High-Resolution Copy-Number Variation Map Reflects Human Olfactory Receptor Diversity and Evolution

Yehudit Hasin-Brumshtein, Tsviya Olender, Miriam Khen, Claudia Gonzaga‐Jauregui, Philip M. Kim, Alexander E. Urban, M Snyder, Mark Gerstein, Doron Lancet, Jan O. KorbelPLoS 2008 · DOI

Abstract

Olfactory receptors (ORs) constitute the largest mammalian protein superfamily, yet the human repertoire is significantly reduced, with approximately 55% of the genes existing as non-functional pseudogenes. This study utilizes high-resolution oligonucleotide tiling microarrays to map copy-number variations (CNVs) across 851 OR loci in 25 individuals. We identified 93 intact OR genes and 151 pseudogenes affected by CNVs, revealing a complex "mosaic" of gene dosages across the population. Our findings indicate that CNVs are more prevalent in pseudogenes and evolutionarily "young" ORs. Furthermore, we identified nine common human-derived deletion alleles, suggesting that structural variation is a primary driver of the ongoing divergence and diminution of the human sense of smell.

Introduction: The Genetic Basis of Sensory Diversity

Human olfactory perception is notoriously subjective; what one person finds fragrant, another may find repulsive or undetectable. While much research has focused on single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), these small-scale changes often fail to explain the full breadth of phenotypic variation. Recent evidence suggests that larger structural changes—Copy-Number Variations (CNVs)—play a more significant role. CNVs involve the deletion or duplication of entire gene sequences, directly altering the "dosage" of receptors available to detect specific odorants.

Previous studies of the human OR repertoire were limited by low resolution, often grouping genes into broad clusters. This research provides a high-resolution map of OR CNVs, aiming to clarify how these structural shifts influence human evolution and sensory diversity.

Methodology

To achieve a high-resolution view of the OR landscape, researchers employed several advanced techniques:

  • Oligonucleotide Tiling Microarrays: A custom array with ~72,000 probes was used to interrogate 851 OR loci at a 1 kb resolution across 25 individuals from diverse ancestral backgrounds (European, Asian, and African).
  • BreakPtr Algorithm: This computational tool was used to identify the precise genomic breakpoints of DNA gains and losses.
  • Validation via qPCR: Findings were rigorously validated using quantitative PCR (qPCR) on 122 sampled ORs, ensuring a low false-positive rate (<4%).
  • Comparative Genomics: Human data were compared against the chimpanzee reference genome to distinguish ancestral states from human-specific evolutionary changes.

The Olfactory Mosaic: Key Results

The study revealed that nearly 28% of the human OR repertoire (244 loci) is copy-number variable. This variation creates a unique genetic "fingerprint" for every individual, where the number of functional copies for any given receptor can vary from zero to multiple.

Heatmap of CNVs across 851 OR loci in 25 individuals. Red indicates gains, blue indicates losses, and green indicates the normal diploid state.

As shown in the figure above, these variations are distributed across the genome, with significant clusters on specific chromosomes (notably chromosome 11). Approximately half of the detected CNVs involve more than one OR gene, with the largest single variation spanning 11 different loci.

Evolutionary Insights: A Shrinking Repertoire

The distribution of CNVs provides a window into human evolution. The researchers found that CNVs are significantly more frequent in pseudogenes than in intact genes. This suggests that natural selection continues to purge deleterious deletions in essential functional receptors while allowing variation to accumulate in "genomic fossils."

Interestingly, ORs that lack a one-to-one ortholog in chimpanzees—considered evolutionarily "younger" genes—showed a higher frequency of CNVs. In these genes, there was a marked bias toward losses (deletions) over gains. The study identified nine common deletion alleles affecting 15 OR genes; comparison with the chimpanzee genome confirmed that all these deletions are human-derived. This structural downsizing likely explains the historical reduction of the human olfactory repertoire compared to other mammals.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This high-resolution map confirms that humans possess a mosaic of smell receptors, providing a structural explanation for individual differences in odor perception. While the study establishes a clear link between CNVs and OR diversity, the "phenotype gap" remains. Future research must connect these specific gene deletions to actual sensory experiences—determining, for instance, if the loss of a specific gene cluster directly results in "anosmia" (smell blindness) for certain chemical compounds. These findings lay the groundwork for large-scale association studies to bridge the gap between our genetic code and our sensory world.

Reference: Hasin Y, Olender T, Khen M, et al. (2008) High-Resolution Copy-Number Variation Map Reflects Human Olfactory Receptor Diversity and Evolution. PLoS Genet 4(11): e1000249.

Summary updated

Abstract

Olfactory receptors (ORs), which are involved in odorant recognition, form the largest mammalian protein superfamily. The genomic content of OR genes is considerably reduced in humans, as reflected by the relatively small repertoire size and the high fraction ( approximately 55%) of human pseudogenes. Since several recent low-resolution surveys suggested that OR genomic loci are frequently affected by copy-number variants (CNVs), we hypothesized that CNVs may play an important role in the evolution of the human olfactory repertoire. We used high-resolution oligonucleotide tiling microarrays to detect CNVs across 851 OR gene and pseudogene loci. Examining genomic DNA from 25 individuals with ancestry from three populations, we identified 93 OR gene loci and 151 pseudogene loci affected by CNVs, generating a mosaic of OR dosages across persons. Our data suggest that approximately 50% of the CNVs involve more than one OR, with the largest CNV spanning 11 loci. In contrast to earlier reports, we observe that CNVs are more frequent among OR pseudogenes than among intact genes, presumably due to both selective constraints and CNV formation biases. Furthermore, our results show an enrichment of CNVs among ORs with a close human paralog or lacking a one-to-one ortholog in chimpanzee. Interestingly, among the latter we observed an enrichment in CNV losses over gains, a finding potentially related to the known diminution of the human OR repertoire. Quantitative PCR experiments performed for 122 sampled ORs agreed well with the microarray results and uncovered 23 additional CNVs. Importantly, these experiments allowed us to uncover nine common deletion alleles that affect 15 OR genes and five pseudogenes. Comparison to the chimpanzee reference genome revealed that all of the deletion alleles are human derived, therefore indicating a profound effect of human-specific deletions on the individual OR gene content. Furthermore, these deletion alleles may be used in future genetic association studies of olfactory inter-individual differences.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hasinbrumshtein2008high,
  author = {Yehudit Hasin-Brumshtein and Tsviya Olender and Miriam Khen and Claudia Gonzaga‐Jauregui and Philip M. Kim and Alexander E. Urban and M Snyder and Mark Gerstein and Doron Lancet and Jan O. Korbel},
  title = {{High-Resolution Copy-Number Variation Map Reflects Human Olfactory Receptor Diversity and Evolution}},
  booktitle = {PLoS},
  year = {2008},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pgen.1000249},
}
Figure