High variability of climate and surface mass balance induced by Antarctic ice rises

Jan T. M. Lenaerts, Joel Brown, M. R. van den Broeke, Kenichi Matsuoka, Reinhard Drews, Denis Callens, Morgane Philippe, Irina Gorodetskaya, Erik van Meijgaard, Carleen H. Reijmer, Frank Pattyn, Nicole Van LipzigJournal of Glaciology 2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that Antarctic ice rises, unlike flat ice shelves, create significant local variations in climate and surface mass balance (SMB). By combining high-resolution climate modeling with observational data, the researchers found that ice rises enhance precipitation on their upwind slopes and influence wind patterns, leading to complex SMB distributions that are crucial for understanding ice sheet dynamics and interpreting paleoclimate records.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Antarctic ice shelves, vast floating ice masses, play a critical role in buttressing the grounded ice sheet. However, their surface mass balance (SMB) – the net gain or loss of ice from precipitation and sublimation – is often assumed to be relatively uniform across large areas. This simplification is problematic because features called "ice rises" (grounded ice masses surrounded by ice shelves) are known to influence local atmospheric conditions and ice flow. Despite their potential importance for both current ice sheet dynamics and as archives of past climate (via ice cores), the detailed impact of ice rises on local climate and SMB has been poorly understood due to a lack of high-resolution data and modeling. This paper aims to fill that knowledge gap by investigating how ice rises, specifically in Dronning Maud Land, East Antarctica, affect their immediate surroundings.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • High-Resolution Regional Climate Modeling: They utilized the Regional Atmospheric Climate Model (RACMO2) with a fine horizontal resolution of 5.5 km. This is a significant improvement over previous Antarctic SMB models, which typically operated at resolutions of 25-50 km, too coarse to resolve the topography of individual ice rises. RACMO2 was forced by ERA-Interim reanalysis data for the period 2001-2012.
  • Observational Data Integration: To validate and complement the model output, they incorporated data from:
  • Weather Stations: Data from Neumayer III (on an ice shelf) and AWS11 (on an ice rise) were used to evaluate near-surface temperature and humidity.
  • Ground-Penetrating Radar (GPR): GPR was used to infer SMB variations along transects across ice rises, providing a spatially continuous record of accumulation.
  • Firn Cores and Snow Stakes: These provided direct measurements of snow density and accumulation, used to calibrate the GPR-derived SMB and validate model results.
  • Snow Radar: Data from a snow radar at Princess Elisabeth base provided snowfall rate measurements.

Datasets

  • ERA-Interim Reanalysis Data: Used to force the RACMO2 model.
  • RACMO2 Model Output: 12 years (2001-2012) of high-resolution climate and SMB simulations.
  • Weather Station Data: From Neumayer III and AWS11 (2011).
  • Princess Elisabeth Base Data: Snowfall rate (2011-2012), snow height, and snowfall (2009-2012).
  • Ground-Penetrating Radar (GPR) Data: Collected on Derwael Ice Rise.
  • Firn Core and Snow Stake Data: Collected on Kupol Ciolkovskogo and Kupol Moskovskij.
  • Digital Elevation Model (DEM): Provided by Bamber et al. (2009), gridded to 1 km.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ice Rises Disrupt Homogeneity: Unlike the relatively uniform climate and SMB over flat ice shelves, ice rises create pronounced spatial variability in their immediate vicinity. This is a fundamental departure from previous assumptions.
  • Winter Warming Effect: Despite their higher elevation, ice rises can experience higher winter temperatures than surrounding ice shelves. This is attributed to their protrusion from the surface-based temperature inversions common over ice shelves and enhanced vertical mixing of warmer air.
  • Orographic Precipitation Dominance: The primary driver of SMB variability around ice rises is precipitation, significantly enhanced on the upwind (northeastern) slopes due to orographic lifting of moist air.
  • Precipitation Shadows: Conversely, downwind (southwestern) sides of ice rises experience a "precipitation shadow," with substantially lower accumulation.
  • Drifting Snow's Significant Role: Beyond precipitation, drifting snow (both erosion and deposition) plays a crucial role in shaping the SMB patterns, particularly on the downwind slopes.
  • Implications for Ice Core Studies: The strong SMB gradients around ice rises mean that ice core records from these locations will reflect a higher temporal resolution of past climate variations, particularly in accumulation, compared to cores from flat ice shelves.

Key Results

  • SMB Gradients: Annual mean SMB values can be significantly higher (2-6 times) on the northeastern slopes of ice rises compared to the surrounding ice shelf. For example, SMB exceeding 1000 mm w.e. a⁻¹ was modeled on upwind slopes, with minima below 100 mm w.e. a⁻¹ on downwind sides.
  • Temperature Differences: While Neumayer III (ice shelf) and AWS11 (ice rise) showed a small annual mean temperature difference (0.9 K), winter observations revealed periods where AWS11 was 5-10 K warmer due to inversion effects.
  • Model-Observation Agreement: RACMO2 simulations generally agreed well with observed temperatures and SMB patterns, particularly for precipitation. Discrepancies in SMB were often attributed to limitations in the DEM or fine-scale drifting snow processes not fully resolved by the model.

Limitations and Future Work

  • DEM Resolution: While the 5.5 km resolution of RACMO2 is high for Antarctic modeling, the underlying DEM has limitations, particularly in accurately representing the fine topographic details of ice rises, which can influence model results. Future work could benefit from higher-resolution DEMs.
  • Drifting Snow Processes: The study acknowledges that fine-scale drifting snow phenomena, which are not fully resolved by the model, may explain some discrepancies between modeled and observed SMB, especially in low-precipitation areas.
  • Ice Core Site Selection: The findings provide crucial guidance for selecting optimal locations for ice coring on ice rises to obtain high-resolution paleoclimate records.
  • Regional Ice-Shelf Mass Balance: Understanding these localized SMB variations is essential for improving regional ice-shelf mass balance estimates, which are critical for predicting sea-level rise.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Ice rises play key roles in buttressing the neighbouring ice shelves and potentially provide palaeoclimate proxies from ice cores drilled near their divides. Little is known, however, about their influence on local climate and surface mass balance (SMB). Here we combine 12 years (2001–12) of regional atmospheric climate model (RACMO2) output at high horizontal resolution (5.5 km) with recent observations from weather stations, ground-penetrating radar and firn cores in coastal Dronning Maud Land, East Antarctica, to describe climate and SMB variations around ice rises. We demonstrate strong spatial variability of climate and SMB in the vicinity of ice rises, in contrast to flat ice shelves, where they are relatively homogeneous. Despite their higher elevation, ice rises are characterized by higher winter temperatures compared with the flat ice shelf. Ice rises strongly influence SMB patterns, mainly through orographic uplift of moist air on the upwind slopes. Besides precipitation, drifting snow contributes significantly to the ice-rise SMB. The findings reported here may aid in selecting a representative location for ice coring on ice rises, and allow better constraint of local ice-rise as well as regional ice-shelf mass balance.
BibTeX
@article{lenaerts2014high,
  author = {Jan T. M. Lenaerts and Joel Brown and M. R. van den Broeke and Kenichi Matsuoka and Reinhard Drews and Denis Callens and Morgane Philippe and Irina Gorodetskaya and Erik van Meijgaard and Carleen H. Reijmer and Frank Pattyn and Nicole Van Lipzig},
  title = {{High variability of climate and surface mass balance induced by Antarctic ice rises}},
  journal = {Journal of Glaciology},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.3189/2014jog14j040},
}
Figure