High white matter hyperintensity burden in strategic white matter tracts relates to worse global cognitive performance in community-dwelling individuals

J. Matthijs Biesbroek, Bonnie Lam, Lei Zhao, Yumi Tang, Zhaolu Wang, Jill Abrigo, Chiu‐Wing Winnie Chu, Adrian Wong, Lin Shi, Hugo J. Kuijf, Geert Jan Biessels, Vincent MokJournal of the Neurological Sciences 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the location of white matter hyperintensities (WMH), often associated with cognitive decline, significantly impacts overall cognitive performance. Specifically, WMH in the forceps minor and left anterior thalamic radiation tracts are linked to poorer global cognition, even when accounting for the total WMH burden. This suggests that damage to these "strategic" white matter pathways disrupts crucial cognitive networks, rather than just accumulating deficits in isolated domains.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

White matter hyperintensities (WMH) are common findings on brain MRI, particularly in older adults, and are linked to cognitive impairment and dementia. However, there's a notable variability: some individuals with substantial WMH show little cognitive decline, while others with less WMH experience significant impairment. This discrepancy highlights that not all WMH are created equal; their location likely plays a critical role in determining their impact on cognition. Previous "lesion-symptom mapping" studies have begun to identify specific white matter tracts where damage has a disproportionate effect on cognitive domains like executive function, processing speed, and memory. This paper aims to extend this understanding by investigating whether WMH in these "strategic" tracts also affect global cognitive functioning, as measured by widely used screening tools, independent of the overall WMH burden.

Methods

The researchers utilized a hypothesis-driven approach, focusing on two specific white matter tracts: the forceps minor and the anterior thalamic radiation (ATR). These tracts were chosen based on prior research linking them to SVD-related cognitive decline in specific domains.

The study involved 830 community-dwelling individuals from the CU-RISK Study. Brain MRI scans were acquired using a 3.0-T scanner. White matter hyperintensities (WMH) were segmented using a semi-automated method, with manual correction to ensure accuracy. These WMH maps were then registered to a standard MNI-152 template.

To quantify WMH burden in the strategic tracts, probabilistic white matter tract atlases were used. Global cognitive function was assessed using two validated screening tools: the Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA) and the Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE).

Statistical analysis involved stepwise linear regression models. Initially, models accounted for demographic factors (age, sex, education). Then, total WMH volume was added. Finally, the models were further adjusted for WMH volume in the forceps minor and left/right ATR, as well as other MRI markers of vascular injury (lacunes, microbleeds) and brain atrophy (brain parenchymal fraction), to determine if the strategic tract WMH had an independent effect on cognition.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the CU-RISK Study (The Chinese University of Hong Kong - Risk Index for Subclinical brain lesions in Hong Kong). This cohort comprised 830 community-dwelling individuals. No new datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Location Matters, Even for Global Cognition: The most significant insight is that the location of WMH is crucial for overall cognitive performance, not just for specific cognitive domains. This challenges the idea that global cognitive scores might simply average out localized deficits.
  • Strategic Tracts as Cognitive Hubs: The forceps minor and left ATR appear to be critical for maintaining global cognitive function. Damage here seems to disrupt networks that are essential for a broad range of cognitive processes.
  • Beyond Total Burden: The findings emphasize that simply measuring the total volume of WMH is insufficient to predict cognitive decline. The specific pathways affected are key.
  • MoCA's Sensitivity: The study notes that the MoCA, which includes more executive function tasks than the MMSE, showed significant associations with strategic WMH. This aligns with previous research suggesting MoCA's greater sensitivity to cognitive impairment, particularly in SVD.

Key Results

  • After correcting for age, sex, and education, WMH volume in the forceps minor and the left anterior thalamic radiation (ATR) were independently associated with lower MoCA scores (p = .019 and p = .038, respectively).
  • WMH volume in the forceps minor was also independently associated with lower MMSE scores (p = .020).
  • These associations remained statistically significant even after further adjustment for total WMH volume, brain parenchymal fraction, lacunes, and microbleeds.
  • WMH in the right ATR did not show a significant independent association with either MoCA or MMSE.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Precision of WMH Segmentation: Manual correction of WMH segmentations was performed on downsampled images, which may have reduced precision and potentially introduced noise, possibly affecting the sensitivity of the analyses.
  • Heterogeneity of WMH: The study could not distinguish between different underlying etiologies of WMH, which could influence their cognitive impact.
  • Limited Power for Hypothesis-Free Analysis: With 830 subjects, the study had insufficient power to explore the impact of WMH in all white matter regions, necessitating a hypothesis-driven approach.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that future research should investigate whether these findings reflect accumulated impairment in isolated cognitive domains or disruption of a network crucial for global cognitive performance. They also highlight the need for multicenter studies with thousands of subjects to investigate the cognitive impact of WMH in less frequently affected regions. Further research could also explore the role of underlying WMH etiology.

Summary updated

Abstract

The impact of WMH on global cognitive functioning depends on location. Whether this reflects accumulated impairment in isolated cognitive domains or disruption of a network that is crucially involved in global cognitive performance remains to be determined.
BibTeX
@article{biesbroek2020high,
  author = {J. Matthijs Biesbroek and Bonnie Lam and Lei Zhao and Yumi Tang and Zhaolu Wang and Jill Abrigo and Chiu‐Wing Winnie Chu and Adrian Wong and Lin Shi and Hugo J. Kuijf and Geert Jan Biessels and Vincent Mok},
  title = {{High white matter hyperintensity burden in strategic white matter tracts relates to worse global cognitive performance in community-dwelling individuals}},
  journal = {Journal of the Neurological Sciences},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jns.2020.116835},
}
Figure