History and Current Status of Neurosurgery in Turkey

Talat Krş, Mehmet AkçakayaNeurosurgery 2016 · DOI

Abstract

The Turkish Republic is located along the border of Asia and Europe. The Asian-influenced part of the country is known as Anatolia, and the smaller, European-influenced portion is called Thrace. Evidence of neurosurgery practice in Anatolia dates back to the Neolithic Age.1 The majority of historical evidence as to surgical intervention and trepanation in Turkey, however, dates back to the Iron and Bronze ages1 (Figure 1). The civilizations of Anatolia were followers of each other, with each civilization connected to its predecessor. These civilizations include the Hittites (2500-1200 BC); Ionians (1050-300 BC); Urartus (900-600 BC); Phrygians, Lydians, Carians, and Lycians (750-300 BC); Hellenistic and Roman civilizations (333 BC-AD 395); Byzantines (AD 330-1453); Seljuks (AD 1071-1300); Ottomans (AD 1299-1923); and contemporary Turkish Republic.2 Turkey is the birthplace of many famous ancient physicians such as Galen of Pergamum (201-131 BC), Aretaeus of Cappadocia (81-138 BC), and Şerafeddin Sabuncuoğlu of Amasya (1385-1468), who each had a long history of medical practice according to classic Greco-Roman and Islamic medical doctrines. Modern medical and surgical practice was ushered into Turkey during the first half of 19th century. In what follows, the development of modern neurosurgery in Turkey and the current status of neurosurgery and practice in the country are discussed.FIGURE 1: An example of trepanation with placed bone flap founded in Dilkaya, Van, in east Turkey that dates back to the Urartu Age (800 BC) (with permission of the Turkish Journal of Neurosurgery). Erbengi A. History and development of neurosurgery in Anatolia (part one). Turk Neurosurg 1993;3:1-5.DEVELOPMENT OF MODERN MEDICAL EDUCATION IN TURKEY During the rise (1299-1453) and expansion (1453-1556) periods of the Ottoman Empire, medicine was practiced according to classic Greco-Roman and Islamic doctrines. The first university (Istanbul University) within the empire was established in the year 1453 after the conquest of Istanbul by Sultan Mehmet II the Conqueror, and Fatih the Conqueror's Mosque Complex (1470) later became a location for medical education and patient care for >350 years. Similarly, the Süleymaniye Mosque Complex, founded by Sultan Süleyman I (the Magnificent) in 1555, included a hospital for patient care and medical education and served people until the early 2000s.3 Other hospital complexes included Bursa (1339), Edirne (1488), and Manisa (1539).4 However, as a result of changes in the Western world such as the Renaissance, Reformation, and conquest of the new world, the Ottoman Empire was unable to keep up in terms of medical knowledge, and the empire entered a long period of stagnation from 1566 to 1827. During this period, the empire suffered a major reduction in its military, political, economic, and scientific powers. At the beginning of the 19th century, attempts were made to modernize the army to compete with the Western world. As a result, the first military schools were opened, which included medical schools and military hospitals. The first modern military medical school, Tersane Tıp Mektebi (Naval Medicine School), was established by Sultan Selim III in 1805 as part of an attempt to modernize the traditional army (Janissary System).5 However, this attempt failed; Sultan Selim III was dethroned, imprisoned, and later killed in a revolt led by the Janissaries in 1808; and the medical school was closed. Later, Sultan Mahmud II was able to establish reforms and to replace the traditional army (the Janissaries) with a modern, Western-like army. As a result, the first medical schools Tıbhane-i Amire (the School of Medicine) and Cerrahhane-i Amire (the School of Surgeons) were founded during Mahmud II's reign in 1827.1 These 2 schools were joined in 1839, representing the core of what is now the Istanbul Medical Faculty of Istanbul University.1 The language of education was French, with Dr Charles Ambrois Bernard holding the first position of dean of the Medical Faculty.6 The faculty had a medical journal titled Vakayı İlmiye, and first graduates of the school exited in 1843.6 The Gülhane Military Medical Academy was founded in 1898 and included Drs Robert Rieder and Georg Dycke, chairmen from Germany. In 1908, these 2 medical schools were united as a part of the university Darülfünun-ı Osmani.”6 During the 1909-1910 academic year, a Turkish surgeon, Cemil Paşa (Topuzlu), became the chairman of the educational board of the faculty (Figure 2). The medical faculty had undertaken an Anglo-Saxon–type education similar to its Western counterparts, which consisted of 5 years of theoretical, practical, and clinical education and a 1-year internship (Figure 3).6FIGURE 2: Cemil Topuzlu was a very important figure in the history of both surgery and neurosurgery in Turkey. He is most likely the first Turkish physician to present a case at an international conference (International Congress of French Neurosurgical Society, Lyon, 1894) in the field of neurosciences.FIGURE 3: Hospital buildings used for medicine faculties in the late Ottoman period were derived from buildings designed for other purposes. The building of the