High-resolution mapping of cell cycle dynamics during T-cell development and regeneration in vivo

Heike Kunze‐Schumacher, Nikita A. Verheyden, Zoe Grewers, Michael Meyer‐Hermann, Victor Greiff, Philippe A. Robert, Andreas KruegerbioRxiv 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper provides a high-resolution map of cell cycle dynamics during T-cell development and regeneration in vivo, revealing that cell cycle acceleration is achieved by proportionally shortening both G1 and S phases. They also developed an agent-based model to integrate experimental data and explore cell cycle heterogeneity, offering a framework applicable to other biological systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how cells control their proliferation is fundamental to biology, especially for immune cells that undergo massive expansion. While we know that T-cell development in the thymus involves periods of rapid proliferation, the precise control mechanisms and how cell cycle dynamics change at different developmental stages remain largely unknown. Specifically, how thymocytes adjust their cell cycle length during development and in response to perturbations like regeneration after irradiation is not well understood. This paper aims to fill this knowledge gap by providing a detailed, quantitative map of cell cycle phase durations across various T-cell developmental stages and during thymus regeneration.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach combining experimental techniques and computational modeling:

  • In vivo dual-nucleoside pulse labeling (EdU and BrdU): This technique involves administering two different DNA synthesis markers (EdU and BrdU) at distinct time points. By analyzing the incorporation patterns of these markers, they could precisely track cells entering and exiting S phase, allowing for the determination of S-phase duration and entry/exit rates.
  • Fluorescent Ubiquitination-based Cell Cycle Indicator (FUCCI) mice: These transgenic mice express fluorescent proteins that change color depending on the cell cycle phase (e.g., green in S phase, orange in G1). This allowed for real-time visualization and quantification of cell cycle phase distribution within different thymocyte populations.
  • Agent-Based Mathematical Model (ABM): To integrate the complex experimental data and account for cell cycle heterogeneity, the authors developed an ABM. This model simulates individual cells progressing through cell cycle phases (G1, S, G2/M) with defined durations and death rates. The model was used to estimate phase durations, explore different hypotheses of cell cycle heterogeneity, and predict how cell cycle dynamics change under various conditions.

Datasets

The study utilized data from experiments performed on murine (mouse) thymocytes. Specifically, they used:

  • Wild-type (WT) C57BL/6J mice.
  • FUCCI transgenic mice.

The experimental data generated from these mice, including flow cytometry data from pulse-labeling and FUCCI reporter expression, served as the basis for parameter estimation and validation of the mathematical model. No new public datasets were introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Stretch Model" of Proliferation: The paper provides strong evidence that T-cell proliferation during development is regulated by a "stretch model." This means that to accelerate cell division, thymocytes don't just shorten one phase; they proportionally contract both G1 and S phases. This is a key insight into how rapid expansion is achieved without compromising DNA replication fidelity.
  • Cell Cycle Heterogeneity is Primarily in G1: While all cell cycle phases can vary, the ABM analysis strongly suggests that the most significant source of cell cycle heterogeneity within thymocyte populations lies in the duration of the G1 phase. This has implications for understanding how different cells within a seemingly homogeneous population can have distinct proliferative behaviors.
  • Regeneration Modulates G1, Not S: During thymus regeneration after irradiation, thymocytes don't necessarily speed up their entire cell cycle. Instead, the study found that G1 phase duration is significantly shortened, while S phase duration remains relatively constant or even slightly increases. This suggests that regeneration is primarily driven by faster entry into the cell cycle, rather than faster DNA replication itself.
  • A Versatile Modeling Framework: The development of the ABM provides a powerful tool for integrating complex experimental data and testing hypotheses about cell cycle dynamics. The authors propose this combined experimental-computational approach is broadly applicable to other organ systems and disease conditions.

Key Results

  • High-Resolution Cell Cycle Mapping: The study successfully mapped cell cycle phase durations for various thymocyte subpopulations at steady-state, revealing significant differences in cycling times. For example, DN3b and DN4 cells exhibited the shortest cell cycle durations (around 8-12 hours), while DN1 and DN3a cells had longer cycles (around 36-47 hours).
  • S-Phase Duration: S-phase durations were found to be relatively consistent across most populations, typically ranging from 5.5 to 9.5 hours.
  • G1 Phase Variation: G1 phase durations showed substantial variability, ranging from as short as 2.8 hours in DN4 cells to over 30 hours in DN3a cells. The ABM analysis indicated that a significant portion of cells in some populations are "long G1" cells, meaning they spend a prolonged period in G1.
  • Regeneration Effects: During thymus regeneration, total cell cycle length was reduced, primarily due to a significant shortening of the G1 phase across most populations. S-phase duration was largely unaffected.
  • Model Validation: The ABM accurately reproduced experimental data and provided insights into cell cycle heterogeneity, particularly highlighting the variability in G1 phase duration.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Murine vs. Human Thymocytes: The study focused on murine thymocytes. While the principles are likely conserved, obtaining similar high-resolution data for human thymocytes remains a technical challenge. Future work could explore organoid technologies to address this.
  • Model Complexity and Time Windows: The ABM, while powerful, has limitations. Simulating long time windows can introduce discrepancies, and the model's ability to capture all biological complexity is inherently limited. The authors acknowledge the challenge of simulating T-cell development in its entirety.
  • Non-Steady-State Conditions: During thymus regeneration, populations are dynamically changing in size, which deviates from the steady-state conditions assumed by the model. Further adaptations to account for non-equilibrium effects would be beneficial, especially for applications in rapidly growing populations like cancer.
  • Defining Transitions: It remains unclear whether thymocyte populations transition to subsequent developmental stages at defined cell cycle phases. This is a complex question due to the nature of marker-defined populations not always reflecting true biological state transitions.
  • Functional Heterogeneity: The observed cell cycle heterogeneity might stem from functional differences within phenotypically identical populations or unequal access to growth factors. Further investigation into these possibilities is warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Control of cell proliferation is critical for the lymphocyte life cycle. However, little is known on how stage-specific alterations in cell cycle behavior drive proliferation dynamics during T-cell development. Here, we employed in vivo dual-nucleoside pulse labeling combined with determination of DNA replication over time as well as fluorescent ubiquitination-based cell cycle indicator mice to establish a quantitative high-resolution map of cell cycle kinetics of thymocytes. We developed an agent-based mathematical model of T-cell developmental dynamics. To generate the capacity for proliferative bursts, cell cycle acceleration followed a ‘stretch model’, characterized by simultaneous and proportional contraction of both G1 and S phase. Analysis of cell cycle phase dynamics during regeneration showed tailored adjustments of cell cycle phase dynamics. Taken together, our results highlight intrathymic cell cycle regulation as an adjustable system to maintain physiologic tissue homeostasis and foster our understanding of dysregulation of the T-cell developmental program.
BibTeX
@misc{kunzeschumacher2023high,
  author = {Heike Kunze‐Schumacher and Nikita A. Verheyden and Zoe Grewers and Michael Meyer‐Hermann and Victor Greiff and Philippe A. Robert and Andreas Krueger},
  title = {{High-resolution mapping of cell cycle dynamics during T-cell development and regeneration <i>in vivo</i>}},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1101/2023.06.14.544919},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure