High-resolution mapping of combustion processes and implications for CO 2 emissions

Rong Wang, Shu Tao, Philippe Ciais, Huizhong Shen, Yufei Huang, Houyu Chen, Guofeng Shen, Bo Wang, Weiqi Li, Yanyan Zhang, Yan Lu, Dan Zhu, Y. C. Chen, X. P. Liu, W. T. Wang, X. L. Wang, W. X. Liu, B. G. Li, Shilong PiaoAtmospheric 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces PKU-FUEL and PKU-CO2, the first global, high-resolution (0.1° x 0.1°) inventories of fuel combustion and CO2 emissions, respectively. By employing a novel sub-national disaggregation method, they significantly reduce spatial biases in emission estimates compared to previous national-level approaches, offering crucial data for climate modeling and policy.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurate mapping of CO2 emissions is vital for understanding climate change, developing effective mitigation strategies, and interpreting atmospheric CO2 measurements. However, existing global emission inventories often suffer from coarse spatial resolution and rely on national-level data disaggregated using simple proxies like population density. This approach can distort the true geographical distribution of emissions within countries, especially in regions with significant internal variations in fuel consumption patterns (e.g., urban vs. rural, industrial vs. residential). This lack of fine-scale detail limits the accuracy of pollutant transport models, climate models, and the interpretation of atmospheric CO2 inversion studies. The paper aims to address this by creating a more detailed and spatially accurate global emission inventory.

Methods

The core innovation of this study is the Sub-national Disaggregation Method (SDM). Instead of using national totals and distributing them based on population density, the researchers utilized detailed fuel consumption data from sub-national administrative units (e.g., counties, states, provinces) for 45 countries. For countries lacking such detailed data, they employed various proxies and regression models.

Key methodological steps include:

  • Data Collection: Compiling fuel consumption data for 64 fuel sub-types across 6 sectors from various sources, including national statistics, industry reports, and scientific literature.
  • Sub-national Disaggregation: Applying the SDM to distribute national fuel data to finer spatial scales (0.1° x 0.1° grids) using detailed sub-national administrative unit data where available. For areas without sub-national data, they used proxies like population density, road networks, or CO emissions.
  • Emission Factor Application: Using compiled emission factors (EFs) for various fuel types and combustion processes to convert fuel consumption into CO2 emissions.
  • Uncertainty Quantification: Employing Monte Carlo simulations to estimate the uncertainties associated with the emission maps, providing both absolute and relative error metrics (R90 and R90/M).
  • Urban-Rural Contrast Analysis: Developing a method to differentiate between urban and rural grid points based on population density thresholds to analyze per capita emission differences.

Datasets

The study utilizes a wide array of datasets:

  • PKU-FUEL: A newly compiled global inventory of fuel consumption at 0.1° x 0.1° resolution for 2007.
  • PKU-CO2: The corresponding global CO2 emission inventory at 0.1° x 0.1° resolution for 2007, derived from PKU-FUEL.
  • National Fuel Consumption Data: From sources like the International Energy Agency (IEA), national statistical bureaus, and industry reports.
  • Sub-national Administrative Unit Data: For 45 countries, including county-level data for China and the USA, and state/province data for India, Brazil, Canada, Australia, Turkey, and South Africa.
  • Population Density Data: From sources like Oak Ridge National Laboratory's LandScan.
  • Nighttime Lights Data: From NOAA satellites, used for estimating natural gas flaring.
  • Wildfire Data: From GFED3 (Global Fire Emissions Database).
  • Power Plant Data: From the CARMA v2.0 database for major power stations.
  • CO Emission Maps: From EDGAR v4.2 and other sources, used as proxies for disaggregation.
  • Agricultural Production Data: From FAOSTAT.
  • Waste Generation Data: From UNSD.
  • CarbonTracker 2010: Net land-atmosphere CO2 flux data for terrestrial ecosystem flux calculations.

The paper introduces the PKU-FUEL and PKU-CO2 inventories as a significant advancement over previous global emission datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Sub-national Data is Crucial: The study strongly demonstrates that using sub-national fuel consumption data, rather than national averages, dramatically reduces spatial bias in CO2 emission maps. This is particularly important for countries with high internal heterogeneity in fuel use.
  • Urbanization Drives Emissions: A striking finding is the significant difference in per capita CO2 emissions between urban and rural areas in developing countries. This highlights urbanization as a major driver of future emission increases, a critical insight for climate policy.
  • Improved Uncertainty Estimates: The Monte Carlo simulations provide a robust quantification of uncertainties, showing that the sub-national approach significantly reduces the spread (uncertainty range) of gridded CO2 emissions.
  • Beyond Fossil Fuels: The inventory incorporates a comprehensive range of fuel types, including biomass and solid wastes, offering a more complete picture of combustion-related emissions.
  • Bridging the Gap for Inversions: The high-resolution PKU-CO2 inventory is directly applicable to improving the accuracy of terrestrial ecosystem CO2 flux estimates derived from atmospheric inversion models.

