Historical Trends in Smart City Governance for the Management of Ancient Urban Centers in Iran: A Case Study of Saqqez Municipality

Lucia Nucci, Akbar Heydari, Najmedin Gilani, Saleh Aminpoor, Yang Liu, Mehdi Gheisari2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study evaluates the transition of Saqqez, an ancient urban center in Iran, into a "smart city" by identifying the primary risks across technological, organizational, and environmental dimensions. Using Structural Equation Modeling (SEM), the researchers found that organizational hurdles—specifically electronic transactions and data privacy—pose a greater threat to successful governance than the technology itself.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Rapid urbanization in Iran, particularly in the Kurdistan province, has outpaced traditional infrastructure management. While "Smart City" initiatives offer a path toward sustainability and efficiency, implementing them in ancient urban centers like Saqqez is fraught with risk.

The authors argue that most smart city frameworks are designed for modern metropolises and fail to account for the specific geopolitical, historical, and organizational constraints of cities like Saqqez. There is a significant gap in understanding which specific "hazards"—ranging from cybersecurity breaches to bureaucratic inertia—most significantly impede the adoption of smart governance in this unique context.

Methods

The researchers employed a quantitative, descriptive-analytical approach:

  • Expert Survey: A structured questionnaire was distributed to 55 experts and professionals within Saqqez Municipality, including specialists from Crisis Management, the Fire Department, and Environmental Safety.
  • Indicator Selection: Indicators were initially gathered from literature but refined by local experts. Notably, technologies like Blockchain and IoT were excluded from the final model because they are not yet present in Saqqez, while "urban smart displays" and "waste management" were added to reflect local priorities.
  • Structural Equation Modeling (SEM): Using AMOS software and the Maximum Likelihood method, the team analyzed the structural relationships between technological, organizational, and environmental dimensions to identify which factors had the highest "factor loadings" (a measure of how much a specific variable contributes to the overall risk profile).
  • Reliability: The instruments were validated using Cronbach’s alpha, yielding high scores (0.875 to 0.922) across all dimensions.

Datasets

The study relies on a primary dataset generated specifically for this research:

  • Expert Population: 55 municipal experts with an average tenure of 9.13 years.
  • Geographic Focus: Saqqez Municipality, Iran.
  • Benchmarking: While no external "standard" dataset was used, the model fit was benchmarked using the Root Mean Square Error of Approximation (RMSEA), achieving a score of 0.077, which indicates a robust and "good" fit for the proposed model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Organizational Bottleneck: Contrary to the common belief that technology is the hardest part of a smart city, this study reveals that organizational factors present the most significant risks. If the bureaucracy cannot handle electronic communication or data preparation, the smartest sensors in the world won't help.
  • AI as a High-Risk Factor: Within the technological dimension, Artificial Intelligence (AI) showed the highest factor loading (0.85 in the abstract; 0.79 in the text). This suggests that experts view the potential for AI-driven errors or security breaches as a top-tier threat.
  • The "Ancient" Constraint: The paper highlights that Saqqez’s status as an ancient center with mountainous terrain (Zagros range) and a sensitive border location adds layers of "environmental" risk—specifically regarding public space lighting and energy security—that modern "greenfield" smart cities don't face.
  • Integration over Innovation: The authors suggest that the solution isn't just "more tech," but the unification of fragmented risk management entities (e.g., merging the efforts of the Red Crescent and the Fire Department into a centralized data system).

Key Results

  • Technological Risks: AI (0.79–0.85) and Software (0.768) were the most critical factors. Interestingly, "system failure" and "social propaganda" had the lowest factor loads, suggesting experts are less worried about total blackouts than they are about the nuances of AI and software security.
  • Organizational Risks: Electronic transactions (0.820) and Privacy (0.760) were the dominant threats. This underscores a deep-seated concern regarding unauthorized access to government documents and the security of digital financial processes.
  • Environmental Risks: Public spaces (0.798) and Energy (0.795) were identified as the most vulnerable areas, particularly regarding disruptions to network-connected lighting and transportation systems.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several constraints:

  • Sample Size: The study is limited to 55 experts within a single municipality. Future research could expand this to a multi-city comparison across Iran.
  • Technological Absence: Because certain technologies (like Blockchain) aren't yet implemented in Saqqez, they couldn't be evaluated as risks, potentially leaving a "blind spot" for future implementation phases.
  • Proposed Solutions: The paper calls for the recruitment of specialized risk management professionals and the establishment of a "National Crisis Management Center" to centralize data, but it does not provide a roadmap for the significant funding required for these initiatives.

Summary updated

Abstract

Objective: This study aims to assess the risks and hazards associated with smart city governance in Saqqez Municipality, with a focus on identifying key threats across technological, organizational, and environmental dimensions. Methodology: The research employed a quantitative approach, using a structured questionnaire distributed among experts within Saqqez Municipality. Data were analyzed using statistical methods, including structural equation modeling (SEM) to assess risk factors and their impacts across different dimensions of smart city governance. Findings: The findings, derived from the CLA method, indicate that within the three dimensions analyzed, the organizational dimension of smart urban governance in Saqqez Municipality presents the most significant risks and threats. Within the technological dimension, artificial intelligence (0.85), pattern orientation (0.762), smart sensors (0.753), and cybersecurity (0.748) exhibited the highest factor loadings. In the organizational dimension, data preparation (0.754), electronic processes (0.817), and electronic communication (0.753) were identified as having the highest impact percentages. Conclusion: The research concludes that comprehensive risk management strategies, including the integration of risk management organizations, establishment of a centralized data collection system, ongoing risk assessments, and recruitment of specialized professionals, are essential to enhance the safety, resilience, and sustainability of smart city initiatives in Saqqez Municipality.
BibTeX
@misc{nucci2023historical,
  author = {Lucia Nucci and Akbar Heydari and Najmedin Gilani and Saleh Aminpoor and Yang Liu and Mehdi Gheisari},
  title = {{Historical Trends in Smart City Governance for the Management of Ancient Urban Centers in Iran: A Case Study of Saqqez Municipality}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.61838/kman.ijimob.3.3.25},
}
Figure