Faculty of Medicine, then called Mekteb-i Tıbbiye-i Şahane, was built in 1903 and designed by Alexandre Vallaury and Raimondo D'Aronco, famous contemporary architects of the period, as an 80 000-m2 hospital complex. Today, it serves as the campus of Marmara University.With the foundation of the modern Turkish Republic by Mustafa Kemal Atatürk in October of 1923, the country entered a whole new era. Following Atatürk's mantra that “the most real guidance in the life is science,” the principles of education in the country were completely transformed. Although centers of Western-type education, as explained above, were available for citizens during the Ottoman Reign, public education throughout the majority of the country remained traditional. However, with the reforms of the Turkish Republic, all levels of public education were made to include methodologies that were more modern. For example, the first female students graduated from medical school in 1927. The modern concept of a university in Turkey was established in August 1933, along with the countrywide drive for university reform.6 With the help of Jewish-German scientists such as Drs Erich Frank and Rudolph Nissen, who fled their homeland because of the rise of Nazism, the Medical Faculty of Istanbul University grew to become an important educational center. To this day, the center maintains its reputation via the contributions of many Turkish scientists, who are motivated by the philosophy of the republic. Aziz Sancar, who won a Nobel Prize in 2015 for chemistry, graduated from Istanbul University's Medical Faculty in 1969. Today, there are >84 faculties of medicine in the Turkish Republic, making the country one of the most important in the world in terms of research productivity in this area.7 HISTORY OF NEUROSURGERY IN TURKEY In the second half of the 19th century, many Turkish physicians were sent abroad for medical and surgical training. Among them, Cemil Paşa (Topuzlu), who completed his surgical training in France, became a pioneer in the field of surgery.1,8,9 In addition to being considered the founder of modern surgery in Turkey, Topuzlu also played an important role in the development of neurosurgery in the country, performing various neurosurgical procedures for cranial traumas, peripheral nerve injuries, Pott disease, spinal injuries, and cerebral infections,1,9 Indeed, he is most likely the first Turkish physician to present a case at an international conference (the International Congress of French Neurosurgical Society, Lyon, 1894) in the field of neuroscience.9 Topuzlu's case concerned a patient who presented with jacksonian epilepsy caused by an open compression fracture on the motor cortex complicated by a brain abscess. The abscess was successfully treated via drainage.10 The case is notable in that it was presented only a few years after McEwen's first report of brain abscess drainage. Neurosurgery has a relatively short history compared with other medical and surgical disciplines in Turkey. During the late Ottoman Period, much like Cemil Topuzlu, many general or ear-nose-throat surgeons performed neurosurgery. Such surgeons included Drs Alexander Kamburoğlu (?-1913), Garabe Yahoub (1865-1936), Julius Wieting (1868-1922), Kerim Sebat (1870-1942), Orhan Abdi (1878-1948), Mim Kemal Öke (1884-1955), and Murat Cankat (1886-1963).1 Among these, Dr Öke, who was chief of the Gulhane Military Medical Academy and was later known as Atatürk's personal doctor, wrote the first Turkish neurosurgical textbook, Dimağ ve Cümcüme Afetleri ve Tedavileri (Disorders of the Brain and the Skull and Their Treatment), in 1924.11 Dr Mazhar Osman Uzman (1884-1955), who finished his training in Germany with Dr Emil Kraepelin, is considered the founder of modern psychiatry in Turkey. Between 1916 and 1918, Uzman published the first Turkish neuroscience journal, Emraz Akliye ve Asabiye Müsamereleri.12 Furthermore, he was a mentor to many young medical students and surgeons, encouraging them to train in the field of neurosurgery. Indeed, he played a crucial role in the establishment of neurosurgery as an independent discipline in Turkey.13 Under his influence, Dr Abdülkadir Cahit Tuner (1892-1980), originally a neuropsychiatrist, became the first physician in Turkey with a Neurosurgical Fellowship Certificate after working with Dr Otfrid Förster in Breslau, Germany, for a year.1,8,9 On his return, Tuner established the first neurosurgery department in Turkey at the Zeynep Kamil Hospital, where he performed craniotomies for brain tumors, laminectomies for spinal tumors, and percutaneous treatment for trigeminal neuralgia from 1923 to 1927.1,8 After 4 years of efficient work, however, he retired from his job as a result of a conflict with his mentor, Dr Uzman, which resulted in the delay of the development of neurosurgery in Turkey. Dr Hami Dilek (1892-1980), also originally a general surgeon, went to France in the late 1930s for neurosurgical training under Dr Uzman. He worked with Drs Clovis Vincent and Thierry de Martel, returning to Turkey after finishing his education in 1936.1,14 After his return, he opened an independent clinic as a division of the General Surgery Department at Bakırköy Hospital for Mental and Nervous System Disorders in 1947, which was the first neurosurgery