High‐Resolution Lagrangian Inverse Modeling of CO2 Emissions Over the Paris Region During the First 2020 Lockdown Period

K. Nalini, Thomas Lauvaux, Charbel Abdallah, Jinghui Lian, Philippe Ciais, Hervé Utard, Olivier Laurent, Michel RamonetJournal of Geophysical Research Atmospheres 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses a sophisticated atmospheric modeling system to quantify CO2 emissions in the Paris region during the first COVID-19 lockdown. It reveals a significant reduction in emissions, particularly from traffic, and highlights the critical role of accurate prior emission data and dense observation networks for precise urban emission mapping.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurately quantifying greenhouse gas emissions from urban areas is crucial for developing effective climate mitigation strategies. Traditional "bottom-up" methods, like emissions inventories, often suffer from data gaps and outdated emission factors, leading to systematic underestimations. "Top-down" approaches, such as atmospheric inversion, offer a way to verify and refine these estimates by using atmospheric measurements. However, these methods face challenges in resolving emissions at the fine spatial scales relevant to cities and are sensitive to uncertainties in both emission inventories and atmospheric transport models. This paper specifically addresses the need to quantify emission changes in a major urban area during an unprecedented event – the COVID-19 lockdown – to test the capabilities of high-resolution inverse modeling.

Methods

The researchers employed a Lagrangian-based Bayesian inverse modeling system. This approach uses atmospheric transport model simulations (specifically, the Weather Research and Forecasting model with its chemistry transport module, WRF-Chem) to link surface emissions to observed atmospheric CO2 concentrations.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • High-Resolution Transport Modeling: WRF-Chem was configured at a 1 km horizontal resolution, allowing for a more detailed representation of atmospheric processes over the Paris region.
  • Lagrangian Particle Dispersion Model (LPDM): Used in backward mode to efficiently calculate the "footprint" or influence of different emission sources on the measurement sites.
  • Bayesian Inversion: This statistical framework combines prior knowledge (emission inventories) with observational data to produce an optimized estimate of emissions, accounting for uncertainties in both.
  • CO and CO2 Assimilation: The study initially used CO2 measurements alone and then incorporated carbon monoxide (CO) measurements. CO is co-emitted with CO2 from fossil fuel combustion, and its molar ratio with CO2 can help differentiate between traffic and non-traffic emission sources.
  • Sensitivity Tests: The authors performed various tests to assess the impact of different assumptions on the inversion results, including prior error variances, correlation lengths, and background mixing ratio definitions.

Datasets

  • Atmospheric CO2 and CO Mixing Ratios: Continuous measurements from a network of six ground-based towers in the Île-de-France region were used.
  • Prior Fossil Fuel Emission Inventory: The "Origins. Earth" inventory, providing high-resolution (1 km) emissions for six sectors (industry, transport, tertiary, residential, energy, and waste) for the Paris metropolitan area.
  • Biogenic CO2 Fluxes: Derived from the Vegetation Photosynthesis and Respiration Model (VPRM), driven by meteorological data.
  • CO/CO2 Ratios: Obtained from the TNO GHG and co-emitted species database for differentiating traffic and non-traffic emissions.
  • Meteorological Data: Hourly three-dimensional fields from the WRF-Chem model, initialized with ECMWF Re-Analysis data (ERA5).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Lockdown's Impact is Quantifiable: The study demonstrates that even with the inherent complexities of urban emission modeling, atmospheric inversion can detect and quantify significant emission reductions during events like lockdowns.
  • Prior Uncertainty is a Major Hurdle: The results strongly suggest that the accuracy of the prior emission inventory, particularly its error structure and spatial correlations, is a critical limiting factor for precise urban emission mapping.
  • CO as a Tracer is Useful but Not Definitive: While assimilating CO helped in distinguishing traffic from other emissions, it wasn't sufficient on its own to fully resolve sectoral contributions, indicating a need for additional tracers.
  • Dense Networks are Essential: The study implicitly highlights that while the existing tower network provided valuable constraints, a denser network would be necessary for more precise spatial mapping of emissions within the urban area.

