High-Resolution Maps of Real and Illusory Tactile Activation in Primary Somatosensory Cortex in Individual Monkeys with Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging and Optical Imaging

Li M. Chen, Gregory Turner, Robert M. Friedman, Na Zhang, John C. Gore, Anna Wang Roe, Malcolm J. AvisonJournal of Neuroscience 2007 · DOI

Abstract

Although blood oxygenation level-dependent (BOLD) functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) has been widely used to explore human brain function, questions remain regarding the ultimate spatial resolution of positive BOLD fMRI, and indeed the extent to which functional maps revealed by positive BOLD correlate spatially with maps obtained with other high-spatial-resolution mapping techniques commonly used in animals, such as optical imaging of intrinsic signal (OIS) and single-unit electrophysiology. Here, we demonstrate that the positive BOLD signal at 9.4T can reveal the fine topography of individual fingerpads in single-condition activation maps in nonhuman primates. These digit maps are similar to maps obtained from the same animal using intrinsic optical imaging. Furthermore, BOLD fMRI reliably resolved submillimeter spatial shifts in activation in area 3b previously identified with OIS as neural correlates of the "funneling illusion." These data demonstrate that at high field, high-spatial-resolution topographic maps can be achieved using the positive BOLD signal, weakening previous notions regarding the spatial specificity of the positive BOLD signal.

Introduction: Challenging the "Blurry" Reputation of fMRI

Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) is a cornerstone of modern neuroscience, yet it has long faced criticism regarding its spatial resolution. Because fMRI measures blood oxygenation (the BOLD signal) rather than direct electrical activity, its precision is theoretically limited by the brain's vascular architecture. Critics argue that large draining veins might pool deoxygenated blood far from active neurons, resulting in functional maps that are spatially offset or "smeared."

This study investigates the ultimate spatial specificity of the positive BOLD signal at ultra-high field strengths (9.4T). The researchers aimed to determine if fMRI could resolve the fine-grained topography of the primary somatosensory cortex (SI) and detect subtle, submillimeter shifts in activation associated with "illusory" tactile sensations.

Methods and Experimental Design

The researchers employed a multi-modal approach in eight squirrel monkeys across 25 imaging sessions. This allowed for a direct "ground-truth" comparison within the same subjects using three primary techniques:

  1. Ultra-High-Field fMRI (9.4T): High-resolution scans were performed during vibrotactile stimulation (8 Hz) of individual fingerpads (D1–D4).
  2. Optical Imaging of Intrinsic Signals (OIS): An invasive technique measuring light reflectance changes due to blood volume/oxygenation, serving as a high-resolution (~100 µm) validation standard.
  3. Electrophysiology: Microelectrode recordings confirmed somatotopic maps by measuring direct neuronal spiking.
Anatomical landmarks and MRI slice orientation in the squirrel monkey brain. Panel (a) shows slice locations relative to the surface coil; (b) provides a photograph of the brain with sulci labeled; (c) displays high-resolution MRI slices.

To push the limits of resolution, the team utilized the "funneling illusion." By stimulating two adjacent fingers simultaneously, a single tactile sensation is perceived in the gap between them. The study tested whether fMRI could resolve the resulting submillimeter shift in cortical activation corresponding to this perceived location.

Key Insights: Precision and Perception

The study yielded several groundbreaking findings that challenge traditional views of fMRI resolution:

  • Spatial Precision of Positive BOLD: At 9.4T, positive BOLD signals accurately reflect the ~1mm representations of individual fingerpads in area 3b. This suggests that the late positive BOLD signal is highly accurate at high field strengths, weakening the theory that only the "initial dip" provides spatial precision.
  • Mapping the "Mind's Finger": Most significantly, fMRI captured the neural correlates of the funneling illusion. When two fingers were stimulated, BOLD activation merged into a single focal point at a central site that received no physical stimulation. This demonstrates that BOLD reflects the perceived location of a stimulus, a product of complex neural processing.
  • Stability of Activation Centroids: While changing statistical thresholds altered the size of activation areas, the centroids (centers of activity) remained remarkably stable, facilitating precise mapping.

Results: Submillimeter Accuracy

The quantitative results underscore the system's high resolution:

  • Submillimeter Resolution: fMRI successfully resolved spatial shifts of less than 0.5 mm during the funneling illusion.
  • Cross-Modal Consistency: The average distance between fMRI and OIS activation centers for the same digit was only 0.14 mm, well within registration error margins.
  • Topographic Clarity: Peak-to-peak distances between adjacent digits (e.g., D2 to D3) averaged ~1.25 mm, which was clearly resolvable.

Limitations and Future Directions

Despite these successes, challenges remain. In areas adjacent to large blood vessels, slight spatial offsets between BOLD and OIS signals were still observed. Furthermore, the use of anesthesia, while necessary for stability, may alter neurovascular coupling.

Future research must determine if these submillimeter maps persist in awake, behaving primates and humans. Additionally, while 9.4T is standard for animal models, translating these results to 3T or 7T human clinical scanners is a critical next step for achieving "columnar-level" functional mapping in human subjects.

Summary updated

Abstract

Although blood oxygenation level-dependent (BOLD) functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) has been widely used to explore human brain function, questions remain regarding the ultimate spatial resolution of positive BOLD fMRI, and indeed the extent to which functional maps revealed by positive BOLD correlate spatially with maps obtained with other high-spatial-resolution mapping techniques commonly used in animals, such as optical imaging of intrinsic signal (OIS) and single-unit electrophysiology. Here, we demonstrate that the positive BOLD signal at 9.4T can reveal the fine topography of individual fingerpads in single-condition activation maps in nonhuman primates. These digit maps are similar to maps obtained from the same animal using intrinsic optical imaging. Furthermore, BOLD fMRI reliably resolved submillimeter spatial shifts in activation in area 3b previously identified with OIS (Chen et al., 2003) as neural correlates of the "funneling illusion." These data demonstrate that at high field, high-spatial-resolution topographic maps can be achieved using the positive BOLD signal, weakening previous notions regarding the spatial specificity of the positive BOLD signal.
BibTeX
@article{chen2007high,
  author = {Li M. Chen and Gregory Turner and Robert M. Friedman and Na Zhang and John C. Gore and Anna Wang Roe and Malcolm J. Avison},
  title = {{High-Resolution Maps of Real and Illusory Tactile Activation in Primary Somatosensory Cortex in Individual Monkeys with Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging and Optical Imaging}},
  journal = {Journal of Neuroscience},
  year = {2007},
  doi = {10.1523/jneurosci.1588-07.2007},
}
Figure