clinic in Turkey.14 However, Dilek sought a neurosurgical center for both patient referrals and neurosurgical training. In 1949, he was able to achieve his goal in founding an independent clinic with 20 beds in Haydarpaşa Numune Hospital. The Ministry of Health soon accepted neurosurgery as an independent specialization, and Dilek's clinic at Haydarpaşa Numune Hospital became the first neurosurgery department with a neurosurgical resident training program, for which he was appointed chairman.14 Along with Dr Dilek, Drs Cemil Şerif Baydur, Mustafa Sakarya, and Cafer Tayyar Kankat went abroad for neurosurgical training in the 1930s. Much as Dr Dilek did, Drs Baydur and Kankat went to France and worked with Drs Vincent and de Martel. Dr Baydur published a Turkish neurosurgical textbook called Nöroşirürji Bahisleri,15 and although Dr Kankat privately practiced neurosurgery instead of working in a university or government hospital, his contribution to Turkish neurosurgery came in the establishment of one of the earliest international neurosurgery journals, Modern Cerrahi ve Nöroşirürji Mecmuası (Journal of Modern Surgery and Neurosurgery), which ran from 1936 to 1947 (Figure 4).16 Dr Sakarya went to the United States and became a fellow of the legendary Dr Walter E. Dandy.17FIGURE 4: Dr Cafer Tayyar Kankat's contribution to Turkish neurosurgery was to publish one of the first international neurosurgery journals, Modern Cerrahi ve Nöroşirürji Mecmuası (Journal of Modern Surgery and Neurosurgery), from 1936 to 1947.The development of neurosurgery in Turkey as an independent specialization in the universities began in the 1950s. Dr Bülent Tarcan (1914-1991), originally a general surgeon, traveled to the United Kingdom in 1950 to train in the field of neurosurgery and to work with Dr Northfield.1,14 A versatile and sophisticated personality, Dr Tarcan was also very well known as a pioneer in the field of Western classical music in Turkey.18 Tarcan established the first neurosurgery clinic in a university hospital as a division of the General Surgery Department of Istanbul University, Istanbul Medical Faculty in 1952 on his return from the United Kingdom. This clinic would go on to become an independent department in 1968.19 Along with his neurosurgical achievements, he was a composer of various Western works of classical music, including piano suites, concertantes, chamber music, orchestrals, and ballets. After his retirement from the Istanbul University as a neurosurgery professor, he served as a professor of classical music composition at the State Conservatory of Mimar Sinan Fine Arts University (Figure 5).18 His versatile personality helped to shape and influence the professional and personal lives of his fellows, residents, and students and continues to influence the spirit of his department to this day.FIGURE 5: Dr Bülent Tarcan is the founder of the neurosurgery clinic at Istanbul University, which is the first neurosurgery clinic in a university hospital in Turkey. He is also one of Turkey's famous classical music composers. His biography, written by Evin İlyasoğlu, discusses his passion for both neurosurgery and classical music.Dr Feyyaz Berkay (1915-1993), yet another Turkish general surgeon, completed his neurosurgical training with Dr Roland M. Klemme in the United States at St. Louis University between 1946 and 1951.1 He was the first Turkish neurosurgeon certified by the American Board of Neurosurgery,20 as well as the founder and first chairman of the Neurosurgery Department of the Cerrahpaşa Medical Faculty. Dr Berkay also played an important role in the establishment of the Turkish Neurosurgical Society (TNS) and the organization of the first national congress in 1971. Dr Hüsamettin Gökay, an American board–certified neurosurgeon, finished his residency under the supervision of Dr Paul C. Bucy in Chicago in 1954. He worked as an attending neurosurgeon in Chicago for another year before coming back to Turkey in 1955 to work in the Neurosurgery Department of Bakırköy Hospital for Mental and Nervous System Disorders and later in the Neurosurgery Department of Istanbul University's medical faculty. Along with Dr Hamit Ziya Gökalp, Gökay is one of the oldest active members of the TNS, representing an excellent role model for young neurosurgeons in terms of professional discipline and dedication. Lastly, Dr Aysima Altınok finished her residency in the Neurosurgery Department of Haydarpaşa Numune Hospital under the supervision of Dr Dilek14 and became the first female neurosurgeon in Turkey in 1959. She is one of the earliest female neurosurgeons worldwide. Later in her career, she became chief of the Department of Neurosurgery at Bakırköy Hospital for Mental and Nervous System Disorders in 1968. She is still an active member of the TNS. After these developments in Istanbul, new neurosurgery departments started to develop in the relatively young universities of Turkey, beginning in Ankara, the capital and second biggest city, in the late 1950s. The Gulhane Military Medical Academy was the first center to have an independent neurosurgery clinic in Ankara. After finishing his residency abroad, Dr Zinnur Rollas became the chairman of the clinic in 1957,21 and in 1959, Dr Hamit Ziya Gökalp became the first resident of the