HISSCLU

C. Böhm, Claudia Plant2008 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces HISSCLU, a novel semi-supervised clustering method that leverages hierarchical, density-based clustering. Instead of relying on explicit "must-link" and "cannot-link" constraints, HISSCLU expands clusters from labeled data points simultaneously, assigning labels to unlabeled points based on their consistency with the emerging cluster structure. This approach better preserves complex, multimodal class structures and provides a rich visualization of hierarchical class and cluster relationships.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In many real-world scenarios, we have large datasets where only a fraction of the data points are labeled with their true class. Traditional unsupervised clustering methods ignore this valuable partial supervision, while existing semi-supervised methods often impose rigid constraints (like "must-link" or "cannot-link" between specific pairs of points). These constraints can force dissimilar points into the same cluster or ignore important similarities between points of different classes, especially when classes are multimodal (i.e., a single class can span multiple distinct clusters). The paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a semi-supervised clustering method that effectively uses partial labels to guide clustering while preserving the underlying data structure and revealing hierarchical relationships between classes and clusters.

Methods

HISSCLU builds upon hierarchical density-based clustering, specifically drawing inspiration from OPTICS. The core innovation lies in its approach to incorporating supervision:

  • Simultaneous Cluster Expansion: Instead of pre-defining constraints, HISSCLU starts expanding clusters from all labeled data points concurrently.
  • Density-Based Reachability: It uses a concept of "path reachability distance" to determine how objects are connected through dense regions, similar to density-based clustering. An unlabeled object is assigned to the class of the labeled object from which it has the "minimum path" in terms of reachability distances.
  • Local Distance Weighting: To handle situations where class boundaries are not well-defined by low-density regions (i.e., when pre-labeled objects from different classes are mixed within a dense area), HISSCLU introduces a local distance weighting mechanism. This mechanism smooths out arbitrary distance variations and helps define more coherent class boundaries.
  • Hierarchical Visualization: The method produces a "semi-supervised cluster diagram" that visually represents the hierarchical structure of both clusters and classes, allowing users to understand relationships like class multimodality and inter-class similarity.

Datasets

The paper evaluates HISSCLU on several datasets:

  • Synthetic Data: Used for illustrating core concepts like ordering paths and the effect of distance weighting.
  • Real-world Datasets:
    • Ecoli Data
    • Yeast Data
    • Glass Data
    • Metabolic Data
    • Liver Data

These datasets are described as having varying dimensionality, numbers of instances, and class distributions, including unbalanced and multimodal classes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Constraints Can Be Detrimental: The paper argues that rigid "must-link" and "cannot-link" constraints can oversimplify complex data structures, especially when classes are multimodal. HISSCLU's approach of expanding from labeled points avoids this pitfall.
  • Visualizing Hierarchy is Crucial: The proposed cluster diagram is a powerful tool for understanding not just clusters but also the hierarchical relationships between classes and clusters. It helps answer questions about class similarity, multimodality, and potential class hierarchies.
  • Local Weighting for Ambiguous Boundaries: When density alone isn't enough to separate classes, local distance weighting provides a principled way to use supervision to refine class boundaries without distorting the underlying cluster structure.
  • Unsupervised Structure Informs Supervision: HISSCLU effectively uses the inherent density-based cluster structure to guide the assignment of labels to unlabeled data, making the process more robust and meaningful.

Key Results

  • Improved Cluster Structure Preservation: HISSCLU demonstrated better preservation of actual cluster structures compared to constraint-based methods, particularly for multimodal classes.
  • Effective Label Assignment: The method assigns class labels to unlabeled objects in a way that is maximally consistent with both the cluster structure and the given labels.
  • High Classification Accuracy: When used as a preprocessing step for classification (e.g., with SVM), HISSCLU achieved significant improvements in accuracy (e.g., from 80.2% to 85.4% on a synthetic dataset after outlier removal, and up to 97.0% on metabolic data by leveraging detected class hierarchies).
  • Robustness and Efficiency: The algorithm is described as determinate, efficient (O(n²) time complexity), and robust against noise.
  • Informative Visualization: The cluster diagram effectively visualizes class and cluster hierarchies, revealing insights not easily obtainable from standard plots.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Parameter Sensitivity: While the paper discusses parameter selection (p and ξ for weighting), the optimal choice might still require some tuning. The paper suggests starting with default values and adjusting based on desired class separation.
  • Scalability: While O(n²) is considered scalable for moderate to large databases, extremely large datasets might still pose challenges, though the paper doesn't explicitly detail performance on massive scales.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that HISSCLU can be applied as a preprocessing step for classification, implying further research into integrating its outputs with various classifiers. The visualization aspect also opens avenues for more advanced interactive exploration tools. The paper also hints at using domain knowledge to specify class hierarchies, suggesting potential for incorporating external information.

Summary updated

Abstract

In situations where class labels are known for a part of the objects, a cluster analysis respecting this information, i.e. semi-supervised clustering, can give insight into the class and cluster structure of a data set. Several semi-supervised clustering algorithms such as HMRF-K-Means [4], COP-K-Means [26] and the CCL-algorithm [18] have recently been proposed. Most of them extend well-known clustering methods (K-Means [22], Complete Link [17] by enforcing two types of constraints: must-links between objects of the same class and cannot-links between objects of different classes. In this paper, we propose HISSCLU, a hierarchical, density-based method for semi-supervised clustering. Instead of deriving explicit constraints from the labeled objects, HISSCLU expands the clusters starting at all labeled objects simultaneously. During the expansion, class labels are assigned to the unlabeled objects most consistently with the cluster structure. Using this information the hierarchical cluster structure is determined. The result is visualized in a semi-supervised cluster diagram showing both cluster structure as well as class assignment. Compared to methods based on must-links and cannot-links, our method allows a better preservation of the actual cluster structure, particularly if the data set contains several distinct clusters of the same class (i.e. the intra-class data distribution is multimodal). HISSCLU has a determinate result, is efficient and robust against noise. The performance of our algorithm is shown in an extensive experimental evaluation on synthetic and real-world data sets.
BibTeX
@misc{bohm2008hissclu,
  author = {C. Böhm and Claudia Plant},
  title = {{HISSCLU}},
  year = {2008},
  doi = {10.1145/1352431.1352486},
}

Loading related content...

Figure