p24) within tonsil tissue sections, particularly in relation to germinal centers (GCs).
  • Peptide-MHC Tetramer Staining: To specifically identify and isolate HIV-specific and CMV-specific CD8+ T-cells for further analysis.
  • SMART-seq2 scRNA-seq: A more optimized scRNA-seq protocol was used for tetramer-sorted HIV-specific, CMV-specific, and non-specific CD8+ T-cells to delve deeper into their transcriptional states.
  • TCR Sequencing: To analyze the clonal expansion of T-cells.

Datasets

The study utilized samples from:

  • HIV-infected individuals (PLWH): From South Africa, including those on ART and treatment-naïve, with varying viral loads.
  • Uninfected individuals: As controls.
  • A natural HIV controller: An individual with undetectable viral load without ART, providing a unique comparison point.

The data generated included flow cytometry data, scRNA-seq data, and immunohistochemistry images.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Tonsil TRM cells are distinct from blood: HIV-specific CD8+ T-cells in tonsils exhibit a unique phenotype compared to their counterparts in the blood. This highlights the importance of studying tissue-resident cells for a complete understanding of immune responses in HIV.
  • HIV infection drives an "exhausted" TRM phenotype: In PLWH, tonsillar HIV-specific CD8+ T-cells show increased expression of exhaustion markers like PD-1 and markers associated with tissue residency (CD69, CD103), but with reduced cytolytic potential. This suggests a state of chronic activation and potential dysfunction.
  • Location matters: These exhausted TRM cells are found predominantly outside the germinal centers (GCs), which are known HIV reservoirs. This spatial separation might limit their ability to effectively clear the virus.
  • Natural controllers offer a contrast: In contrast to viremic individuals, HIV-specific CD8+ T-cells in a natural controller's tonsils showed a less exhausted phenotype, with lower PD-1 expression and a more "non-cytolytic" profile, suggesting a different mechanism of viral control.
  • Immunotherapy potential: The "exhausted" but tissue-resident nature of these HIV-specific CD8+ T-cells in tonsils makes them a potential target for immunotherapies aimed at reactivating or modulating their function to combat HIV reservoirs.

Key Results

  • HIV-specific CD8+ T-cells in tonsils of PLWH are enriched for activation and exhaustion profiles compared to blood.
  • These tonsillar HIV-specific CD8+ T-cells express high levels of PD-1 and CD69, and reduced levels of CD127.
  • scRNA-seq revealed distinct transcriptional signatures of activation, clonal expansion, and exhaustion in these cells.
  • In a natural HIV controller, HIV-specific CD8+ T-cells in tonsils showed reduced PD-1 expression and less evidence of exhaustion.
  • These cells were primarily located outside the germinal centers, where the majority of the HIV reservoir resides.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sample size: While the study includes a reasonable number of participants, larger cohorts could further strengthen the findings.
  • Generalizability: The study was conducted in South Africa, and while the findings are significant, further research in diverse populations might be beneficial.
  • Functional consequences: While the study identifies phenotypic and transcriptional signatures of exhaustion, further in-depth functional studies are needed to fully elucidate the impact of these changes on viral control.
  • Immunotherapy development: The authors suggest that these findings provide a rationale for developing immunotherapies targeting these specific CD8+ T-cell populations. Future work could focus on testing strategies to modulate PD-1 expression or enhance the cytolytic capacity of these cells.
  • Role of GCs: Further investigation into why these T-cells are located outside GCs and how this impacts their interaction with the HIV reservoir is warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Lymphoid tissues are an important HIV reservoir site that persists in the face of antiretroviral therapy and natural immunity. Targeting these reservoirs by harnessing the antiviral activity of local tissue resident memory ( T RM ) CD8 + T-cells is of great interest, but limited data exist on T RM s within lymph nodes of people living with HIV (PLWH). Here, we studied tonsil CD8 + T-cells obtained from PLWH and uninfected controls from South Africa. We show that these cells are preferentially located outside the germinal centers (GCs), the main reservoir site for HIV, and display a low cytolytic and transcriptionally T RM -like profile that is distinct from blood. In PLWH, CD8 + T RM -like cells are highly expanded and adopt a more cytolytic, activated and exhausted phenotype characterized by increased expression of CD69, PD-1 and perforin, but reduced CD127. This phenotype was enhanced in HIV-specific CD8 + T-cells from tonsils compared to matched blood. Single-cell profiling of these cells revealed a clear transcriptional signature of T-cell activation, clonal expansion and exhaustion ex-vivo . In contrast, this signature was absent from HIV-specific CD8 + T-cells in tonsils isolated from a natural HIV controller, who expressed lower levels of cell surface PD-1 and CXCR5, and reduced transcriptional evidence of T-cell activation, exhaustion and cytolytic activity. Thus, we show that HIV-specific T RM -like CD8 + T-cells in tonsils from non-HIV controllers are enriched for activation and exhaustion profiles compared to those in blood, suggesting that lymphoid HIV-specific CD8 + T RM cells are potentially ideal candidates for immunotherapy to modulate their ability to targeting the HIV reservoirs.
BibTeX
@misc{fardoos2021hiv,
  author = {Rabiah Fardoos and Sarah K. Nyquist and Osaretin E. Asowata and Samuel W. Kazer and Alveera Singh and Abigail Ngoepe and Jennifer Giandhari and Ntombifuthi Mthabela and Dirhona Ramjit and Samita Singh and Farina Karim and Søren Buus and Frank Anderson and J. Zachary Porterfield and Andile Lindokuhle Sibiya and Rishan Bipath and Kumeshan Moodley and Warren Kuhn and Bonnie Berger and Son Nguyen and Túlio de Oliveira and Thumbi Ndung’u and Philip Goulder and Alex K. Shalek and Alasdair Leslie and Henrik N. Kløverpris},
  title = {{HIV-specific CD8 <sup>+</sup> T-cells in tonsils express exhaustive T <sub>RM</sub> -like signatures}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.11.04.467061},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure