Abstract: Formation of high spatial frequency laser induced periodic surface structures (HSFL) in germanium by 90 fs mid-IR pulses at a 1 kHz repetition rate with wavelengths between λ = 2 and 3.6 μm was studied with varying angle of incidence and polarization. The period of these structures varied from λ/3 to λ/8. A modified surface-scattering model including Drude excitation and the optical Kerr effect explains the spatial period scaling of HSFL across the mid-IR wavelengths. Transmission electron microscopy shows the presence of a 30 nm amorphous layer above the structure of crystalline germanium. Various mechanisms including two photon absorption and defect-induced amorphization are discussed as probable causes for the formation of this layer.
Introduction
Laser-Induced Periodic Surface Structures (LIPSS) have emerged as a powerful, single-step technique for creating nanostructures on various materials. While Low Spatial Frequency LIPSS (LSFL) are well-understood as resulting from the interference of incident light with surface electromagnetic waves, High Spatial Frequency LIPSS (HSFL)—with periods significantly smaller than the wavelength—present a more complex challenge. Germanium (Ge) is a particularly interesting candidate for such studies due to its importance in mid-infrared (mid-IR) optics and its exceptionally high third-order nonlinearity ($\chi^{(3)}$).
The Modeling Challenge
Traditional models, such as the Sipe model, often struggle to predict HSFL formation in semiconductors. This is because they typically treat the material's optical properties as static. In the mid-IR regime, the intense electric fields of femtosecond pulses induce significant nonlinear effects. Specifically, the optical Kerr effect and the excitation of a dense electron plasma (Drude excitation) dynamically alter the refractive index during the pulse, fundamentally changing the conditions for surface patterning. The authors sought to bridge this gap by determining how HSFL periods scale with wavelength and angle of incidence in the mid-IR regime.
Experimental Methodology
Experimental characterization utilized two Optical Parametric Amplifier (OPA) systems to generate 90 fs pulses across a wavelength range of 2.0 to 3.6 µm. Single-crystal Ge samples were irradiated at varying angles of incidence (0°, 45°, and 76°) and polarizations. Surface morphology was characterized using Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) and Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM). To investigate the subsurface structure, Focused Ion Beam (FIB) milling was employed to prepare cross-sections for Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM), allowing the researchers to see beneath the surface.
The Sipe-Drude-Kerr (SDK) Model
To account for the high-intensity dynamics, the authors developed the SDK model. This approach integrates the standard Sipe theory of surface scattering with two critical additions:
- Drude Excitation: Modeling the generation of a "plasma" of free carriers that shifts the dielectric constant.
- Optical Kerr Effect: Incorporating the intensity-dependent refractive index change caused by the intense light field itself.
In germanium, these two effects often compete; the Kerr effect is so strong that it can oppose the effects of electron excitation. The study demonstrates that including $\chi^{(3)}$ effects is essential for accurate predictions in highly nonlinear semiconductors.
Key Findings and Scaling
Experimental results revealed HSFL periods ranging from $\lambda/3$ down to an extreme $\lambda/8$. For a 3.6 µm laser, the structures were as small as ~450 nm. Notably, the HSFL period showed a remarkable insensitivity to the angle of incidence, a behavior that contradicts standard LSFL models but is successfully captured by the SDK model. The structures were consistently oriented parallel to the laser polarization.
Structural and Phase Analysis
High-resolution TEM imaging provided a breakthrough in understanding the material state. It revealed a distinct ~30 nm thick amorphous layer capping the crystalline Ge substrate. Diffraction patterns confirmed the transition from the disordered surface layer to the underlying single-crystal lattice. This "amorphous cap" suggests that the HSFL formation involves either rapid melting and quenching or a cumulative process of defect-induced amorphization over multiple laser pulses. The ripples themselves were found to have a peak-to-trough height of approximately 115 nm.
Discussion and Conclusion
The SDK model demonstrates that HSFL formation is optimized when the excited electron density is approximately half of the critical plasma density. At these levels, the surface remains non-metallic, distinguishing HSFL from LSFL, which typically requires metallic-like surface plasmon excitation. While the authors discuss two-photon absorption (TPA) and defect-induced amorphization as causes for the 30 nm amorphous layer, they note that the exact TPA coefficient for Ge in the mid-IR femtosecond regime requires further characterization. Future work will focus on the pulse-by-pulse evolution of the surface to further clarify the underlying phase-change mechanisms.
Summary updated