High Precision Results for Top-Quark Decay at N3LO in QCD

Long Chen, Xiang Chen, Xin Guan, Yan-Qing Ma2024 · DOI

Abstract

In this talk we present the first complete high-precision results for the top-quark $t$ decay width $\Gamma_t$, $W$-helicity fractions and semi-inclusive distributions for the $t$-decay process to the third order in the strong coupling constant $\alpha_s$. Our investigation reveals that the pure $\mathcal{O}(\alpha_s^3)$ correction decreases $\Gamma_t$ by $0.8\%$ of the previous $\mathcal{O}(\alpha_s^2)$ result, which exceeds the error estimated by the conventional scale-variation. With this critical piece of pertubative correction incorporated, our to-date most precise theoretical prediction meets the request by future high-energy colliders.

Introduction

The top quark is the heaviest fundamental particle known, serving as a critical laboratory for testing the Standard Model and searching for new physics. A fundamental property of the top quark is its decay width ($\Gamma_t$), a measure of its lifetime. As we look toward future "Higgs factories" and high-energy colliders like the CEPC or CLIC, experimental precision is expected to reach the 20–26 MeV range. To interpret such precise data, theoretical predictions must achieve even higher accuracy—ideally with uncertainties half as large as the experimental ones. This research pushes the theoretical boundary from Next-to-Next-to-Leading Order (NNLO) to Next-to-Next-to-Next-to-Leading Order ($N^3LO$) to ensure theory keeps pace with future experimental capabilities.

Methodology

Calculating physics at the $N^3LO$ level is notoriously difficult due to the complexity of three-loop virtual corrections and real radiation. The researchers employed several sophisticated mathematical techniques to achieve these results:

  • Dimensional Regularization (DR): A standard method to handle mathematical singularities in quantum field theory.
  • Integration-By-Parts (IBP) Reduction: A technique used to reduce thousands of complex integrals into a small set of "master integrals."
  • Differential Equation Method & AMFlow: The team utilized the AMFlow software package to solve boundary conditions for differential equations, allowing for high-precision numerical results for the master integrals.
  • Frobenius Series Solutions: Employed to handle phase-space integration over infrared-sensitive regions where particles are emitted with very low energy or nearly parallel to each other.

Input parameters were sourced from the Particle Data Group (PDG), including a top-quark mass of $m_t = 172.69 \pm 0.30$ GeV, the Fermi constant ($G_F$), and the $W$-boson mass ($m_W$).

Key Insights and Ideas

The "Scale Variation" Trap and Convergence

In theoretical physics, researchers often estimate the error of a calculation by varying the renormalization scale ($\mu$). This study reveals that the $N^3LO$ correction shifted the result by 0.8%, which was significantly larger than the error predicted by the previous NNLO scale variation. This finding demonstrates that conventional scale variation can underestimate theoretical uncertainty.

Top decay width $\Gamma_t$ as a function of the renormalization scale $\mu/m_t$ at different perturbative orders. The NNNLO result (red) shows a distinct shift from the NNLO (green) prediction.

Furthermore, the perturbative series for the top-quark decay width shows signs of deterioration at higher orders, likely due to "infrared-renormalon" sensitivity associated with the definition of the quark's mass.

W-Boson Energy Distribution

The study provides a detailed look at the energy distribution of the $W$-boson during decay. The researchers found that QCD corrections are non-uniform across the spectrum, becoming particularly sizable (7–14%) at the high-energy end.

The $W$-boson energy distribution and its ratio to NLO. The bottom panel highlights how higher-order corrections (NNLO and NNNLO) significantly impact the high-energy tail of the distribution.

Key Results

The paper provides the most precise theoretical values to date for top-quark decay:

  • Total Decay Width: $\Gamma_t = 1.3148^{+0.003}_{-0.005}$ GeV (assuming $|V_{tb}| = 1$).
  • W-Helicity Fractions: These describe the polarization states of the $W$-boson produced in the decay. The results at $N^3LO$ are:
  • Longitudinal ($f_0$): $0.686$
    • Left-handed ($f_L$): $0.312$
    • Right-handed ($f_R$): $0.00157$

These results meet the precision requirements for future colliders, ensuring that future measurements can effectively distinguish between Standard Model behavior and potential new physics.

Future Outlook

Despite this breakthrough, challenges remain. The fixed-order prediction breaks down at the extreme edge of the energy spectrum, requiring averaging over a 1 GeV bin in that region. Future work will focus on a full $N^3LO$ calculation that includes a massive $b$-quark and moving toward "fully differential" calculations. Such advancements will allow for even more detailed comparisons with experimental detector data.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this talk we present the first complete high-precision results for the top-quark $t$ decay width $\Gamma_t$, $W$-helicity fractions and semi-inclusive distributions for the $t$-decay process to the third order in the strong coupling constant $\alpha_s$. Our investigation reveals that the pure $\mathcal{O}(\alpha_s^3)$ correction decreases $\Gamma_t$ by $0.8\%$ of the previous $\mathcal{O}(\alpha_s^2)$ result, which exceeds the error estimated by the conventional scale-variation. With this critical piece of pertubative correction incorporated, our to-date most precise theoretical prediction meets the request by future high-energy colliders.
BibTeX
@misc{chen2024high,
  author = {Long Chen and Xiang Chen and Xin Guan and Yan-Qing Ma},
  title = {{High Precision Results for Top-Quark Decay at N3LO in QCD}},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.22323/1.476.0381},
}
Figure