Highly Disordered Nanoporous Carbons for Enhanced Energy Storage in Supercapacitors

Xinyu Liu, Robert Hunter, Zhen Xu, El Hassane Lahrar, Céline Merlet, Clare P. Grey, Maria‐Magdalena Titirici, Alexander C. ForseChemRxiv 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper reveals that highly disordered nanoporous carbons with small graphene-like domains and high ion adsorption capacity are key to enhanced supercapacitor performance. The researchers demonstrate that low-temperature synthesis is a promising route to achieve these properties and, crucially, show that NMR spectroscopy can directly predict a carbon's capacitance based on its structural disorder and ion accessibility.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Supercapacitors are a vital energy storage technology, offering fast charging and long cycle life. Their performance heavily relies on the electrode material, typically nanoporous carbons. However, designing these carbons for optimal performance has been challenging due to their complex, disordered structures. While factors like pore size, surface area, and functional groups have been explored, clear design principles remain elusive. This paper aims to bridge this gap by investigating the fundamental relationship between the local structural order of nanoporous carbons and their electrochemical performance, specifically focusing on capacitance.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach combining synthesis, advanced spectroscopy, and electrochemical testing:

  • Low-Temperature Synthesis: They synthesized a series of nanoporous carbons from glucose using hydrothermal carbonization followed by chemical activation with KOH at temperatures ranging from 600-750 °C. This "low-temperature" approach was chosen to promote disorder and limit graphitization.
  • Raman Spectroscopy: Used to probe the degree of structural disorder. The intensity ratio of the D band to the G band (ID/IG) is a key indicator of disorder, with lower ratios suggesting smaller graphene-like domains.
  • Solid-State NMR Spectroscopy: This was a central technique. By using electrolyte-soaked carbon samples, they could simultaneously probe:
  • Local Structural Order: Through the chemical shift difference ($\Delta\delta$) of electrolyte ions, which is influenced by the "ring current effects" from the carbon's aromatic domains. Smaller $\Delta\delta$ values indicate smaller graphene-like domains.
  • Ion Adsorption Capacity: The integral of the "in-pore" NMR signal directly quantifies how many electrolyte ions can access the carbon's nanopores without an applied potential.
  • Gas Physisorption (N₂ isotherms): Used to determine standard porosity metrics like BET surface area and pore size distribution.
  • Electrochemical Testing: Gravimetric and volumetric capacitances were measured using cyclic voltammetry and galvanostatic charge-discharge cycles in an organic electrolyte (1M NEt₄BF₄/ACN).

Datasets

The paper utilizes data from:

  • Synthesized Carbons: A series of novel nanoporous carbons synthesized by the authors (labeled HTC-600, HTC-650, HTC-700, HTC-750, and variations with "_1" for different activation times).
  • Commercial Activated Carbons: Data from previously studied commercial activated carbons and their thermally annealed counterparts were included for comparison.
  • Carbide-Derived Carbons (CDCs): Data from CDCs were also incorporated for broader correlation analysis.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, the study leverages existing datasets alongside their newly synthesized materials to establish broader correlations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Disorder is King (for Capacitance): The study strongly reinforces the idea that smaller graphene-like domains (higher disorder) lead to higher capacitance. This is a significant departure from solely focusing on pore size and surface area.
  • NMR as a Dual Probe: The power of solid-state NMR lies in its ability to simultaneously assess both structural disorder ($\Delta\delta$) and ion accessibility (ion adsorption capacity) using the electrolyte ions themselves as probes. This provides a more holistic picture than techniques that measure porosity or disorder independently.
  • Ion Adsorption Capacity Matters: Beyond structural disorder, the ability of ions to access the carbon's internal structure (ion adsorption capacity) is a critical determinant of capacitance.
  • Predictive Power of NMR: The researchers developed a predictive model where capacitance can be accurately estimated directly from NMR-derived $\Delta\delta$ and ion adsorption capacity values. This offers a rapid screening tool for new materials.
  • Low-Temperature Synthesis Advantage: This approach proves effective in creating highly disordered carbons with small domain sizes, leading to enhanced performance.

Key Results

  • Enhanced Capacitance: Low-temperature synthesized carbons (e.g., HTC-600, HTC-650) exhibited significantly higher gravimetric and volumetric capacitances compared to commercially available carbons. For instance, HTC-600 showed a higher gravimetric capacitance than many commercial samples.
  • Correlation with Disorder: Gravimetric capacitance generally increased as the synthesis temperature decreased from 700 °C to 600 °C, correlating with smaller graphene-like domain sizes (lower $\Delta\delta$ values).
  • Correlation with Ion Adsorption: Capacitance also showed a strong positive correlation with ion adsorption capacity, with HTC-750 demonstrating the highest capacity and good capacitance.
  • Predictive Model Accuracy: The linear regression model combining $\Delta\delta$ and ion adsorption capacity to predict capacitance showed a strong agreement with measured values (Fig. 4b).
  • Trade-offs: While low-temperature carbons showed improved capacitance, they exhibited slightly poorer conductivity and reduced cycling stability compared to commercial counterparts.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cycling Stability: The authors acknowledge that the low-temperature synthesized carbons displayed reduced cycling stability. They hypothesize this could be due to reactive edge sites or the inherent reactivity of disordered structures. Future work should focus on addressing these stability challenges, potentially through conductive additives or electrode mass balancing.
  • Generalizability: While the study suggests the approach can be extended to various precursors and synthesis routes, further validation across a wider range of materials is needed.
  • Non-Microporous Carbons: The NMR-based prediction model is emphasized for predominantly microporous conductive carbons. The authors note that for non-porous or meso/microporous carbons, the interpretation of $\Delta\delta$ might differ.
  • Electrolyte Dependence: The study primarily used an organic electrolyte. Further investigations into the impact of different electrolytes (e.g., aqueous) on the structure-property relationships would be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

There has been a lack of clear principles for designing nanoporous carbons with enhanced performance in supercapacitors due to their structural complexity. Our recent NMR and Raman spectroscopy studies of a series of commercial nanoporous carbons showed that carbons with smaller graphene-like domains have higher capacitance. In this study, we demonstrate that low-temperature synthesis provides a promising route for producing highly disordered nanoporous carbons with enhanced gravimetric and volumetric capacitance. NMR spectroscopy measurements provided unique insights by simultaneously probing local structural order and ion adsorption capacities, revealing that carbons with smaller graphene-like domain sizes and higher ion adsorption capacities generally have better capacitive performance. We finally show that the capacitance of a nanoporous carbon can be predicted directly from the NMR spectra of electrolyte-soaked electrodes. Our findings establish a versatile strategy that can be extended to various carbon precursors and synthesis routes, paving the way for the development of next-generation energy storage materials.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2025highly,
  author = {Xinyu Liu and Robert Hunter and Zhen Xu and El Hassane Lahrar and Céline Merlet and Clare P. Grey and Maria‐Magdalena Titirici and Alexander C. Forse},
  title = {{Highly Disordered Nanoporous Carbons for Enhanced Energy Storage in Supercapacitors}},
  booktitle = {ChemRxiv},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.26434/chemrxiv-2025-4wvlj},
}
Figure