clinic. However, because of the lack of a certain residency program, Dr Gökalp was sent to the United States for residency, and on his return, practical residency training began.22 Dr Vahdettin Türkmen, who finished his residency under the guidance of Dr Francis Grant at the Philadelphia Medical Center at the University of Pennsylvania, established the Neurosurgery Department of Hacettepe University's Medical Faculty. However, just a year later, he left Turkey.1 Nurhan Avman (1928-1988), a former resident of Dr James Poppen at the Lahey Clinic in Boston and Dr Ernest Sachs, Jr at Dartmouth College School of Medicine, became the chairman of this department (Figure 6).1 In 1965, he left Hacettepe University and established the neurosurgery department of Ankara University. Neurosurgery departments were founded in Izmir at Ege University by Dr Erdem Tunçbay (1930-2010) in 1967 and in Adana at Çukurova University in 1972, which were then followed by the establishment of other departments countrywide.1 Dr Gazi Yaşargil also deserves mention as a figure who offered microneurosurgical training to many Turkish neurosurgeons from various clinics in his department in Zurich, which helped to develop Turkish neurosurgery in relation to the latest advances and technical standards.FIGURE 6: Dr Nurhan Avman is a pioneering neurosurgeon and founder of neurosurgery clinics at the universities of Hacettepe and Ankara. He was also the first president of the Turkish Neurosurgical Society.Including state and private universities, government training, and research hospitals, there are 83 neurosurgery training programs in Turkey today, with approximately 150 residents in training nationwide. There are currently >1500 neurosurgeons in Turkey. At present, a neurosurgical education lasts 5 years in Turkey, including 7 months of rotations. In terms of neurosurgical technologies and surgical techniques, Turkey is up to date with the of the world, and research the contribution to neurosurgical between and it in in terms of general research for for case and for clinical The first neurosurgical in Turkey was founded in Istanbul by neurosurgeons in This was however, as a result of a military in much like other organization in Turkey. In the was founded in Ankara by with Dr Nurhan Avman as its first included Drs Osman M. M. M. Mehmet Murat and There were members of the as of The to young neurosurgeons in terms of research and clinical education abroad, scientific the public of and of public to and the professional of its In the a of each to neurosurgical education The also for scientific In the current year, the are as Hamit Ziya Gökalp, Erdem Neurosurgery Board Aysima Neurosurgery Prize and and The has its congress in at the of the Neurosurgery Congress for the years. In both the Congress and Neurosurgery Congress These for the scientific and of members and residents in training. In addition to the there are by the in major throughout Turkey such as Istanbul, Ankara, and for the training and education of including and and and work each of which at in addition to many and its scientific the has established various and to public professional and the of for The has 2 scientific journals, both of which have in a Turkish Journal called Nöroşirürji and the international journal Turkish which is currently in and The journal has an of with a of according to the of Journal in (Figure The first of this journal was Dr and its first board included Drs M. M. and Dr also because of his and of his board during the of the journal in the in to these the journal became more known each year, with only of of the now coming from Turkey. to the journal are of a from all the world, from the United States to Germany to and to the to were published and were An has used for scientific journals, the a each year to members of various and with a of the also sent to In addition to the journals, the has published on of Turkish Neurosurgery is the international journal of the Turkish Neurosurgical Society, which is in the and has in has Neurosurgery to a of neurosurgery for residents and young The education and its are very similar to of the of Neurosurgical training A finished in 4 with to on of neurosurgery. In the to an International Neurosurgery on other national International Neurosurgery to to the training and a education for neurosurgeons of with a on Today, the is a for the TNS, with an of each year and with from in The is a member of and the of Neurosurgical The only and national also international such as the International the Neurosurgical the Neurosurgical the the Congress of and with other neurosurgical such as the in and the Neurosurgical in The also an with Congress of with the first in 2015 in Turkey, followed by another in of the year in Istanbul was as the of the Congress of and the of Neurosurgical Congress in Istanbul one of the most and important by the TNS. have offered a of the history and current status of neurosurgery in Turkey, with a on the TNS. The have or in of the or in this
BibTeX
@inproceedings{krs2016history,
  author = {Talat Krş and Mehmet Akçakaya},
  title = {{History and Current Status of Neurosurgery in Turkey}},
  booktitle = {Neurosurgery},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1227/neu.0000000000001282},
}

Loading related content...

Figure