Historical Water Management Strategies—Case Study of Traditional Villages in Southern China, Hunan Province

Ning DongGe, Jinbiao Yan, Peilin Liu, Martin van den Toorn, Albert FeketeLand 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates historical rainwater management strategies in two traditional Chinese villages, revealing how their architectural design and site selection were intricately linked to local environmental conditions. The findings highlight the adaptability and sustainability of these ancient systems, offering valuable lessons for modern urban planning and water resource management, particularly in the face of climate change.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses the growing challenge of sustainable water resource management in the context of increasing urbanization and climate change. It posits that traditional settlements, often developed in close harmony with their natural environment, hold valuable, time-tested strategies for managing water. Specifically, the authors aim to explore and understand the underlying logic, mechanisms, and adaptability of these historical water management systems, particularly focusing on rainwater harvesting in traditional Chinese villages. The research seeks to bridge the gap between traditional ecological knowledge and contemporary needs for sustainable development, offering insights that can inform modern urban landscape planning and water resource management.

Methods

The study employed a multi-faceted approach combining:

  • Field Investigation and On-site Interviews: To gather qualitative data on the traditional water management practices and cultural context.
  • Photogrammetry and 3D Modeling: Using DJI Phantom3 drones and Contextcapture software to create detailed 3D models of the settlements. This allowed for precise measurement of architectural features like roof and patio areas, which are crucial for calculating water catchment.
  • Surface Measurements and Linear Regression Analysis: Performed using Acute3D viewer to quantify the relationship between different catchment areas (roof and patio).
  • Topographic Data Analysis: Collected via Google Earth and processed with Surfer software to understand the terrain, surface runoff patterns, and the overall spatial layout of the villages.
  • Quantitative Calculation: Estimating the amount of rainwater collected based on measured catchment areas and meteorological data (precipitation).
  • Comparative Analysis: Contrasting the strategies, capacities, and influencing environmental factors of the two studied villages.

The novelty lies in the integrated use of advanced remote sensing and 3D modeling techniques to quantitatively analyze traditional architectural elements and their contribution to water management, combined with qualitative insights from local knowledge.

Datasets

The study utilized the following data sources:

  • Meteorological Data: Annual average precipitation, temperature, and humidity data for the two villages, specifically referencing data from 1981-2010 and a meteorological data website [40].
  • Geospatial Data: Topographic data obtained from Google Earth.
  • Architectural Data: Measured roof and patio areas of dwellings within the two villages, collected through drone photogrammetry and 3D modeling. This data was presented in Table 2, detailing the catchment areas for individual buildings and their ratios.
  • Settlement Area Data: Total area and river area for each village, used in conjunction with precipitation data to estimate total water collection capacity (Table 3).

No new benchmarks were introduced; rather, the study analyzed existing environmental and architectural data within the context of the chosen case study villages.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Holistic Water Management: Traditional settlements viewed water management not just at the building level but as an integrated system encompassing individual dwellings, the settlement layout, and the surrounding landscape.
  • Environmental Adaptation is Key: Despite similar underlying strategies (e.g., roof and patio collection), the actual water collection capacity varied significantly between the two villages. This difference was directly attributed to their adaptation to specific local conditions, namely precipitation levels and topography.
  • Feng Shui's Practicality: The study connects traditional Feng Shui principles (e.g., siting between mountains and rivers) to practical environmental benefits, such as thermal regulation, wind management, and crucially, optimal water management and flood mitigation.
  • Cultural Sustainability: The paper argues that the sustainability of traditional water management is deeply intertwined with cultural values and practices, suggesting that these strategies offer more than just resource efficiency; they embody a way of life.
  • Sponge City Principles Pre-dated the Term: The traditional approach of using topography and architectural design to manage surface runoff and infiltration aligns with modern "sponge city" concepts, demonstrating the long-standing efficacy of these principles.

Key Results

  • Quantitative Water Collection Differences: ZhangGuYing village collected an estimated 5.73 million liters of rainwater annually, while ShangGanTang village collected 1.784 million liters. This difference, despite similar strategies, was explained by environmental factors.
  • Precipitation and Topography Influence: ShangGanTang village, with higher precipitation (1426 mm vs. 1353 mm) and a larger river area (3745.28 m² vs. 1125.23 m²), had a higher potential for water collection. However, its lower overall collection capacity was linked to its topography and a greater emphasis on flood control, leading to smaller roof and patio areas. ZhangGuYing, with lower precipitation and river size but a flatter terrain, maximized its collection capacity by adjusting roof size.
  • Linear Correlation: A positive linear correlation was found between roof and patio areas in both villages, indicating a consistent design logic for rainwater harvesting and storage.
  • Cultural Expression of Water Management: The "DaWu" architectural style in ZhangGuYing, where dwellings are connected by roofs, exemplifies a cultural approach to maximizing rainwater collection and integration.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Availability: The paper notes that newer official data for village populations were not available, relying on older figures.
  • Generalizability: While the study provides deep insights into two specific villages, further research is needed to assess the broader applicability of these traditional methods across different regions and cultural contexts.
  • Contemporary Adaptability: The authors suggest that future studies should focus on the contemporary adaptability of traditional rain harvesting methodologies from a global perspective, particularly in urban environments facing climate change challenges.
  • Urban Application: The paper explicitly mentions the potential for improving urban and landscape structural systems in a European context by applying oriental traditions, aiming to mitigate urban flooding.

Summary updated

Abstract

Based on the landscape architecture of traditional settlements in southern China, this study takes water as a vital element through field investigation and model analysis to explore the water management strategies of two traditional villages in Xiangjiang River Basin, Hunan Province. We have found that traditional settlements are located between rivers and mountains. The community of the settlement has a strong interaction with the water environment. The water management system consists of two parts: the rainwater collection and storage system of a single building and the settlement’ s water collection and drainage system. Through calculation, we found that the amounts of water collected (per year) between the two villages are different: ZhangGuYing (Z village) = 5.73 million L, ShangGanTang (S village) = 1.784 million L, in spite of the fact that water management strategies of the two settlements are similar. Further analysis shows that the difference is related to the adaption of the precipitation and topography of the surrounding areas. The above-mentioned systematic management strategy of water resources has been used until currently, with adaptability, low cost, and sustainability. It has outstanding significance for the current demand for sustainable development from both resource management and cultural aspects.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dongge2022historical,
  author = {Ning DongGe and Jinbiao Yan and Peilin Liu and Martin van den Toorn and Albert Fekete},
  title = {{Historical Water Management Strategies—Case Study of Traditional Villages in Southern China, Hunan Province}},
  booktitle = {Land},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/land11122107},
}
Figure