Key Results

  • Global CO2 Emissions: Estimated total CO2 emissions from combustion sources in 2007 were 11.2 Pg C yr⁻¹, with fossil fuels contributing 7.83 Pg C yr⁻¹ (closely matching IEA estimates).
  • Uncertainty Reduction: The average 95th minus 5th percentile range (R90) of CO2 emissions per grid cell was reduced from 417 Mg km⁻² yr⁻¹ (using national data) to 68.2 Mg km⁻² yr⁻¹ (using sub-national data).
  • Spatial Bias Reduction: Relative differences (RDs) between the sub-national (PKU-CO2) and national (NAT-CO2) disaggregated inventories ranged from 17.5% to 79.8% in countries with detailed sub-national data, indicating substantial bias reduction.
  • Urban vs. Rural Emissions: In developing countries, urban per capita CO2 emissions were 2.08 Mg C/(cap. × yr) compared to 0.598 Mg C/(cap. × yr) for rural areas. In developed countries, this difference was negligible (3.55 vs. 3.41 Mg C/(cap. × yr)).
  • Global Ecap: The median global per capita fossil fuel CO2 emission (Ecap) was 1.51 Mg C/(cap. × yr).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Availability: While the study significantly improved sub-national data coverage, it acknowledges that detailed sub-national fuel consumption data are still lacking for many countries.
  • Temporal Resolution: The current inventory is for the year 2007. Future work should focus on developing inventories with finer temporal resolutions (intra- and inter-annual) to capture dynamic emission changes.
  • Proxy Limitations: For countries without sub-national data, the accuracy of the disaggregation relies on the chosen proxies, which can still introduce some spatial bias.
  • Other Greenhouse Gases and Pollutants: The current inventory focuses on CO2. Future work could extend this methodology to other greenhouse gases and air pollutants.
  • Integration with Inversion Models: The paper suggests that future studies should integrate PKU-CO2 and its uncertainties directly into atmospheric inversion systems to improve terrestrial carbon flux estimates.
  • Reporting Standards: The authors recommend that large countries with significant per capita fuel consumption differences should be encouraged to report sub-national data for more accurate IPCC GHG reporting.

Summary updated

Abstract

High-resolution mapping of fuel combustion and CO2 emission provides valuable information for modeling pollutant transport, developing mitigation policy, and for inverse modeling of CO2 fluxes. Previous global emission maps included only few fuel types, and emissions were estimated on a grid by distributing national fuel data on an equal per capita basis, using population density maps. This process distorts the geographical distribution of emissions within countries. In this study, a sub-national disaggregation method (SDM) of fuel data is applied to establish a global 0.1° × 0.1° geo-referenced inventory of fuel combustion (PKU-FUEL) and corresponding CO2 emissions (PKU-CO2) based upon 64 fuel sub-types for the year 2007. Uncertainties of the emission maps are evaluated using a Monte Carlo method. It is estimated that CO2 emission from combustion sources including fossil fuel, biomass, and solid wastes in 2007 was 11.2 Pg C yr−1 (9.1 Pg C yr−1 and 13.3 Pg C yr−1 as 5th and 95th percentiles). Of this, emission from fossil fuel combustion is 7.83 Pg C yr−1, which is very close to the estimate of the International Energy Agency (7.87 Pg C yr−1). By replacing national data disaggregation with sub-national data in this study, the average 95th minus 5th percentile ranges of CO2 emission for all grid points can be reduced from 417 to 68.2 Mg km−2 yr−1. The spread is reduced because the uneven distribution of per capita fuel consumptions within countries is better taken into account by using sub-national fuel consumption data directly. Significant difference in per capita CO2 emissions between urban and rural areas was found in developing countries (2.08 vs. 0.598 Mg C/(cap. × yr)), but not in developed countries (3.55 vs. 3.41 Mg C/(cap. × yr)). This implies that rapid urbanization of developing countries is very likely to drive up their emissions in the future.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2013high,
  author = {Rong Wang and Shu Tao and Philippe Ciais and Huizhong Shen and Yufei Huang and Houyu Chen and Guofeng Shen and Bo Wang and Weiqi Li and Yanyan Zhang and Yan Lu and Dan Zhu and Y. C. Chen and X. P. Liu and W. T. Wang and X. L. Wang and W. X. Liu and B. G. Li and Shilong Piao},
  title = {{High-resolution mapping of combustion processes and implications for CO <sub>2</sub> emissions}},
  booktitle = {Atmospheric},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.5194/acp-13-5189-2013},
}
Figure