Key Results

  • Overall Emission Reduction: The inversion estimated a 43% reduction in fossil fuel CO2 emissions in the Paris region during the first lockdown period (March-May 2020) compared to 2019. The prior inventory itself suggested a 37% reduction.
  • Traffic Emission Decrease: When using CO and CO2 data, traffic emissions were estimated to be reduced by 68% in 2020 compared to non-traffic emissions (which saw a 29% reduction).
  • Prior vs. Posterior: The inversion generally led to a positive readjustment of fossil fuel emissions compared to the prior inventory for both 2019 and 2020, suggesting the prior might have underestimated emissions in some areas.
  • Error Reduction: The inversion successfully reduced uncertainties in emission estimates, particularly in the central Paris region near observation sites, by 2% to 10%.
  • Lockdown Impact Robustness: Sensitivity tests indicated that the relative decrease in emissions between 2019 and 2020 due to lockdown restrictions was relatively robust to changes in prior error assumptions.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Prior Error Characterization: The paper acknowledges the lack of rigorous and objective quantification of prior emission errors, which significantly impacts inversion results. Future work should focus on better characterizing these errors, including their spatial structures.
  • Network Density: While the study demonstrates the utility of the existing network, a denser network of observation sites would be crucial for more precise spatial mapping of emissions within the urban area.
  • Sectoral Separation: The joint CO-CO2 inversion showed limitations in fully separating traffic and non-traffic emissions. The authors suggest that additional tracers (e.g., NOx) might be needed for better sectoral attribution.
  • Biogenic Fluxes: The inversion system's sensitivity to biogenic fluxes was limited, partly due to the tower gradient approach excluding non-local sources and sinks. Further investigation into biogenic flux modeling and its interaction with urban emissions is warranted.
  • Nighttime Emissions: The inversion primarily constrains daytime emissions (7-17 UTC). Understanding nighttime emissions and their contribution to the overall urban budget remains an area for future research.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Stringent mobility restrictions across the world during the COVID 19 pandemic have impacted local economies and, consequently, city carbon budgets, offering a unique opportunity to evaluate the capability of scientific approaches to quantify emissions changes. Our study aims to quantify and map CO 2 emissions from fossil fuel and biogenic CO 2 fluxes over the Paris metropolitan area during the first lockdown period (March‐May 2020) in France, in comparison with the same period in 2019. Our inversion system relies on transport model simulations initiated with the Weather Research and Forecasting chemistry transport model combined with a high‐resolution fossil fuel CO 2 emissions inventory, and biogenic CO 2 fluxes from a vegetation model. The inversion with atmospheric observations from a network of six towers resulted in a positive re‐adjustment of fossil fuel CO 2 emissions in 2019 and 2020 compared to prior. In 2020, the inversion resulted in a large emission reduction (43%) compared to 2019, while the reductions were estimated to be 37% based on the prior inventory itself. By assimilating CO mixing ratios in addition to CO 2 , the traffic emission estimates were reduced by 68% in 2020, compared to nontraffic (29%). Various sensitivity tests show that prior emission uncertainty and different background conditions significantly impacted the emissions estimates. We conclude that our current inversion system with atmospheric CO 2 monitoring makes it possible to identify the emission decrease in 2020 partly over the urban region. However, additional information on prior emission errors and a dense network will be needed to map emissions precisely.
BibTeX
@article{nalini2022highresolution,
  author = {K. Nalini and Thomas Lauvaux and Charbel Abdallah and Jinghui Lian and Philippe Ciais and Hervé Utard and Olivier Laurent and Michel Ramonet},
  title = {{High‐Resolution Lagrangian Inverse Modeling of CO<sub>2</sub> Emissions Over the Paris Region During the First 2020 Lockdown Period}},
  journal = {Journal of Geophysical Research Atmospheres},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1029/2021jd036032},
}
Figure