Hill sphere contraction at light-speed: Prompt electromagnetic emission from the merger of stellar mass black holes in an AGN accretion disk

Barry McKernan, K. E. Saavik Ford, I. Bartos, M. J. Graham, Wladimir Lyra, Szabolcs Márka, Z. Márka, Nicholas P. Ross, Daniel Stern, Yuan-Pei YangarXiv 2019 · arXiv

Abstract

Accretion disks around supermassive black holes are promising sites for stellar mass black hole (BH) mergers due to mass segregation and merger acceleration by disk gas torques. At BH merger, a few percent of the mass is lost, generating gravitational waves detectable with Advanced LIGO and Advanced Virgo. The mass loss causes the merging system's sphere of influence, known as the Hill sphere (radius $R_H$), to contract at light speed, and gas within the Hill sphere will self-collide. Observational signatures will depend on how $R_H$ compares to the accretion disk height, $H$. If $R_{H}\geq H$, a UV flare emerges post-merger on timescale $R_{H}/c$. A thermalized disk hot spot alters the AGN optical/UV photometry and asymmetric broad emission line profiles can develop. If $R_{H}<H$, detectability depends strongly on the disk optical depth. Large optical sky surveys can be used now, during O3, to search for BH mergers in AGN disks. LIGO/Virgo triggers should include rough mass estimates to optimize follow-up.

Introduction

The detection of gravitational waves (GWs) from merging stellar-mass black holes (BHs) has opened a new window into the universe. However, identifying electromagnetic (EM) counterparts to these events remains a significant challenge, as BH mergers in vacuum are expected to be "dark." A compelling solution lies in the dense environments of Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN). In these regions, supermassive black holes (SMBHs) are surrounded by massive gas disks where stellar-mass BHs can migrate, pair up, and merge. This paper explores a mechanism for prompt EM signatures from such mergers, driven by the sudden change in the local gravitational environment.

The Mechanism: Hill Sphere Contraction and Recoil

When two BHs merge, they lose approximately 5% of their total mass to GW radiation. This mass loss occurs nearly instantaneously, causing the system's Hill sphere—the region where the binary's gravity dominates—to contract at the speed of light. Gas previously bound within the Hill sphere suddenly finds itself unbound or "homeless," leading to internal collisions and shocks.

Furthermore, asymmetric GW emission often imparts a "recoil kick" to the newly formed remnant BH, propelling it through the surrounding disk gas at speeds up to hundreds of kilometers per second. This motion creates a high-velocity shock, or "hot spot," as the BH plows through the disk material.

Observational Signatures and Detectability

The resulting EM signal is primarily a UV/optical flare. The detectability of this flare depends crucially on the geometry of the merger site, specifically the ratio of the Hill sphere radius ($R_H$) to the disk scale height ($H$).

  • Prompt Flares ($R_H \geq H$): If the Hill sphere is large enough to encompass the disk height, the shock-heated gas can radiate directly from the disk surface. This produces a prompt UV flare emerging within days of the merger.
  • Smothered Signals ($R_H < H$): If the merger occurs deep within the disk, the signal must diffuse through dense, opaque material, leading to a delayed and potentially obscured optical signature.
Predicted flux ratios for a $10^9 M_\odot$ SMBH across various accretion rates ($\dot{m}_{Edd}$) and binary separations. The dashed line indicates a 5% detection threshold.

The models indicate that for a $10^6 M_\odot$ SMBH, the resulting flare could represent a flux increase of over 5%, making it detectable by current and future wide-field surveys like the Zwicky Transient Facility (ZTF).

Predicted flux ratios for a $10^6 M_\odot$ SMBH. The curves show that for many configurations, the expected flux ratio exceeds the 5% detection threshold (dashed line).

Strategic Follow-up

To maximize the chances of detection, the authors suggest prioritizing GW triggers with total masses exceeding $50 M_\odot$. Such massive binaries are more likely to have larger Hill spheres, increasing the probability of a prompt, detectable flare. Surveys like ZTF and the upcoming Vera C. Rubin Observatory (LSST) are well-positioned to monitor AGN catalogs for these transient events.

Conclusion

Merging BHs in AGN disks are not necessarily invisible. The combination of Hill sphere contraction and recoil kicks provides a robust physical mechanism for generating detectable EM counterparts. Identifying these flares would not only confirm the AGN disk channel for BH mergers but also provide a new way to probe the physics of accretion disks and the evolution of black hole populations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Accretion disks around supermassive black holes are promising sites for stellar mass black hole (BH) mergers due to mass segregation and merger acceleration by disk gas torques. At BH merger, a few percent of the mass is lost, generating gravitational waves detectable with Advanced LIGO and Advanced Virgo. The mass loss causes the merging system's sphere of influence, known as the Hill sphere (radius $R_H$), to contract at light speed, and gas within the Hill sphere will self-collide. Observational signatures will depend on how $R_H$ compares to the accretion disk height, $H$. If $R_{H}\geq H$, a UV flare emerges post-merger on timescale $R_{H}/c$. A thermalized disk hot spot alters the AGN optical/UV photometry and asymmetric broad emission line profiles can develop. If $R_{H}<H$, detectability depends strongly on the disk optical depth. Large optical sky surveys can be used now, during O3, to search for BH mergers in AGN disks. LIGO/Virgo triggers should include rough mass estimates to optimize follow-up.
BibTeX
@misc{mckernan2019hill,
  author = {Barry McKernan and K. E. Saavik Ford and I. Bartos and M. J. Graham and Wladimir Lyra and Szabolcs Márka and Z. Márka and Nicholas P. Ross and Daniel Stern and Yuan-Pei Yang},
  title = {{Hill sphere contraction at light-speed: Prompt electromagnetic emission from the merger of stellar mass black holes in an AGN accretion disk}},
  year = {2019},
  eprint = {1907.03746},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1907.03746},
}

Loading related content...

Figure